The fight for Inishmore [Concluded]

[Andres]

No zombie cow is a match for us mafiosos...

A confession?

[Beefy187]

Now that I'm dead, I want the Irish mafia to win this, although I want Brendan to survive as long as he can.

As for betting, my moneys on the towns victory.. Lets have a two games in a row for the towns

[Ituralde]

So Padraic was AVSM? Since AVSM was also mentioned in the writeup.

And what's up with everybody claiming to be mafia, Sasaki being the last to do so. Has WIFOM become that popular?

[Yoyoma1910]

I knew it!



Hah, Who's making groceries now!

[Andres]

Vote: taka

Only 2 of your 9 posts have occurred since actual play began. One informing us you read the opening post and the other saying there's been a lot of blather going on. The last one IS a fair comment, but this is shaping up into another lurk -- and I will not have it.

You should know by now that taka always lurks. It's not necessarily suspicious behaviour for him.

I hear I am tied with beefy to be lynched, I would rather not be lynched. So

Vote: Beefy

Out of curiosity, who told you to get over here and vote?

[gaelic cowboy]

As my dear mum is fond of saying to my father when he asks what for dinner

Pat: "Mairead whats for dinner"

Mairead: "Daft I call it

Translate It has no meaning but it stops questions

This tatic I have been thinking this WIFOM is popular because the town will be unable to act but the truth is the two mafia can ascertain all just from inaction.

I guess I am only new I could be wrong.

Now I have to log off have a shower go to college for scummy lectures on mechanics

Think were finishing a question stress in the frame of a bike.

Town is only down only one I bet everyone is down one.

more later.

[Reenk Roink]

Vote: Sasaki Kojiro

[boudica]

vote: Reenk Roink - (why believe one WIFOMmer and not the other? - that's politics that is)

[FactionHeir]

Vote Oink because you were the first to claim killing ability.

[Andres]

Vote : Seamus

I don't like your reasoning for voting taka.

[Greyblades]

3 Mafia (IRA)
3 Mafia (English)
3 Pro Town
2 other roles.

No suicide roles.

Looking back on this I think I can guess most of the roles we are dealing with.
Its safe to say that each mafia group has 1 godfather and 2, probably ordinary, goons.

(as for that though, the GodF will die.)

(Thank you beefy for getting the hosts confirmation)
Each group seems to have one kill per night. If they had more there would be less players left by now. Allthough I'm not sure why only one group killed on the opening writeup...

This is going on assumption and guess work but the pro-town roles are probably the standard layout: one investigator, one doctor, and one vigilante. Seeing as this is a realistic game, the doctor's not one of ATPG's resurrection doctors. (Yes I did read the Full monty mafia game. Wow that was a mash up; 2 resurrection roles and a zombie maker in one game.)

According to the host there are 2 other roles. Seeing that there have only been at most 2 kills a night I am willing to assume that they are not psychopaths, allthough I could be wrong. Maybe a mason group?: one recruiter and one starting convert perhaps?

[Jolt]

Bleh. The Mafia really like to kill me. Was it because I was a Irish martian?

[Yoyoma1910]

Vote:Reenk


For saying there will be blood last night.

[Andres]

This Reenk bandwagon is really silly.

[Yoyoma1910]

A) Who says it's a bandwagon? Two people have voted for him.


B) He said this:

Beefy has died early now in both games!

Tonight blood will be spilled...

[Andres]

And that's a good reason to lynch Reenk Roink?

[Reenk Roink]

Obviously Mafia are much more likely to pick easy scapegoats. Statements like Yoyoma's are what I expect from SOME Mafia.

Yoyoma is probably Mafia (for real too, not a YLC or Sasaki thing)

Unvote: Sasaki
Vote: Yoyoma

You will die. Somehow...

[F.C is the bees knees]

Vote Taka because i feel like it plus i'm good at guessing.

[Jolt]

You will die. Somehow...

It is the nature of things. He will die in the future for sure. He certainly already has had more time to live.

[Greyblades]

Vote: Reenk
Death threats are just rude.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Vote:Abstain, Courteously

Death threats are just rude.

Rude = mafia??

[Reenk Roink]

A question to all those who are voting for me now. Why not state these reasons before? I made them a long time ago, yet I was not questioned until now? Do you realize how bad that makes you look?

Seems like some Mafia have already bitten...

[ULC]

Hmmm...No, Yoyoma, at most, is a grunt, not a Godfather, Reenk, so he is secondary. I'm fairly sure one of you TWC guys is a Godfather however, and if we assume Reenk's case is true, therefore knows Yoyoma and picked him.

Vote: Yoyoma for now, until I have gone through the list of players and picked out my target.

Also, WIFOM is for the Lazy, since one can make a WIFOM statement out of anything - if your actualy trying to deduce somehting, then you will see the WIFOM disappear - Occams Razor for all (though don't make it to sharp, or you'll cut yourself)

[Reenk Roink]

Occams Razor is the worst postulate ever. It has no epistemic merit, yet I still see it used. I don't mind as much in unimportant things, but in Mafia games!

I present you Reenk's Razor:

Multiply entities as much as possible as the most complex explanation is usually the right one

[Greyblades]

Rude = mafia??

It was a joke. Besides, why would a townie threaten someone with death?

[Reenk Roink]

It was a joke. Besides, why would a townie threaten someone with death?

I'm not a townie! And again, killing is only bad if a bad guy does it.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

It was a joke. Besides, why would a townie threaten someone?

It doesn't count as a joke when paired with a vote. But you give you real reason here I see.

VV Isn't it a little early to be giving up? Don't like it...

[Reenk Roink]

Come on, don't lynch me.


Well this plan failed...

[Greyblades]

It was the Death threats are just rude. that was a joke.

[Reenk Roink]

VV Isn't it a little early to be giving up? Don't like it...

Not giving up, just pretending to give up to push some emotional buttons and get some unvotes.