Quote Originally Posted by Stig
Dunno, afterall I'm not Peter von Kastillien, I'm Ansehelm.
But Factionheir gave you the battle? (at least according to the PM I received that also addressed you). And Ansehelm was present?

The general the computer denotes as commanding does not necessarily have to be the one fighting the battle. Where there is more than one player controlled general, I think the Chancellor can have some discretion based on out of game availability and in game considerations. You sallying from the settlement you are Count of seems fine to me. It's a bit sad from the point of view of traits that Peter not Ansehelm benefits, but given it was a sally, there may not be anything that can be done about that.

I'll work from the save you uploaded unless someone shouts stop.