Swords in the Moon [Concluded]

[Louis VI the Fat]

The ninjas are clever. By attacking two names from the list, they increased the chance of the town lynching an innocent today. Not, however, as clever as they may had hoped: by their very act of attacking both BQ and two names from the list, the ninjas showed to all that BQ's reveal was genuine.

There would've been attacks on innocents anyway. Making last night's ninja actions a net plus for the town: we would've lost to kills anyway, but now we know the list to be genuine.

Furthermore, I think it was a good idea to make the list public. The scum by definition knew who was innocent, whereas we did not. Pity that BQ couldn't be protected.


In the absense of anything remotely resembling a case, maybe Wishazu would make a decent lynch target.

Possibly he wasn't paying close attention when he both voted Beskar and challenged GH, both innocent. Possibly, he was. However that may be, lynching him will prevent his duel with innocent GeneralHankerchief.

But, that will leave GH v Beskar as today's sole challenge. Innocent v innocent. So lynching Wishazu is only sensible when there are other challenges around - lest we be sure that an innocent will die in a duel. I would propose some challenges on possible suspects today. Currently, of the four dueling players, three are innocent. So if you have always wanted to make a challenge, today would be the right time methinks.