Org Mobile Site
Out of all the great civilizations of the era, I find Carthage to be the most interesting. A mix between Phoenician, Hellenistic, and North African, Iberian(?) cultures creating a huge trading empire to take on the fledgling Res Publica and ultimately lose.
following the total destruction of Carthage by the Romans, did the Carthaginian culture and language completely disappear? Surely there must have been punic citizens maybe not in Carthage itself when it was destroyed? they were traders after all. Or what about the Balearic islands? Southern Iberia?
I just find it very interesting that such a dominant and powerful culture could have disappeared completely without maybe some refugee enclaves, maybe back to Phoenicia itself? Or to Hellas?
any recommending readings i would love to check out.
following the total destruction of Carthage by the Romans, did the Carthaginian culture and language completely disappear? Surely there must have been punic citizens maybe not in Carthage itself when it was destroyed? they were traders after all. Or what about the Balearic islands? Southern Iberia?
I just find it very interesting that such a dominant and powerful culture could have disappeared completely without maybe some refugee enclaves, maybe back to Phoenicia itself? Or to Hellas?
any recommending readings i would love to check out.
Originally Posted by fomalhaut:
Out of all the great civilizations of the era, I find Carthage to be the most interesting. A mix between Phoenician, Hellenistic, and North African, Iberian(?) cultures creating a huge trading empire to take on the fledgling Res Publica and ultimately lose.
following the total destruction of Carthage by the Romans, did the Carthaginian culture and language completely disappear? Surely there must have been punic citizens maybe not in Carthage itself when it was destroyed? they were traders after all. Or what about the Balearic islands? Southern Iberia?
I just find it very interesting that such a dominant and powerful culture could have disappeared completely without maybe some refugee enclaves, maybe back to Phoenicia itself? Or to Hellas?
any recommending readings i would love to check out.
There is always some recommended reading, check out the EB Bibliography:Out of all the great civilizations of the era, I find Carthage to be the most interesting. A mix between Phoenician, Hellenistic, and North African, Iberian(?) cultures creating a huge trading empire to take on the fledgling Res Publica and ultimately lose.
following the total destruction of Carthage by the Romans, did the Carthaginian culture and language completely disappear? Surely there must have been punic citizens maybe not in Carthage itself when it was destroyed? they were traders after all. Or what about the Balearic islands? Southern Iberia?
I just find it very interesting that such a dominant and powerful culture could have disappeared completely without maybe some refugee enclaves, maybe back to Phoenicia itself? Or to Hellas?
any recommending readings i would love to check out.
https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showt...m-Bibliography
The culture did not completely disappear, it just didn't have an impact on today's society like the Hellenes or Romani did.
Of course there is still Tunisia to see, I hear a trip to North Africa is quite cheap nowadays..
~Fluvius
I think Punic was still spoken in north Africa up until it was replaced by Arabic in the 7th century.
Im going to south spain in the summer and i thought... is there any sites of punic origin around Malaga?
We Malaga was a Phoenician colony so I would guess so, don't know any specific sites though.
herm carthaginian culture subsisted in roman agriculture and maritime ways i bet there are others but the romans probably masked them and then called it their own creation
during the debate about the people of sardinia i´ve read alot of articles about arqueological diggings that where wrongly considered romans when in fact they where at a closer look of either nuringhian-punii origin or just punic in origin so that shows that our lack of compreension of what was the punic culture makes us even today make mistakes in dating and caractherising some sites and thus not recognising the valour of punic culture
but the ship construction and most defenitly the roman agricultural knowledge borrowed alot from the punic writtings and treaties on those subjects so we can only conjecture that there where alot more subjects the romans took from them
during the debate about the people of sardinia i´ve read alot of articles about arqueological diggings that where wrongly considered romans when in fact they where at a closer look of either nuringhian-punii origin or just punic in origin so that shows that our lack of compreension of what was the punic culture makes us even today make mistakes in dating and caractherising some sites and thus not recognising the valour of punic culture
but the ship construction and most defenitly the roman agricultural knowledge borrowed alot from the punic writtings and treaties on those subjects so we can only conjecture that there where alot more subjects the romans took from them
you could argue that as the carthagians were phoenicians and thus used the phoenician alphabet and as the greek alphabet is based on the phoenician and everybody knows on what the latin alphabet is based on, we today still write in something that has evolved from the alphabet used by the carthagians. bit scarce but the first thing that came to my mind.
I went to Carthage when I was younger, it's still there although..less..y'know, visible than it used to be. It's still there though.
