I think Limbaugh would most likely be a good neighbor. The other 3? Not so much. Olbermann/O'Rly both seem like egotistical rage junkies (on and off air afaik) and Matthews seems like he would just be.... creepy.

This was an online poll wasn't it? I'd be mildly curious to see how the results would be in a scientific poll- I'll hold my breath.