My only criticisms for the Germanic units are concerning helmets. The first is that I think that a few too many units have helmets- for instance, why do Germanic light cavalry have helmets? I can understand heavy cavalry owning them, but not light cavalry. The second is that the form of the leather helmet that many units wear is really strange; I understand that there are no actual examples to work from, but I really doubt that a leather helmet like that would have had separate cheekpieces.

For the rest, however, they are definitely one of the best factions in EB. The revamp got rid of almost all the old questionable reconstructions and the new conservative reconstructions suit them well.