
Originally Posted by
cmacq
I'm sorry, thats the point.
Verhoeven thought he was making an anti-war/anti-american flick, that would discredit the precept of the novel, yet in fact he failed in the worst way, as it is neither anti-war, anti-american, nor did it do harm to the book's standing. And Verhoeven, the guy that made the movie still dosen't get it. On top of this critics that think the same as he, grossly misinterpreted the intent of the Imagery used in the movie, branded him with the f word, and consequently help hurt his career (in part due to the tenets of correct speech). Now, that’s what I bloody well call satirical.
Right,
by the way the USA’s republic is only eight years older than the Kingdom of the Netherlands. The glory days of the Dutch Republic are long gone. Besides the Dutch of that era had their own witches to burn (Roermond Netherlands 1613). Of course, as Verhoeven tosses that f word around so much, he may mistake the symbolic nature of the device/artifact and its relationship to a Republic, say the Roman Republic for example. All subtle, but very important points.
With all this said, I very much agree with Conrad about the novel and at least the first movie.
Still, I view Team America as a parody, while SST, a failed hit job that actually made good.
CmacQ
Bookmarks