Results 1 to 30 of 45

Thread: EB Online Faction Guide

Threaded View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #12

    Default Re: EB Online Faction Guide

    Quote Originally Posted by gamegeek2 View Post
    Created Pahlava's own category.

    What does Qarthadast have more in common with Romans than Hellenes? Sure, the African Heavy Infantry are essentially legionnaires, but look at the following parallels

    African Pikemen - Argyraspidai/Chaonion Agema/Klerouchon Agema
    Sacred Band Cavalry - Hetairoi/Molosson Agema
    Sacred Band Inf - Hypaspistai/Epilektoi Hoplitai
    Libyan Spearmen - Thureophoroi
    Heavy Libyans - Thorakitai
    Liby-Phoenician Inf - Hoplitai
    Iberian Assault Inf - Pheraspidai

    The other, native Iberian units don't count, they're essentially foreign natives.


    In that case, Kart-Hadast can be put together even with nomads because of their Iberian Lancers (something lke armoured h/a's without archers), and with barbs because of their hard-core ap troops like elite liby-phoenican infantry (barb: naked fanatics or wildmen) and so on.

    Anyway, Carthaginian pikemen are elite, and strategy of Carthagian army on the field is supposed to be very different than Hellenic pike-phalanx-based field development. I know that in mp battles many users (including myself) are acting very similar as Hellenes with pikes as a core troops, but this is just an example of searching for best-suited strategy for Carthaginians, and not a definite Carthaginian strategy. If you take Hannibal as an example, you'll see what i'm talking about: their mix of various types of infantry makes them specific.

    Because of that Carthage must be in its own category.

    Carthage deserves that


    EDIT: i have also developed mechanism for breaking phalanx line, but it works only with AI... tried that on Maion in mp , but it doesn't work. Damn And its not about encirclement: with some mix of Carthaginian troops one can beat any phalanx you like- from the front: without cheating (like running through phalanx).

    I'll post a picture very soon. It may be useful for some players.


    EDIT No2 (a picture)


    Last edited by Jebivjetar; 06-03-2009 at 10:06.


Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO