The Settlement [Concluded]

[TinCow]

Please can Captain Blackadder be lynched before me? He posted a fake role PM that two other people received...

To make sure this is clear, Captain Blackadder's role PM isn't fake, it's just his cover role PM, not his actual role PM. That priest role PM was given to both Jolt and Yoyoma as their 'cover' role PMs, so there's no reason to suspect that others wouldn't have it as well. However, it does very strongly indicate that Blackadder has only disclosed his 'cover' role PM, and not his real one.

In other news, Iffo is likely to be randomly assigned to a living player so watch out for that.

Explain why you said this. LG's role PM stated that Iffo had been "bound... to charity." That seems to me like it was a person who would otherwise look like they had a 'power' pro-town role, but who would then flip to scum after The Watcher died.

Captain Blackadder claims to be a Priest of OsiOsi. Every single other priest and god-related role we've seen has had night abilities of some kind. Blackadder claims no night abilities at all. What are the odds that we've got an actual Priest of OsiOsi that's not capable of aiding the town in any way?

[Captain Blackadder]

I have being thinking it over and I have realised that I need to die quickly. I have no other role apart from the priest of OsiOsi but it is implied that the person who is Iffo does not know they are Iffo but will turn to Iffo at some point in the game now if I die now I can still win since my role pm is as it says above is to outlast the usurpers but if I turn to Iffo I will lose since I will soon be killed off. But all this does not matter since pisuf an old god will easily be able to out dual me with my rating of 1

[FactionHeir]

Explain why you said this. LG's role PM stated that Iffo had been "bound... to charity." That seems to me like it was a person who would otherwise look like they had a 'power' pro-town role, but who would then flip to scum after The Watcher died.

Captain Blackadder claims to be a Priest of OsiOsi. Every single other priest and god-related role we've seen has had night abilities of some kind. Blackadder claims no night abilities at all. What are the odds that we've got an actual Priest of OsiOsi that's not capable of aiding the town in any way?

Read the night writeup. Iffo is FREE as the watcher died.

And I think its very peculiar that Tristan out of a sudden stopped lurking and actually started posting and asking to get someone lynched.

big FoS on Tristan

[_Tristan_]

big FoS on Tristan

Have I been lurking ? I don't think so...

I have always explained why I voted for certain people and tried to find explanations in the write-ups that might lead us closer to unmaking the usurpers.

I know some people can vouch for me but I don't think it is necessary at this point...

[CountArach]

And I think its very peculiar that Tristan out of a sudden stopped lurking and actually started posting and asking to get someone lynched.

big FoS on Tristan

I investigated him last night - he is innocent. He does, however, have the ability to tamper with the votes:
"Vote Tampering: Every day, before voting ends, you may tamper with the vote count, adding one tally to a settler of your choice and removing one tally from a settler of your choice."

[LittleGrizzly]

Well theres the man that killed TC...

I made the priest bound to charity link as well... i think its more likely than the beggar theory.. though i guess it works from the other way around...

I would like to point out for the CA case his 3rd person has not come forward!!!

This leads me to believe that this 3rd person nows of his guilt, we should lynch jolt first but CA should be the next lynch imo...

Even if we just lynch him once while someone investigates and trys to find Iffo...

bit of a rush ill make a bigger post when i get home...

[Jolt]

Town, DO NOT use Pisuf to kill anyone. Someone in the thread has caught spot-on what will happen if he does. If you use Pisuf to murder at his will, you WILL lose town.

[Captain Blackadder]

What evidence do you have for this I think the same thing but I only have my gut to tell me this what do you have?

[TinCow]

Pisuf still must be lynched (twice), but unfortunately we have to deal with Jolt first. With CA and CB dueling today, we will also know quickly whether CB is Iffo. If he is and dies, then we just get to work on double-lynching CA tomorrow. If CB is Iffo and kills CA, then we just lynch CB. If CB is not Iffo and CA kills him, then we get to work lynching CA tomorrow while continuing to search for Iffo.

[CountArach]

I would like to point out for the CA case his 3rd person has not come forward!!!

Yes he has... it is Yoyoma... He sent my role PM to GH who then confirmed me innocent.

[boudica]

Yes he has... it is Yoyoma... He sent my role PM to GH who then confirmed me innocent.

Hold on - at what point were you confirmed innocent? - quote please. As far as I am aware you rejected the opportunity to work on behalf of town and are simply following your own - essentially serial killer - victory conditions. Sure - you're not mafia - but you're not pro-town either and therefore hardly innocent.

[_Tristan_]

I investigated him last night - he is innocent. He does, however, have the ability to tamper with the votes:
"Vote Tampering: Every day, before voting ends, you may tamper with the vote count, adding one tally to a settler of your choice and removing one tally from a settler of your choice."

And what exactly is the point of exposing me like that ?

Aside from putting a bull's eye on my forehead for any usurper still alive..

[TinCow]

And what exactly is the point of exposing me like that ?

Aside from putting a bull's eye on my forehead for any usurper still alive..

He's doing everything he can to direct attention at people other than himself. He knows that his ability to survive his first lynching puts him in a very good spot to win. If he can get someone else lynched tomorrow other than himself, he could very well give up any pretenses at being pro-town and simply start killing us because we wouldn't be able to lynch him twice before he won.

[Captain Blackadder]

Hello Captain Blackadder, thanks for playing

If thou ever feeleth the desire to striketh another, restrain thyself and burneth a pound of meat to OsiOsi. He will allow thee to bed the wife of thee enemy.

A priest's sermon

You are a Priest

Background:

There are a two prerequisites for becoming a priest:

1) Being old
2) Being a virgin

After that you can worship the gods all the time instead of just on weekends!

Battle Rating:

1 – Devoting yourself to the rituals of the gods leaves little time for military training. The strongest man is the one with the strongest faith as you say.

Victory Conditions:

Outlast the usurpers (settler victory)

Sorry about this I didn't realise how to get hte message in fully with all original formatting. Allthough I suspect it is too late now.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

hmm, thing is, when FH investigated me he saw through my cover role. But with blackadder he saw him as a priest. Was there anyone who just had a basic pm with no cover role, and that pm was used as a cover role by a power character?

I might be best to not do the duel, and have CA challange taka instead.

[boudica]

So is there not still a case to lynch CA once today and leave Jolt til later?... I haven't done the maths, but we know Jolt can be blocked, whereas didn't Pisuf evade the roleblock back near the beginning?
atm Jolt cannot win - we have him as good as in chains - but Pisuf is too much of a liability. If we lynch him for the first time today, he can still kill Blackadder in the duel (who I actually believe for the moment - the Iffo situation is too hairy to do nothing, but still very much an unknown quantity) and CA becomes far more manageable when brought closer to mortality.

unvote: vote: CountArach

[TinCow]

So is there not still a case to lynch CA once today and leave Jolt til later?... I haven't done the maths, but we know Jolt can be blocked, whereas didn't Pisuf evade the roleblock back near the beginning?
atm Jolt cannot win - we have him as good as in chains - but Pisuf is too much of a liability. If we lynch him for the first time today, he can still kill Blackadder in the duel (who I actually believe for the moment - the Iffo situation is too hairy to do nothing, but still very much an unknown quantity) and CA becomes far more manageable when brought closer to mortality.

unvote: vote: CountArach

This is a strong argument and one that should be considered. Jolt CAN be blocked. We've seen this happen and it works. CA CANNOT be blocked, we've also seen this happen.