Quote Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro View Post
Like I said your objection isn't truly to the theory it's to people feeling differently about owning slaves.
Maybe. Idk. Still very skeptical. I'm afraid that looking kindly on no-so-great decisions because of the context of the time let's people do mental hopscotch and make revisionist history. I'm not trying to talk about how we should understand history, I am trying to talk about how we should learn from history. It is important to understand what the situation was at the time and why they made the decisions they did. But that should not alter our view of their faults imo.


I don't know why you two imagine that people are desperately trying to hold on to an image of perfection and that your view is the nuanced one
Because to me, I see a bunch of people that are more than willing to apply "historical context" to slave owning Founding Fathers, but no one seems to apply the same process to their positive attributes due to the risk of diminishing what we hold as demi-god like.

Hence why American culture seems to have fully characterized all the Founding Fathers as one homogeneous entity that fought for freedom because they all agreed that we were under tyranny. What happened to applying historical context there? A lot of Founding Father's were only pushed into the war as a measure of last resort due to the rejection of the Olive Branch Petition.