Quote Originally Posted by Sgt Kelly
Errr, no. I'm faced by a fully repaired wall and have no choice but to exit out of the battle, taking 182 casualties I could do nothing about.
Game never lets you assault unless there is a breach, you got arty or a spy's in. Even if it did, you would get an insta close defeat.

Did you really check all 4 sides of the settlement? Because unless you attack from the exact same angle, the damaged section will be at another side of the settlement.