The Brothel - Large Mafia Game [Concluded]

[Craterus]

Trying to reason your way out of a lynch only ever seems to incriminate you further in the first round but, since you asked nicely, here's what I think. I don't see how it's logical that myself or Andres must be mafia/puritan. 2 extra players doesn't mean one is town and the other mafia. Roles aren't handed out to the ratio of 1:1 in mafia games.

[Andres]

Trying to reason your way out of a lynch only ever seems to incriminate you further in the first round but, since you asked nicely, here's what I think. I don't see how it's logical that myself or Andres must be mafia/puritan. 2 extra players doesn't mean one is town and the other mafia. Roles aren't handed out to the ratio of 1:1 in mafia games.

Indeed

[FactionHeir]

I see, both of you trying to shift the blame and appear innocent.

[Andres]

I see, both of you trying to shift the blame and appear innocent.

The mere fact that we were the last to join the game doesn't increase the chance of us being mafia. That's just bad logic.

[Craterus]

Shift what blame? There haven't been any kills yet.

What's more, I didn't mention anyone's name, I'm hardly shifting the blame. At this stage, I'm as clueless as everybody else.

[FactionHeir]

The mere fact that we were the last to join the game doesn't increase the chance of us being mafia. That's just bad logic.

So you are saying that Omanes had assigned 4 mafiosi already with only 17 players of the original 20+ he was aiming for? Since you two joined after the initial distribution and made it 19 he just made you townies?
I think not.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Omanes said that each mafioso/Puritan could kill one person every two nights.

With the extra 2 players, it's extremely unlikely that both new players are mafiosi. With the one though, maybe. The mafia would get an extra kill every two days. This may not seem like much, but considering that there really aren't that many people playing and there is the possibility of townie kill groups, this game could be over very quickly. I personally think that Andres and Craterus are both townies.

[FactionHeir]

But then again we don't know what your role is. For all we know you could be their scum buddy.

[Andres]

But then again we don't know what your role is. For all we know you could be their scum buddy.

Back to your inquisitorial style? Or is that still subject to change?

The fact that GH might be scum doesn't mean that his statement is incorrect.

[FactionHeir]

Of course not, I don't think both of you are, but one of you probably is. Still I doubt both of you are town.

[Andres]

Of course not, I don't think both of you are, but one of you probably is. Still I doubt both of you are town.

And the only reason is the fact that we were the last to join the game?

What do you think about Beefy187 who just quoted your (questionable) reasoning and voted Craterus?

[FactionHeir]

I'm more interested why you are questioning me now. You are still the suspect.

[Andres]

I'm more interested why you are questioning me now. You are still the suspect.

Aren't we all suspects?

[FactionHeir]

I'm town. One of you two isn't. Of course you may just view it the same way.

[GeneralHankerchief]

I'm town. One of you two isn't. Of course you may just view it the same way.

Are you referring to Andres and me or Andres and Craterus?

[Beefy187]

Im guessing FH meant Andres and Craterus.

Seeing as when those two joined roles were already given out normally I would say those two are innocent. However given the amount of players in this game it is also likely that those two recieved either extra mafia roles or pro town roles.
So lynching one of you could end up killing a important town role but chance of being mafia is rather higher compared to others. Thats the reason of me voting for Craterus.

I thought its a good enough reasoning for round 1 rather then "my hunch says..."

[Craterus]

but chance of being mafia is rather higher compared to others.

How?

[Beefy187]

How?

ok i see a hole in my logic. Ill take that back.

Unvote: Craterus vote: anelious phyyrus

[Omanes Alexandrapolites]

Day I Conclusion
As the voting concluded, and after several moments of counting, there appeared to be one clear lynch target - pevergreen. After several moments of struggling and attempting to persuade those around him of his innocence, pevergreen was taken to the top of a flight of stairs within the brothel and thrown off. It took three repeats of this to kill him, the first providing a crack as his arm broke under the strain, the second knocking him out and breaking both his legs, and the final resulting in the fracturing of his skull following by dramatic levels of internal bleeding. Within ten minutes, pevergreen had breathed his final breath.

pevergreen has been lynched!

Tally:
pevergreen 3 (anelious phyros, Craterus, makaikhaan)

Beefy187 2 (Rythmic,Caius)
FactionHeir 2 (GeneralHankerchief, Andres)
makaikhaan 2 (TevashSzat, Tratorix)

Tratorix - 1 (El Diablo)
TevashSzat - 1 (Sigurd Fafnesbane)
Andres - 1 (FactionHeir)
GeneralHankerchief - 1 (shlin28)
Caius - 1 (Cronos Impera)
anelious phyros - 1 (Beefy187)
Craterus - 1 (CrazedRabbit)

Night I begins! All actions must be PMed to me by approximately 08:00 (GMT+1) on Friday the 11th of July. This is a total of about 24-hrs.

Alive (18):
Andres
anelious phyros
Beefy187
Caius
Craterus
Crazed Rabbit
Cronos Impera
El Diablo
Elite Ferret
FactionHeir
GeneralHankerchief
makaikhaan
Quintus.J.Cicero
Rythmic
shlin28
Sigurd Fafnesbane
TevashSzat
Tratorix

Lynched (1):
pevergreen (formerly peverpink)

Killed (0):

WoGed (0):

Suicided (0):

[Sigurd]

nvm...

[Csargo]

If you need to replace someone Omanes, send me a PM and I'd be glad to.

[Omanes Alexandrapolites]

Night I Conclusion
El Diablo was silently lying on the floor of the brothel. A cold draft swept across the floor and the moth bitten woollen blankets provided little protection from this.

As he stood up to move out of the way of this draft, he saw a man shivering in the corner of the room, whimpering slightly as if he was crying or was injured. As El Diablo walked forward to try and establish what was wrong, this little man charged forward brandishing a dagger which he must have been hiding behind his back. El Diablo was literally ripped apart by the dagger and was left rapidly dying in a pool of his own blood. Before he left however, the killer did one thing - he made an incision in the area containing the liver and ripped the vital organ out.

****

El Diablo has been killed!

Day II begins! This day phase will conclude at about 19:00 (GMT+1) on Sunday the the 13th of July. This is a total of 60 hours - an extension is needed to optimise the timings for my own personal schedule.

Alive (17):
Andres
anelious phyros
Beefy187
Caius
Craterus
Crazed Rabbit
Cronos Impera
Elite Ferret
FactionHeir
GeneralHankerchief
makaikhaan
Quintus.J.Cicero
Rythmic
shlin28
Sigurd Fafnesbane
TevashSzat
Tratorix

Lynched (1):
pevergreen (formerly peverpink)

Killed (1):
El Diablo

WoGed (0):

Suicided (0):

BTW, Ichigo, thanks for your offer - I'll drop you a PM if somebody is WoGed or suicided

[Andres]

Vote : makaikhaan

Talk

[naut]

Why take the liver?

[Caius]

Tratorix - 1 (El Diablo)

There could be a coincidence. Might as well Tratorix should come and defend himself, it could be framing.

[TevashSzat]

Vote : makaikhaan

Talk

I need to hear some talking from him too...Vote: makaikhaan

Tally:

makaikhaan 2 (Andres, TevashSzat)

[seireikhaan]

Hmm, talk? About what? Well, lets see, I went to orientation for uni a couple days ago, found out my roommate is an evangelical redneck, my room is boiling hot in the summer, played 3 straight full court games of basketball at our very nice rec center, and I signed up for my classes, most of which don't have anything to do with my major, but are instead core classes that uni makes us take anyways.

Vote: FactionHeir, for antagonizing people with the

[shlin28]

Hmmmmmm...

This morning when I came in for a look at the thread I distinctively remember there was another paragraph in the write-up, however, due to the fact that I really need to go I did not read it and only looked at who had died...

What are you hiding from us Omanes?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Vote: FactionHeir

I really don't like the way he's been acting. He's maintaining way too much that Andres and/or Craterus is mafia when really, it's been proven that there's no way of knowing. I think in my explanation post he totally discounted it and said that he couldn't trust it because I might be scum.

I'd like a little more than that dismissive refutation, please, but even that probably won't be enough for me to change my vote.

[Cronos Impera]

Vote: Caius

I keep constant to my previous vote for the same obvious reasons....and will keep doing that untill the end.