Results 1 to 30 of 320

Thread: Proposition 8 declared unconstitutional

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1
    Needs more flowers Moderator drone's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Location
    Moral High Grounds
    Posts
    9,286

    Default Re: Proposition 8 declared unconstitutional

    So the 9th Circuit Court retains the same-sex marriage ban until their hearing starting December 6th.
    http://www.cnn.com/2010/US/08/16/sam...ex.html?hpt=T1
    Interesting decision, I wonder if this was done to postpone flak before the elections. Because it's a forgone conclusion that the 9th will uphold Walker's ruling.
    The .Org's MTW Reference Guide Wiki - now taking comments, corrections, suggestions, and submissions

    If I werent playing games Id be killing small animals at a higher rate than I am now - SFTS
    Si je n'étais pas jouer à des jeux que je serais mort de petits animaux à un taux plus élevé que je suis maintenant - Louis VI The Fat

    "Why do you hate the extremely limited Spartan version of freedom?" - Lemur

  2. #2
    The very model of a modern Moderator Xiahou's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2002
    Location
    in the cloud.
    Posts
    9,007

    Default Re: Proposition 8 declared unconstitutional

    The "standing" issue is really unsettling to me. You have a majority of voters pass a proposition. One person can challenge it in court and if the attorney general of the state isn't interested in supporting the proposition, it gets overturned by default? That really seems to short-circuit the democratic process. This would mean any referendum passed by the people can be tossed aside if the current government doesn't support it.

    On another note- isnt the AG shirking his duty here?
    "Don't believe everything you read online."
    -Abraham Lincoln

  3. #3

    Default Re: Proposition 8 declared unconstitutional

    Which would be the case, if the law in question (prop 8) had actually been valid within the legal framework it must fit in (Californian constitution, and the USA one). Remember that in the USA federal laws trump state laws, and constitutions trump “lesser” laws. But prop 8 isn't and that is the meat of the ruling (that the AG isn't interested in defending it is merely a mildly interesting sideshow).

    Now the Judge has noted two things: (1) that the defense for prop 8 failed to make a case why prop 8 is not in fact unconstitutional, (2) that prop 8 does indeed appear to violate applicable constitutions and law. So (2) might have been considered differently had (1) not been the case however (2) still applies which is (a) also the contention brought before the court by the plaintiffs, and (b) the argument which I still haven't seen anyone giving a sound counter-argument to.

    Finally, remember that it is the job of the courts to check the excesses of lawmakers (be that popular vote or politicians making hay while the sun is still shining on a Mosque in NYC): that is why you should be grateful not to live in any “democracy” (or rather mob-rule) but in a country where laws can be scrutinized and acid-tested before a court. It gives minorities protection from arbitrary decisions imposed on them by a majority, if they can prove them to be unjust/unfair.
    - Tellos Athenaios
    CUF tool - XIDX - PACK tool - SD tool - EVT tool - EB Install Guide - How to track down loading CTD's - EB 1.1 Maps thread


    ὁ δ᾽ ἠλίθιος ὣσπερ πρόβατον βῆ βῆ λέγων βαδίζει” – Kratinos in Dionysalexandros.

  4. #4
    Praefectus Fabrum Senior Member Anime BlackJack Champion, Flash Poker Champion, Word Up Champion, Shape Game Champion, Snake Shooter Champion, Fishwater Challenge Champion, Rocket Racer MX Champion, Jukebox Hero Champion, My House Is Bigger Than Your House Champion, Funky Pong Champion, Cutie Quake Champion, Fling The Cow Champion, Tiger Punch Champion, Virus Champion, Solitaire Champion, Worm Race Champion, Rope Walker Champion, Penguin Pass Champion, Skate Park Champion, Watch Out Champion, Lawn Pac Champion, Weapons Of Mass Destruction Champion, Skate Boarder Champion, Lane Bowling Champion, Bugz Champion, Makai Grand Prix 2 Champion, White Van Man Champion, Parachute Panic Champion, BlackJack Champion, Stans Ski Jumping Champion, Smaugs Treasure Champion, Sofa Longjump Champion Seamus Fermanagh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    Latibulm mali regis in muris.
    Posts
    11,454

    Default Re: Proposition 8 declared unconstitutional

    Quote Originally Posted by Xiahou View Post
    The "standing" issue is really unsettling to me. You have a majority of voters pass a proposition. One person can challenge it in court and if the attorney general of the state isn't interested in supporting the proposition, it gets overturned by default? That really seems to short-circuit the democratic process. This would mean any referendum passed by the people can be tossed aside if the current government doesn't support it.

    On another note- isnt the AG shirking his duty here?
    Depends on whether you view elected officials in Jeffersonian or Burkean terms. Jefferson held that an elected official should reflect the will of her constituency. Burke held that an elected official should work for the long term best interests of their constituency EVEN if that meant opposing the will of that constituency in the short term. I would venture to guess that most of the officials in California believe that restricting marriage to hetersexual unions is morally wrong and that they are duty bound to oppose the short-sighted electorate on the issue.
    "The only way that has ever been discovered to have a lot of people cooperate together voluntarily is through the free market. And that's why it's so essential to preserving individual freedom.” -- Milton Friedman

    "The urge to save humanity is almost always a false front for the urge to rule." -- H. L. Mencken

  5. #5
    Darkside Medic Senior Member rory_20_uk's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2003
    Location
    Taplow, UK
    Posts
    8,690
    Blog Entries
    1

    Default Re: Proposition 8 declared unconstitutional

    Interesting. I'm sure everyone thinks of themselves as Burkean in nature, as after all this enables one to override all opposition as the other side clearly needs saving from itself.

    An enemy that wishes to die for their country is the best sort to face - you both have the same aim in mind.
    Science flies you to the moon, religion flies you into buildings.
    "If you can't trust the local kleptocrat whom you installed by force and prop up with billions of annual dollars, who can you trust?" Lemur
    If you're not a liberal when you're 25, you have no heart. If you're not a conservative by the time you're 35, you have no brain.
    The best argument against democracy is a five minute talk with the average voter. Winston Churchill

  6. #6
    Mr Self Important Senior Member Beskar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    Albion
    Posts
    15,930
    Blog Entries
    1

    Default Re: Proposition 8 declared unconstitutional

    Quote Originally Posted by rory_20_uk View Post
    Interesting. I'm sure everyone thinks of themselves as Burkean in nature, as after all this enables one to override all opposition as the other side clearly needs saving from itself.

    Indeed.
    Days since the Apocalypse began
    "We are living in space-age times but there's too many of us thinking with stone-age minds" | How to spot a Humanist
    "Men of Quality do not fear Equality." | "Belief doesn't change facts. Facts, if you are reasonable, should change your beliefs."

  7. #7
    Praefectus Fabrum Senior Member Anime BlackJack Champion, Flash Poker Champion, Word Up Champion, Shape Game Champion, Snake Shooter Champion, Fishwater Challenge Champion, Rocket Racer MX Champion, Jukebox Hero Champion, My House Is Bigger Than Your House Champion, Funky Pong Champion, Cutie Quake Champion, Fling The Cow Champion, Tiger Punch Champion, Virus Champion, Solitaire Champion, Worm Race Champion, Rope Walker Champion, Penguin Pass Champion, Skate Park Champion, Watch Out Champion, Lawn Pac Champion, Weapons Of Mass Destruction Champion, Skate Boarder Champion, Lane Bowling Champion, Bugz Champion, Makai Grand Prix 2 Champion, White Van Man Champion, Parachute Panic Champion, BlackJack Champion, Stans Ski Jumping Champion, Smaugs Treasure Champion, Sofa Longjump Champion Seamus Fermanagh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    Latibulm mali regis in muris.
    Posts
    11,454

    Default Re: Proposition 8 declared unconstitutional

    Xiahou:

    I would suggest that that is exactly the system that obtains. If Schwarzeneggar and enough of the legislature wish to do elsewise, then elsewise it shall be. The voters may turn them out of office via recall or at the next balloting if they are scandalized enough. Unfortunately, enough will forget before the next balloting that this may not motivate the representatives enough to support the constitutional choice of a modest majority of Californians.

    In the specific instance of California, I think their simple majority rule for Constitutional changes is coming back to haunt them here. The gov is not seeking another term so he feels free to do as he sees fit. Moreover, he can get political support because the majority that voted YES on this issue was modest -- and many in the legislature know that not enough of their voters will turn on them over this to be decisive. If Cali had a 2/3 rule for such changes, they'd be less frequent but VERY hard to ignore. 67% is not just a majority choice, its a mandate.
    "The only way that has ever been discovered to have a lot of people cooperate together voluntarily is through the free market. And that's why it's so essential to preserving individual freedom.” -- Milton Friedman

    "The urge to save humanity is almost always a false front for the urge to rule." -- H. L. Mencken

  8. #8

    Default Re: Proposition 8 declared unconstitutional

    The ruling has been upheld by the federal appeals court. On to the Supreme Court.

  9. #9
    The very model of a modern Moderator Xiahou's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2002
    Location
    in the cloud.
    Posts
    9,007

    Default Re: Proposition 8 declared unconstitutional

    Quote Originally Posted by Seamus Fermanagh View Post
    Depends on whether you view elected officials in Jeffersonian or Burkean terms. Jefferson held that an elected official should reflect the will of her constituency. Burke held that an elected official should work for the long term best interests of their constituency EVEN if that meant opposing the will of that constituency in the short term. I would venture to guess that most of the officials in California believe that restricting marriage to hetersexual unions is morally wrong and that they are duty bound to oppose the short-sighted electorate on the issue.
    For just a moment, set aside the gay marriage issue. The logical extension of this is that any law passed by the legislature or by referendum can be cast aside as long as the Governor and AG oppose it. Take any law, challenge it in court, have the AG no-show, and the law gets overturned. The referendum process becomes meaningless if the current regime doesn't support it.

    Quote Originally Posted by rory_20_uk
    Interesting. I'm sure everyone thinks of themselves as Burkean in nature, as after all this enables one to override all opposition as the other side clearly needs saving from itself.

    I'm pretty sure the AG's oath of office is to support the laws of the state. Not to support only the laws he likes. The California Supreme Court already determined that the law was legally enacted- which is why it was elevated to the federal courts. As a duly passed amendment to the state's constitution, I don't see where he can get off on just saying "pass".
    Last edited by Xiahou; 08-17-2010 at 15:17.
    "Don't believe everything you read online."
    -Abraham Lincoln

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO