The Secret Formula [Concluded]

[TevashSzat]

vote: Sarathos

Can you perhaps provide a reason??

Vote: Sarathos

I dunno, doesn't seem that shlin is scummy, but based on what he did last round, he will probably get lynched this round.

[Beefy187]

Can you provide reason why your voting for Sarathos?

Sarathos seems to be spamming like he normally does. Soon as his back from his math exam im sure hell be spamming more. So im pretty sure its not Sarathos

[TevashSzat]

Whoops made an error there

Unvote, Vote: Gibson Your dirty mind tricks shall not work on me!

[gibsonsg91921]

I voted Sarathos - he seemed a bit too inquisitive about who was mafia, like hes trying to hide that he is.

and whats FoS?

[woad&fangs]

Finger of Suspicion
And that's actually a pretty solid point. What ever happened to Lurker Pride, Sarathos?

[Zain]

I, the ghost of Zain, curse whoever it was that killed me!!

But, it's okay, because I'm gonna play in another one day, and win.

[Beefy187]

Sarathos changed his playing style i guess.. Normally he gets lynched real early but this time his still alive. So he could be somewhat motivated by that.

UnFoS: Gibson

You got some reason now. I shall UnFoS you

[Twilightblade]

Finger of Suspicion
And that's actually a pretty solid point. What ever happened to Lurker Pride, Sarathos?

Sarathos lurks then spams then lurks again most of the time

[Northnovas]

Okay, I still can't figure this out to actually have a suspect because I don't know anyone. However, the experience players finger each other with suspicion on statements that do not make sense to me this early in the game but they see something or have us believe they do.
I don't want to be a "lurker" but I don't know what to really say. Though I guess I did post a bad thing being impatient.

[CountArach]

Nah, eventually people tell you

Vote: Shlin

Stig, you seem incredibly eager to see shlin killed. Is there any particular reason to this. I will FoS: shlin for trying to tip the vote at the end of yesterday, but I shall Vote: Stig for appearing far too eager to vote for someone.

[Caius]

When I voted Stig for voting me, everyone started a bandagon against me!

[FactionHeir]

Something I don't understand is how 2 people "suicided"? How come it doesn't count as WoG?

As for suspicions... what CA said just now seemed very un-townie like.
vote: CA

[Hepcat]

Personally CountArach is the person I trust the least. He always seems to just try and get whoever is voting voted against. If someone votes, he immediately acts as if that person is suspicious.

I think he's hiding something.

Vote: CountArach

[CountArach]

Damn typing! I just realised I said:

but I shall Vote: Stig for appearing far too eager to vote for someone.

I meant to say too eager to kill a single person. Rather than thinking through new evidence, he just follows an old trail.

[Hepcat]

Damn typing! I just realised I said:


I meant to say too eager to kill a single person. Rather than thinking through new evidence, he just follows an old trail.

It's interesting how your post at the start of the game showed how determined you were to kill someone.

I would vote Hanky, but we all know that this is the way he feels.

Vote: Martok

Prove you are innocent.

I don't trust you. By your own reasoning we should be suspicious of you. My vote stays where it is.

[Beefy187]

Suicide is where the players ask the host to kill them. WoG is where the player get killed by the host fro not being active.

CA seems suspecious. But my vote stays. Maybe ill go for him next round.

All alive players should post what they think about CA or kills in the past rounds so least people get a clue about stuff.

[Sarathos]

Sarathos seems to be spamming like he normally does

I dont spam.....

[Sarathos]

I voted Sarathos - he seemed a bit too inquisitive about who was mafia, like hes trying to hide that he is.

Woaw woaw man, i just asked two questions. Just trying to make conversation and maybe a bit of evidence or hints.....

[Sarathos]

What ever happened to Lurker Pride, Sarathos?

I still got it Woads, dont worry. Its just in this game I cant lurk to much or I will get WOGED.

[Sarathos]

Sarathos lurks then spams then lurks again most of the time

You normally just get lynchd/killed......

[Sarathos]

Vote: TwilightBlade for being so negatibe, unhelpful and so ragey (if that is even a word). Settle down TBlade and help us win.

[Sarathos]

Well I think i have answered all the questions and aided the discussion a fair bit now, I have done enough posting so someone else please take over.

[FactionHeir]

Sarathos seems to be spamming like he normally does

I dont spam.....

You really could have put all that in 1 post, at most 2.

[CountArach]

It's interesting how your post at the start of the game showed how determined you were to kill someone.
[SNIP]
I don't trust you. By your own reasoning we should be suspicious of you. My vote stays where it is.

I don't understand... My reasoning is that insisting that someone is lynched at the exclusion of all other people's evidence and arguments (As Stig did) is both scummy and unhelpful. It generates no extra conversation.

[Stig]

Stig, you seem incredibly eager to see shlin killed. Is there any particular reason to this. I will FoS: shlin for trying to tip the vote at the end of yesterday, but I shall Vote: Stig for appearing far too eager to vote for someone.

Shlin has been acting suspicious for the last 2 days.
But then, so have you.

Mafia: Shlin and CA ... nice possibility.
I'd say we tie them up, and let them fight it out.

[Beefy187]

I could lynch Sarathos for 3 reasons
1. Spamming
2. Bad reasoning of the vote
3. For being who he is

Ok back to the topic. It would be appreciated if someone can make some tally because im a little busy right now. If its Shlin vs CA i say CA is more scummy. Also i dont like the way Brave Sir Robin, Sarathos, Twilightblade, Factionheir are playing. So FOS them all.

[Northnovas]

Suicide is where the players ask the host to kill them. WoG is where the player get killed by the host fro not being active.

CA seems suspecious. But my vote stays. Maybe ill go for him next round.

All alive players should post what they think about CA or kills in the past rounds so least people get a clue about stuff.

Though I cannot do a statement analysis from the post I have to go with what I have been told.

We are in a mountain area that has snow and therefore is cold.
2 townies have been lynched
2 committed suicide
6 members have been murdered
There are 3 killers I think. 2 are Mafia; raven hair and sinister. The other killer only descriptors hiss in his talk, likes collecting things possible serial

Day 1

2 murders to start mercs/ raven hair and sinister/ Bodies are decapped and mutilated the heads are found in the soup

no townies but a member is lynched ichigo

Day 2

pevergreen/ raven hair/ mafia/ MOD drug overdose
Sigurd/ sinister/ mafia/ MOD blowed up and blowed up good too
Tiberius/ hissy/ serial/ MOD mutilated and lunch

Killfr3nzy lynched

Day 3

3 more murders and 2 suicides

Zain/ raven hair/ mafia/ MOD ice pick bleeds out
Garcilaso/ hissy/ serial/ MOD knife in the heart
Roadkill/ sinister/ mafia/ MOD run over playing on the road

Suicides

Enoch
Greaterhaan

I don't who they are yet but there should be 3 person of interest.

[Omanes Alexandrapolites]

Vote: woad&fangs

Was this post just a misunderstanding, or a sinister attempt to ensure that you look innocent? This vote is subject to change should you provide me with an adequate reason for your "mistake".

I also want to point the finger of suspicion Sarathos, for his abnormal rapid posting spree. Have you lost your edit button through warning points, or are you trying to increase your apparent in thread post count to avoid any suspicion being aroused over you? Correct me if I'm wrong, but as far as I remember, this isn't his usual behaviour.

Finally, I want to think about shlin. I am beginning to doubt his guilt the more I consider it, but I still am yet to trust him after his peculiar voting and post analysis actions earlier in the game. I am willing to place these ideas down to the fact that he is still learning, though, for now at least.

[Xiahou]

Vote: Abstain
for now....

[Jubal_Barca]

I agree with omanes. vote woad.