Ok here's my example.( V 1.2 btw) Im Rome fighting a counter action against Ptolomy after a sneak attack by them. I have about 2/3 of a very good legion in the Desert and they catch a Machimoi Native Phalanx on his lonesome. I decide to fight the battle (been having some very silly results with a couple of auto resolves).
Right. I wander up to the sole unit with my Army, and they just stand there, of course. So I bait them with Velites, and they start that slow annoting walk. So here's what I did. I got the Phalanx to circle my units, while I individually controlled each one and had them throw pila from the right hand side (no shield) or slightly behind. I even followed them from behind with 2 units of well promoted Archers, controlling their "fire at will".
Thats a heck of a lot of pilae and arrows. And you know what? When every single missile had been
spent, there was still almost half their unit left!! (Of course they then routed instantly when charged).
I know all about hammer and anvil tactics against Long Spears, and they work very well thank you.
But my point is, the 2 units of Archers should have kill just about all of them. I've no complaints about a phalanx being nails tough from the front, but all these missiles were from behind.?! If you are shot in the back with an arrow at point blank range, you are going down. Just because you have a long pointy stick held in the opposite direction, and are walking in close mass in a slow zombie way towards the enemy, doesn't give you magical protection where you have none. Heck, in fact because the men in the unit are packed tight together, they make an even more unmissable target from behind. I've started to wonder if all my Creten Merc Archers are just a fancy, expensive waste of money.
Ah, well still a magnificent game, it's destroyed any sleep pattern I never really had in the last week or so ;)
Comments and thoughts appreciated.
Bookmarks