Poll: Which one has the more difficult job?

Results 1 to 28 of 28

Thread: Admiral or General?

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1
    Camel Lord Senior Member Capture The Flag Champion Martok's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2002
    Location
    In my own little world....but it's okay, they know me there.
    Posts
    8,257

    Question Admiral or General?

    Which do you think is more difficult to command, an army or a fleet? I'm not referring to just in combat -- I'm also thinking of things like supply, logistics, etc.

    This has been one of those "in the back of my mind" questions that I've been mulling for a while, and I'm no closer to a conclusion now than when I first began contemplating it. I'm curious as to what your thoughts are.
    Last edited by Martok; 08-23-2008 at 21:19.
    "MTW is not a game, it's a way of life." -- drone

  2. #2
    A very, very Senior Member Adrian II's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Location
    The Netherlands
    Posts
    9,748

    Default Re: Admiral or General?

    Quote Originally Posted by Martok View Post
    Which do you think is more difficult to command, an army or a fleet? I'm not referring to just in combat -- I'm also thinking of things like supply, logistics, etc.

    This has been one of those "in the back of my mind" questions that I've been mulling for a while, and I'm no closer to a conclusion now than when I first began contemplating it. I'm curious as to what your thoughts are.
    I never gave it a thought. I know for a fact that in the 17th and 18th centuries the Navy was generally regarded as a wastebin for less talented (to put it mildly) sons of well-to-do families. Epitomized by Admiral Sir George Rodney telling his officers: "Gentlemen, the painful task of thinking belongs to me."
    The bloody trouble is we are only alive when we’re half dead trying to get a paragraph right. - Paul Scott

  3. #3
    Poll Smoker Senior Member CountArach's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    Sydney, Australia
    Posts
    9,029

    Default Re: Admiral or General?

    I would say an Admiral because once things start going wrong, it is much harder to get them to start going your way again.
    Last edited by CountArach; 08-23-2008 at 22:27.
    Rest in Peace TosaInu, the Org will be your legacy
    Quote Originally Posted by Leon Blum - For All Mankind
    Nothing established by violence and maintained by force, nothing that degrades humanity and is based on contempt for human personality, can endure.

  4. #4
    Just your average Senior Member Warmaster Horus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Besancon, France: a stepping stone to greatness. I hope.
    Posts
    2,940

    Default Re: Admiral or General?

    I voted gah! simply because someone has to, and because I think their jobs are relatively equally difficult. Both have different things to overcome: an admiral has more difficulty changing things to his advantage and has to adapt to a dangerous battlefield (if there's a storm and a ship's out...), whereas the general has maybe more things to consider in an operation: civilian population, must sometimes adapt to guerrilla warfare (especially these days).
    The Throne Room: "Less a forum, more a way of life." Econ21
    Don't hesitate to visit the Mead Hall! A little more reading, a little less shouting, please.
    Join the latest greatest installement of mafia games: Capo di Tutti Capi!
    Check out the Gahzette!
    By the by, are you interested in helping out the Gahzette? Think you could be a writer, reporting on the TW or Org community? Then check the Gahzette Thread or drop me a PM!


    Back.

  5. #5
    Member Member KrooK's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2005
    Location
    Kraj skrzydlatych jeźdźców
    Posts
    1,083

    Default Re: Admiral or General?

    Depends what kind of admiral or whats kind of general it is. I voted on general because he had more units to command. Admiral has some ships - usually few teens. General has some thousands of soldiers.
    John Thomas Gross - liar who want put on Poles responsibility for impassivity of American Jews during holocaust

  6. #6
    Senior Member Senior Member Quintus.JC's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    UK
    Posts
    2,572

    Default Re: Admiral or General?

    I voted Gah. Its an interesting topic though, I always had this discussion with my graphics teacher about this, my graphic teacher is a rather patriotic British guy and a huge fan of Admiral Nelson. As a player of TW I'm not much into naval warfare (not yet, at least) and generally I prefered Napoleon and Wellington. I have no idea about the responsiblilties of an admiral though.

  7. #7
    Emperor of the Brutii Member Emperor Mithdrates's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    Imperial Palace, Croton, Southern Italy
    Posts
    145

    Default Re: Admiral or General?

    compared to generals who command a man to move around (which is quite simple) Admirals have to try and gety huge and unmanoverable warships into battle formations in limited time while trying not to collide with other ships. Also communication is done by small flags and can take a while for orders to get across.
    [B][I]"Sometimes you have to serve in order to lead." - Odysseus: King of Ithaca

    "We have the best archers in the world and our walls have never been taken, We can win this war!" - General Briskais of Troy


  8. #8
    Retired Senior Member Prince Cobra's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    In his garden planting Aconitum
    Posts
    1,449
    Blog Entries
    1

    Default Re: Admiral or General?

    I think the Amdiral. In the past, a single storm could ruin your plans...

    Yet most of the battles are on land and unless you are fortunate enough to live on island, you should rely on your generals. But that's another story. Voted admiral.
    R.I.P. Tosa...


  9. #9
    Member Member Mangudai's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Location
    The Middle West
    Posts
    178

    Default Re: Admiral or General?

    The General has the harder job. The general has to manage the morale of his men in a thousand different ways. He has to BE a man who inspires confidence in everyone around him. If the troops begin to loose confidence in their general, disaster is right around the corner. The general also has to understand and manage the attitudes of civilians.

    The Admiral can do a good job with analysis and good judgement. He has less impact on morale than the captains under him, and in any case morale is less important because a sailors' duty is more straitforward.

    Many of us computer nerds are good at tactics, but unless you were the most popular guy in high school you probably wouldn't make a great general.

  10. #10
    Vermonter and Seperatist Member Uesugi Kenshin's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Location
    The Mountains.
    Posts
    3,868

    Default Re: Admiral or General?

    Quote Originally Posted by Mangudai View Post
    The General has the harder job. The general has to manage the morale of his men in a thousand different ways. He has to BE a man who inspires confidence in everyone around him. If the troops begin to loose confidence in their general, disaster is right around the corner. The general also has to understand and manage the attitudes of civilians.

    The Admiral can do a good job with analysis and good judgement. He has less impact on morale than the captains under him, and in any case morale is less important because a sailors' duty is more straitforward.

    Many of us computer nerds are good at tactics, but unless you were the most popular guy in high school you probably wouldn't make a great general.
    I agree with some of your points here, but navies have been crippled by morale issues simply because ships cannot move without the sailors, and the sailors don't usually like being on the ships for extremely long periods of time without a chance to rip loose in a city. Just a thought.
    "A man's dying is more his survivor's affair than his own."
    C.S. Lewis

    "So many people tiptoe through life, so carefully, to arrive, safely, at death."
    Jermaine Evans

  11. #11
    Sage Member Wasp's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Brabant, the Netherlands
    Posts
    319

    Default Re: Admiral or General?

    I voted for the Admiral, but mainly because of logistics. It requires a lot of thinking ahead. A General has to do that as well, of course, but can make last-minute decisions.
    The purpose of a fish trap is to catch fish, and when the fish are caught, the trap is forgotten. The purpose of a rabbit snare is to catch rabbits. When the rabbits are caught, the snare is forgotten. The purpose of words is to convey ideas. When the ideas are grasped, the words are forgotten. Where can I find a man who has forgotten words? He is the one I would like to talk to.

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO