I do not believe the ninjas would challenge unless they had to.

GH- Is a "confirmed" innocent and he has challenged frequently.

Kage- He is either messing with us or he truly didn't realize that Shingen was dead. I believe it is the latter and I also believe that Kage would have noticed if he was a ninja.

Yoyoma1910- The haikus could be an easy way to mask mafia behavior but the only time I've seen him as a mafioso he was rather serious. His challenger died during the night.

Ichigo- He has fought in two duels and does not appear guilty to me based on either the duel descriptions or his in-game behavior.

Rhyfelwyr- He was in the early abstain bandwagon. He had retaliatory/defensive votes against Tincow and LittleGrizzly. In his favor, the kill choices seem more like that of a veteran. Also, GH survived through the night despite challenging Rhyf.

vote: Yoyoma1910

Rhyf, if you look at previous games I have played, you will see that this is just my style. For reference, Taormina is a large game in which I was a townie and Netherworld is a large game in which I was mafioso. I have played in other games and I encourage you to look at them too.