Mafia IV: Night of the Living Mafia [Concluded]

[Csargo]

@Tiberius-pshh



Could you possibly list who voted for who and who didn't vote when you do the tally? Would be handy.

Your asking a little much don't you think Sasaki. Hard enough to count a couple of votes in a thread but as many as he has to it would be kinda hard.

Disco is kinda suspicious to me and the people who are voting for Ice and of course you can never count out Ice using voting for Disco as a alibi.

[UltraWar]

Unvote: Destroyer of Hope
Vote: Leet Eriksson

This is because on how suspicious Leet Eriksson is acting.

[Csargo]

Unvote: Destroyer of Hope
Vote: Leet Eriksson

This is because on how suspicious Leet Eriksson is acting.

Not a very good reason Ultra. You couldn't think of anything better?

[UltraWar]

That is correct, yet is a little wrong

[Silver Rusher]

This is unbelievable!

5 pages in a single round of voting!?!?! Why couldn't my game have such active participation?

[Csargo]

This is unbelievable!

5 pages in a single round of voting!?!?! Why couldn't my game have such active participation?

I guess it's because GH is such a popular guy. His mafia games seem to be the most fun. Good job GH

[Silver Rusher]

I guess it's because GH is such a popular guy. His mafia games seem to be the most fun. Good job GH

I'm flattered.

[Csargo]

I'm flattered.

I've never played in your Mafia game so I wouldn't know how they are. Sorry if I offended you.

[Avicenna]

He's the original with a nice, simple system. 'Tried and tested'.

The most inactive, I found, was the overly complex system that Sasaki set up. Boggled me throughout.

You also contribute a lot with your own posting, which I guess was missing in the Godfather.

[Silver Rusher]

I've never played in your Mafia game so I wouldn't know how they are. Sorry if I offended you.

Oh, OK. And no, you didn't offend me one bit. Now let's all be happy.

[Lemur]

Is Dutch Guy around? If so, just tell me who he's voting for. He has an uncanny ability to be correct. As for the rest of the arguments, I'm feeling more heat than light. I really, really don't want to take a blind stab at a vote, 'cause I know how irritating it is to have somebody vote for you for no reason. Can somebody sum up the suspects for this round? Or is that even worth it?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Ok, everyone

The voting has now ended. I'm going to tally them.

See you in a week

Edit: Execution will be in a new post.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Is Dutch Guy around? If so, just tell me who he's voting for. He has an uncanny ability to be correct. As for the rest of the arguments, I'm feeling more heat than light. I really, really don't want to take a blind stab at a vote, 'cause I know how irritating it is to have somebody vote for you for no reason. Can somebody sum up the suspects for this round? Or is that even worth it?

You're pretty much suspect Numero Uno I'm afraid.

[Csargo]

You're pretty much suspect Numero Uno I'm afraid.

True dat

[GeneralHankerchief]

We have a tie vote. I'm not going to bother writing an execution scene until someone actually gets executed.

Here's how it will work: You can only vote for Drisos or Kagemusha (or abstain). All votes are wiped. You have a little less than 24 hours.

Here is the vote tally for Session 1:

Drisos: 4 (Divine Wind, Big King Sanctaphrax, King Henry V, Byzantine Mercenary)
Kagemusha: 4 (Kagemusha, Destroyer of Hope, AggonyDuck, Masy)
discovery1: 3 (Ice, Kommodus, Ignoramus)
Ice: 2 (discovery1, Leet Eriksson)
Sasaki Kojiro: 2 (Sir Moody, Csar)
UltraWar: 2 (Sigurd Fafnesbane, doc_bean)
Destroyer of Hope: 2 (Sasaki Kojiro, Crazed Rabbit)
Csar: 1 (Drisos)
Sigurd Fafnesbane: 1 (Orb)
Leet Eriksson (UltraWar)

Abstained: 6 (Evil Maniac From Mars, Cowhead418, Reenk Roink, Lemur, Myrddraal, Dutch_guy)
Didn't vote: 2 (Zalmoxis, The Spartan)

[Csargo]

Abstain

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Bah, we have to choose between innocents?

Vote:Drisos

I'm not inclined to humor Kage's request.

[Lemur]

Sorry, I don't have enough information to vote, and I'm not cool with executing someone at random. Since GH has stated that we may abstain I'm going to do so.

[edit]

Changed to Vote:Kage

[Crazed Rabbit]

Vote: Drisos

He seems the more guilty of the pair.
CR

PS - thanks for recording who voted for who GH- it's super useful for making a spreadsheet.

[Big King Sanctaphrax]

I suppose I might as well be consistent.

Vote: Drisos.

[Kommodus]

Vote: Kagemusha

Asking to be lynched has shown itself to be one of the best ways to avoid being lynched. Also, I still think Drisos is innocent.

[Sir Moody]

Vote: Kage


Drisos has defended himself well enough to satisfy me... for now

[Myrddraal]

Vote:Kage

More suspicious behavior, I'm more inclined towards giving him the chop than Drisos due to both their posting attitudes.

[Reenk Roink]

Reenkistien abstains...courteously...

[Evil_Maniac From Mars]

Vote: Kagemusha

[Zalmoxis]

That was quick, I'm gone for a day and there are 5 pages of posts...
Abstain, since I didn't read absolutely every page.

[Byzantine Mercenary]

i think Kagemusha asked to be lynched because he knows that (as a townsperson) that it is the best way to avoid death by mafia (they will keep him alive as he is likely to be lynched in their stead)

so im provisionally going for Drisos, i might change my mind...

[Cowhead418]

Bah, it seems I'm not here for the lengthy discussions, only afterwards. Anyway, here are some comments I'd like to make:
1. BKS, a lynching will not always be in the town's interest, especially in the first few rounds when there is little to go on. We are almost certain to lynch an innocent the first round, and that helps the mafia.
2. Destroyer of Hope did vote every round until his death in the Godfather. When I was choosing him as my target I remember being surprised that he had no warnings.
3. While I don't believe that either Kage or Drisos are mafia, I think we shouldn't take a chance with Kage. Remember, in Mafia III Lemur voted for himself and survived to the end. He may very well be just having fun (and I believe this to be so), but it could be a tactic to draw away suspicion, though it is a very risky chance to take. Vote: Kagemusha

[Sasaki Kojiro]

1. BKS, a lynching will not always be in the town's interest, especially in the first few rounds when there is little to go on. We are almost certain to lynch an innocent the first round, and that helps the mafia.

Nooooo why do people always say this. It's always in the towns best interest to chance a lynch. If we don't lynch they are going to kill innocents anyway. We have 32 peeps I believe. We can lose two each round, or we can lose 3 each round with a small chance at a mafioso.

Scenario 1: First three rounds we abstain. 6 innocents die.
Scanario 2: We lynch two rounds in a row. We have a 1/30 and a 1/27 chance of killing a mafioso. If we don't 6 innocents die.

Now which is better for the town? LYNCHING

[Myrddraal]

Since a lynch is going to happen anyway I guess it isn't essential to vote this round, but in general it's in the towns interest to lynch.