Results 1 to 30 of 33

Thread: Excellent documentary on Parthia

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1
    Satalextos Basileus Seron Member satalexton's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Posts
    1,180

    Default Re: Excellent documentary on Parthia

    We've been keeping to ourselves lately...are you taking a jab at us? Don't mix modern politics with ancient history.




    "ΜΗΔΕΝ ΕΩΡΑΚΕΝΑΙ ΦΟΒΕΡΩΤΕΡΟΝ ΚΑΙ ΔΕΙΝΟΤΕΡΟΝ ΦΑΛΑΓΓΟΣ ΜΑΚΕΔΟΝΙΚΗΣ" -Lucius Aemilius Paullus

  2. #2
    Member Member NikosMaximilian's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2009
    Location
    Buenos Aires, Argentina
    Posts
    78

    Default Re: Excellent documentary on Parthia

    Quote Originally Posted by satalexton View Post
    We've been keeping to ourselves lately...are you taking a jab at us? Don't mix modern politics with ancient history.
    No, it's not directed at you, it's at Jones' documentary. He just jumps into conclusions without presenting evidence or documents supporting them. He also presents his personal opinion as historical facts, it's almost as bad as a History Channel documentary.

    Completed campaigns:


    Ongoing campaigns:

  3. #3
    Arrogant Ashigaru Moderator Ludens's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Posts
    9,063
    Blog Entries
    1

    Default Re: Excellent documentary on Parthia

    Quote Originally Posted by NikosMaximilian View Post
    It's bad revisionist history, because in order to talk about the engeneering, the technology, the culture and military achievements of the "Barbarians", he needs to paint Rome as Mordor and the "barbarians" as innocent wildmen. This is a weak form to create an argument, simple and fails to reach any good point. It's like supporting Al-Qaeda or the Taliban because you don't like US foreign policy. The World isn't black or white, Mr Jones (he should really go back to comedy).
    Fair point and I agree, but I think it was a deliberate decision. Jones wanted to write about the Romans in the way the Romans (and many uncritical writers since) often wrote about the barbarians. Hence I called it an antidote. Jones can do better than this (I personally very much enjoyed his writing on the Crusades, also based on a BBC documentary that I managed to miss).
    Looking for a good read? Visit the Library!

  4. #4
    Member Member Horatius's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    England
    Posts
    383

    Default Re: Excellent documentary on Parthia

    Quote Originally Posted by NikosMaximilian View Post
    I got the impression of Jones being a Romaioktonoi after watching not only the Parthian chapters, but also those referring to the Celts, the Germanic tribes and the Huns (you can watch them by searching "Jones Barbarians Huns" or "Jones Barbarians Celts" in YouTube)

    Every time the Romans won a battle the reason was "because of good luck and treachery, combined with the fact that they were bloodthirsty animals who were technologically and culturally backwards compared to the rest of the inocent people living in the world". When the Romani were pagans, they sacrificed humans, hosted bloody gladiatorial games and enslaved everyone (and looks like they were the only ones doing it). When they were Christians, he implies that they are the ones to blame for the rise of the Roman Catholic Church and everything that happened later, including the Crusades, the Inquisition and priests abusing children.

    Every time the Romans lost, well, not only he rejoices over it, he also makes it clear that it was "because they were bloodthirsty greedy animals who were technologically and culturally backwards". The Gothic, Vandal and Hunnic incursions are mentioned as someone renting a penthouse for a couple of years: "Oh, yeah, you don't mind, do you? I'll just enter here and take this place". Of course, when Roman citizens (even if they weren't Italians) were killed, that's not much of an issue.

    It's bad revisionist history, because in order to talk about the engeneering, the technology, the culture and military achievements of the "Barbarians", he needs to paint Rome as Mordor and the "barbarians" as innocent wildmen. This is a weak form to create an argument, simple and fails to reach any good point. It's like supporting Al-Qaeda or the Taliban because you don't like US foreign policy. The World isn't black or white, Mr Jones (he should really go back to comedy).
    I couldn't agree more.

    Jones could and usually does better, but as far as Rome goes he really has nothing but hate for it. He gives it some recognition in his "Surprising History of Rome", which actually contradicts all of his other ancient world documentaries by depicting Roman Technology that his other documentaries claim they didn't have among other things, but overall I get the feeling that he would have a wonderful time giving Hannibal an interview or two.

    Although he usually does better on non ancient history, he still does have some obvious bias. I.E. he does claim some universal aspects of the middle ages (Knighthoods granted to low born for example) are English unique, but his medieval things are still much better then his ancient, although that could just be my own bias in liking the way he depicts England.

  5. #5

    Default Re: Excellent documentary on Parthia

    Quote Originally Posted by Horatius View Post
    ...although that could just be my own bias in liking the way he depicts England.
    My eyes went straight for where it says "location" and I couldn't help but read "England". Haha. I know nothing of medieval Evropa other than the fantasy that I imagine. This will change with education, though!
    EB Online Founder | Website
    Former Projects:
    - Vartan's EB Submod Compilation Pack

    - Asia ton Barbaron (Armenian linguistics)
    - EB:NOM (Armenian linguistics/history)
    - Dominion of the Sword (Armenian linguistics/history, videographer)

  6. #6

    Default Re: Excellent documentary on Parthia

    one really could get the impression that many people here think Documentaries(and history books) are meant to be totally unbiased. things like this are always biased. if one follows the opinion mainstream one may not notice that and condemn all opposing opinions as highly biased, but personally I find it highly important to look at a matter from more than one perspective. this does not mean to look for books whose authors claim to be unbiased but to listen to both sides rather than only those with whom you agree.

    ps: very nice find gamegeek2, I'll watch all episodes now :)
    "Who fights can lose, who doesn't fight has already lost."
    - Pyrrhus of Epirus

    "Durch diese hohle Gasse muss er kommen..."
    - Leonidas of Sparta

    "People called Romanes they go the House"
    - Alaric the Visigoth

  7. #7
    CAIVS CAESAR Member Mulceber's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Location
    Ithaca, NY
    Posts
    548

    Default Re: Excellent documentary on Parthia

    They are intended to be unbiased. They always fail, because all mediums are biased. But in the field of academia we should strive to be as unbiased as possible. It is impossible of course to completely remove bias, but we can get fairly close. TJ clearly is not trying at all to be unbiased. And no, you are not correct that we should listen to all biases - that would be like suggesting you should only get your news from MSNBC and Fox. What we should do is try to find the sources that have the least bias and listen to them. ie. the scholarly equivalent of watching PBS news and CSPAN. -M
    My Balloons:

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO