Swords in the Moon [Concluded]

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Dutch guy is acting normal, which makes GH suspicious I guess. Though there isn't much to go on this game. Beskar should still be lynched just because.

[Dutch_guy]

I can't defend myself against a bandwagon, as that's what this is. I'm never that active, and usually at one point pay the price for it - smart move on part of the mafia if that's why they kept me alive: they earn a free lynch.

My death will not help the town win this, that's all I know, but perhaps Beskar's will:

Vote: Beskar.

[AggonyDuck]

I'd recommend lynching Rhyfelwyr.

[Gregoshi]

Just stating your vote without reason isn't helping the cause. We need to focus on a smartly selected target.

As for cases, assuming Beskar reported accurately, ajaxfetish's observed activities early in the game, while telling, did not carry much weight because he could have had a pro-town role. However, now that all the (known) pro-town roles are dead, his activities seem to hang a "bad guy" sign around his neck.

While Rhyfelwyr has the rap of being the last standing pever, there were four pevers but the ninjas got only three kills. This left Rhyfelwyr in a bad spot, it seems unlikely he's a baddie.

Dutch_guy's inactivity and spotty voting record early on sends a FoS his way, but I think ajaxfetish has a stronger case.

Forget Beskar, he says he's innocent. That's good enough for me.

Therefore, I suggest ajaxfetish for lynching but D_g is a good alternative.

[Beskar]

Hard to explain as there is a really strong gut feeling I had since a while ago for Ichigo. I had suspicions since early on and I wanted BG to investigate him for me, however, BQ didn't live that night. However, look at Ichigo's case, there is nothing that even suggests a town-role, any form of aid, advice or logic. He has repeatedly voted on bandwagons or against innocents. Hell, he has never actually denied being a mafia-role either when accused.

Even then, there is as you said:

Something that stands out from Duck's analysis, is Ichigo voting for Beskar almost every night since BQ put Beskar in the innocent list.

[FactionHeir]

woad is screaming guilt at me. Completely avoids "plays cool" any accusation by talking about something completely unrelated as if nothing else was ever said.

[Husar]

My analysis says 90% chance the town will lose this.

The thing about Beskar is this, if he is the ninja master and turned up innocent, but is the only remaining person of BG's innocent list who is still alive, then wouldn't he have framed himself by killing off all the other suspects? Ultimately this ends up as a mafia in front of you as everything else does but at the moment I tend towards letting him live and killing dutch_guy, Ichigo, Kage.

[Csargo]

Hard to explain as there is a really strong gut feeling I had since a while ago for Ichigo. I had suspicions since early on and I wanted BG to investigate him for me, however, BQ didn't live that night. However, look at Ichigo's case, there is nothing that even suggests a town-role, any form of aid, advice or logic. He has repeatedly voted on bandwagons or against innocents. Hell, he has never actually denied being a mafia-role either when accused.

Even then, there is as you said:

How long ago?

Oh, btw I'm innocent.

[Beskar]

Oh, btw I'm innocent.

Well, you convinced me to change my vote.

Got any reasons for people not to vote for you? Any evidence or proof of your innocent? People have been lynched for less suspicion than you.


Edit: I am actually the last person on the innocent list? Looks like my prediction was correct then, I thought two of the people who were killed were not on it. Doh....

[ajaxfetish]

As for cases, assuming Beskar reported accurately, ajaxfetish's observed activities early in the game, while telling, did not carry much weight because he could have had a pro-town role. However, now that all the (known) pro-town roles are dead, his activities seem to hang a "bad guy" sign around his neck.

First of all, it was Stephen Asen who accused me in the early game. Second, I denied having a pro-town special role then . . . because I don't have one. I explained my actions from the beginning as a personal role-play, because I didn't expect to live too long based on my previous game and didn't want to get too bored with the night phases.

That said, I have no idea who's guilty, so I'm just as expendable as any of our few remaining townies.

Ajax

[Beskar]

Ichigo's sarcastic style is a confession of him being a mafia-role.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Ichigo's sarcastic style is a confession of him being a mafia-role.

Explain. I would like to hear this out.

[Csargo]

Ichigo's sarcastic style is a confession of him being a mafia-role.

You spent the whole first half of the game saying you were innocent and expecting everyone to believe you, but now you don't believe me. Attacking everyone who voted against you and just kept repeating "I'm innocent" when no one had a reason to believe you. Even though BG investigated you that doesn't make you innocent. The likelyhood of Andres giving the ninja-master the ability to fool an investigation is pretty high I think, possibly some of the ninja.

[Csargo]

Ichigo's sarcastic style is a confession of him being a mafia-role.

Yeah, have the confirmed innocent duel another one. Great logic.

[Gregoshi]

You are right ajaxfetish, it was Stephen. My bad. I've little to go on as far as guilt too. But what are your thoughts on the various FoS's that have been tossed out? Surely you must have some thought on the rightness or wrongness of at least ONE of them (besides your own). Give us a hand please.

Ichigo, I have nothing against you. You are Glorious. However, you are alive and thus a prime candidate for being bad Glorious. Sorry, but life sucks, as they say. Unfortunately, death sucks more.

AD, I'm talking about Chimpyang since he "returned" yesterday. "I'm back!" and then...nothing.

Gotta run and get food. I'm "cooking" tonight.

[Beskar]

Beskar should still be lynched just because.

Well, if you are going to play it that way. Let's see you fight back now.

*Gets a red hot poker and goes to where the Corpse of Sasaki Kojiro is laying*

Now then... which part of your body are you willing to have missing for the afterlife?

My death will not help the town win this, that's all I know, but perhaps Beskar's will:

Vote: Beskar.

Yeah, because lynching a known innocent will actually help the town, obviously.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Well, if you are going to play it that way. Let's see you fight back now.

*Gets a red hot poker and goes to where the Corpse of Sasaki Kojiro is laying*

Now then... which part of your body are you willing to have missing for the afterlife?

You just admitted to being guilty.

[Beskar]

No, I just threatened a ghost who keeps speaking on lynching some one "for the lulz"/"just because" with removing body parts from their corpse to deprive them in the afterlife.

A confession of any form of guilt would have been "I enjoyed ridding you of your miserable life", unfortunately, I don't have such a pleasure.

[Gregoshi]

You just admitted to being guilty.

Yeah, he needs to work on his poker face.