Originally Posted by Ca Putt:
you could argue that as the carthagians were phoenicians and thus used the phoenician alphabet and as the greek alphabet is based on the phoenician and everybody knows on what the latin alphabet is based on, we today still write in something that has evolved from the alphabet used by the carthagians. bit scarce but the first thing that came to my mind.
i thought of this as well but its really not quite what i had in mind.you could argue that as the carthagians were phoenicians and thus used the phoenician alphabet and as the greek alphabet is based on the phoenician and everybody knows on what the latin alphabet is based on, we today still write in something that has evolved from the alphabet used by the carthagians. bit scarce but the first thing that came to my mind.
Probably plenty of remnants of Carthaginian "culture" around, and probably things most of us cannot name (I sure cannot!) Let us falsely assume all of the Carthaginian domain to fall under one distinct culture. I suppose you could ask what innovations the Carthaginians brought about during their age. Then you could possibly make an argument that distinctly relates these ancient innovations to modern day derivations, if that is how you wish to look at them. From a linguistic perspective I would suggest taking a look at possible loans in the tongues of peoples directly (or indirectly) affected by Carthage. Considering the Carthaginians were, as we are taught, a maritime trading people, you may look at shipping and economic innovations; what similarities do you find in contemporary overseas trade? Enjoy the mind exercise!
EDIT: Not a student of Carthage. Someone mentioned the EB Biblio thread. First place to look, indeed!
EDIT: Not a student of Carthage. Someone mentioned the EB Biblio thread. First place to look, indeed!
business!!
Originally Posted by artavazd:
business!!
could you elaborate on this?business!!
and i just realized in my first EB Kart Hadast campaign that one of the conditions is to retake your homeland Phoinike! i think that is really really cool.
It was Carthage that i played my most memorable campaign in vanilla, and it was because of their Sacred Band (a pike phalanx in full Corinthian helmets and greek panopaly with the horse hair hahaha wow) that i started looking into history a bit more as they were quite interesting. this lead me eventually to EB! just so yall know
i recently discovered that the worst insult in my language comes from the word kar´alia wich is a semitic word so punii had insults
i'm going to assume do to their diversity that the Phoenicians had a lot of insults. i mean, those dirty rotten Libyans, Massylians, Nurigians, Numidians, Garamantines, Iberians, dirty rotten whoever is in control of Phoenicia or Tyre
Originally Posted by moonburn:
i recently discovered that the worst insult in my language comes from the word kar´alia wich is a semitic word so punii had insults
Well every language has insults, wouldnt even be surprised when the first spoken words were insults. i recently discovered that the worst insult in my language comes from the word kar´alia wich is a semitic word so punii had insults
Edit: I am curious now about that specific insult, so enlighten me ^^
Sardinia has several well preserved traces of punic culture.
The southern part of the island was thoroughly colonized (Nora was as old as Carthage itself) and unlike other parts of the punic empire many sites had an extremely gradual evolution.
Punic language and institutions like the Shophets survived until the 2nd century AD while traditional art still bears today a few traces of the ancient past, while a few place names still bear close derivatives of punic words.
The southern part of the island was thoroughly colonized (Nora was as old as Carthage itself) and unlike other parts of the punic empire many sites had an extremely gradual evolution.
Punic language and institutions like the Shophets survived until the 2nd century AD while traditional art still bears today a few traces of the ancient past, while a few place names still bear close derivatives of punic words.
Originally Posted by fomalhaut:
could you elaborate on this?
and i just realized in my first EB Kart Hadast campaign that one of the conditions is to retake your homeland Phoinike! i think that is really really cool.
It was Carthage that i played my most memorable campaign in vanilla, and it was because of their Sacred Band (a pike phalanx in full Corinthian helmets and greek panopaly with the horse hair hahaha wow) that i started looking into history a bit more as they were quite interesting. this lead me eventually to EB! just so yall know
The Phoenicians were probably the first civilization to take international trade (business) to great lengths. There are evidence of Phoenician trade all the way in Britain. Carthage its self was a Phoenician trading settlement.could you elaborate on this?
and i just realized in my first EB Kart Hadast campaign that one of the conditions is to retake your homeland Phoinike! i think that is really really cool.
It was Carthage that i played my most memorable campaign in vanilla, and it was because of their Sacred Band (a pike phalanx in full Corinthian helmets and greek panopaly with the horse hair hahaha wow) that i started looking into history a bit more as they were quite interesting. this lead me eventually to EB! just so yall know
Clear Glass???
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO