Order Of The Stick Mafia [Concluded]

[robbiecon]

I will stick with Vote: Renata.

[Secura]

Why does Renata get your vote, robbiecon?

We're reaching the end-game now, simply casting your vote won't wash at this stage. :3

[Askthepizzaguy]

I will stick with Vote: Renata.

Sure.

Vote: Renata


Apparently I decided against vig killing last night. I wonder why.

[God Emperor]

I thought I would be dead by now :O anyway I guess it's time to go back in the thread and look at people's behavior

[Secura]

FFFFFFFFFFFFFFUUUUU-

What are the reasons for these votes? Is there not going to be any discussion or anything?

I can tell that being dead is going to infuriate me to no end. ¬_¬

[Askthepizzaguy]

Theory is that Renata bussed her partner on a round where there was no good vote for the mafia.

I'll be back in 8 hours or so to see if there's any reason to vote anyone else.

[Romanic]

The case about Beskar is that he has made a lot of defensive posts so far (on why his vote on WH wasn't a grudge, why he didn't kill WH, why he isn't mafia), and not so many useful posts.

I cannot find a single post where he appears to be looking for scum.

Also, a look at his vote gives me the feeling that he doesn't care much:

D1, voted Winston Hughes (Town), as a joke.
D2, voted Autolycus (Serial Killer) because he was 3rd on the Beskar bandwagon (lol)
But this vote is also an attempt to save himself, which was very possibly his main motivation for voting autolycus,
D3 Voted God Emperor, simply because GE was voting for him.
Later, moved his vote on robbiecon because "he came out of nowhere". Both votes are bad cases.

Lastly, each time I spoke privately with Beskar about this game, his answers were quick and no attempt to "solve" the game were made by him.

Bottom line, Beskar is a bad townie, or he's motivated by his scum alignment.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I believe he's a bad townie.

If he were scum he'd care more, and at least attempt to deflect criticism by trying harder.


Remember, townies suck. Mafia rule. If someone is doing a bang-up job, I gotta know why.

[Beskar]

Vote: Renata

She is the mafia.

[Secura]

Remember, townies suck.

[Beskar]

Bottom line, Beskar is a bad townie, or he's motivated by his scum alignment.

Erm.... no. I am not "bad" townie.

What about you? You walk around with a stick in your ear pretending you rule the world. Let's look at your votes.

D1 - You voted a Haley from the Order on Round 1 and got them lynched, randomly swapping votes for no reason at all. (Haley was most likely pro-town too, OOPS!)
D2 - Instead of great reasoning by Beskar, you mention that autolycus is most likely innocent. You finally get convinced to unvote an innocent (me) and vote a different innocent (Seon). (Great Going, LOL)
D3 - You jump on a bandwagon and lynch Cecil, you contributed nothing else other than flip more votes than a flipping seal.

So if I am "bad" townie, what does this make you?

At least I admit I have no abilities at all and working on pure guesswork. You talk as if you know the entire game when it is so far from the truth, you past Uranus and currently on Pluto.

The mafia are either God Emperor or Renata.

[Romanic]

I'm not going to debate why I am a better townie than you in this game Beskar. It's so obviously true that I would only be wasting my time.

[Secura]

You walk around with a stick in your ear pretending you rule the world.

And that's how the Order of the Stick was formed. :P

[Beskar]

I'm not going to debate why I am a better townie than you in this game Beskar. It's so obviously false that I would only be wasting my time.

I agree entirely with the correction.

And that's how the Order of the Stick was formed. :P

Touché

[God Emperor]

let's see..

Renata has made a lot of posts which says absolutely nothing - is that normal of her?

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Has it really been that long? *boggles*

Now there's an idea. *takes notes*

Thanks, DE.

Miko's been a bad, bad girl.

Also, lol.

I still love you, Miko, even if you were actually Belkar.

Best strategy, never fails.

She gave Cecil a vote that put him in the lead on round one.. that is a good vote , though it may be placed to distance herself. not sure about that though.

Yarapolk has been lurking the entire game and only to show up when a vote was placed on him.. Does anyone knows his normal style ? There isn't much else to say about him I think

Beskar.. well I have said many times over what I think about what he is doing in this game. . . else I would second what Romanic wrote just before.
I spoke with Beskar in private about his 'now with autolycus dead, I am cleared' . . what he meant was apparently that he was clear of the murder on... classical hero(?) , which would be true.

ATPG never struck me as off in this game.. and iirc he said YLC playes like he is always playing when he is town.. YLC has hardly made any posts in this game.

Then there is Romanic. only made one thing which struck me is strange, and that was how quickly he took his vote off -- Beskar I think it was. However all the rest of his play seems like how he is when he is town.

did I miss out anyone ? anyway it's imo down to those 3; Renata, Yarapolk, Beskar

[robbiecon]

I assure you Beskar, that Romanic has been exceptional behind the scenes.

Also, GE, Yaropolk is accounted for. He, like myself has been more active behind the scenes than in-thread, but he's been a useful asset too.

[God Emperor]

right I completely forgot about you robbie ! you have been almost gone from the gamethread as well. What have the behind-the-scenes activity been about? and how come you are in contact with Yarapolk ?

[Romanic]

I assure you Beskar, that Romanic has been exceptional behind the scenes.

Also, GE, Yaropolk is accounted for. He, like myself has been more active behind the scenes than in-thread, but he's been a useful asset too.

I don't know if I can slap you hard enough for revealing this.

[Beskar]

This is my behind the scenes with Romanic and others, in short:

R - "Are you mafia?"
B - "No, I am vanilla town role with no abilities."

R - "It is obvious you killed Winston Hughes"
B - "Not really, if anything, it is obvious it isn't, especially since he flipped over a first round vote."

R - "Why are you voting Autolycus? He is most likely innocent."
B - "He evidently isn't innocent (lists reasons I already said in thread)"
R - "Oh, okay, I still think he is town."

R - "Did you investigate me last night and tell Renata?"
B - "No, I have no abilities"
R - "You always talk to Renata"

They were great in-depth conversations. These are my other ones.

S - "Awww, I am vanilla townie again. :( :( :("

and

GE - "You are mafia, because you are mafia, like in Council of Villians and Lylat Wars"
B - "I was a neutral in Lylat Wars"
GE - "Still, you are scum"
B - "Okay"

and

Pizza - "You are going to be investigated tonight, if you are cleared, I know who the mafia is."
B - "Well, I am innocent, but if you really want to go ahead..."

and

Renata - "I'm tired, How are you?"
B - "I am fine thanks, how is it going?"

and

YLC - "I have to admit Beskar, you are a hero of mine, can I have an autograph?"
B - "Sure."
YLC - "PUNKED!!"

[Secura]

S - "Awww, I am vanilla townie again. :( :( :("

True story!

[Romanic]

I think it would be interesting to post the chat logs, to show how Beskar is misrepresenting what was actually said, but who cares? This is typically Beskar.

[robbiecon]

I don't know if I can slap you hard enough for revealing this.

I think you need this:

[Beskar]

Only the YLC one was made up. The others are just short versions.

Anyway, according to Pizza, I would have been investigated. Since there is no one claiming they investigated me and I am guilty, pretty sure sign I am not the mafia.

[Yaropolk]

unvote; vote:Renata

[Askthepizzaguy]

I claimed Beskar was going to be investigated because I wanted to see if the investigator would die or if I would, or what.

I also wanted to see his reaction, like God Emperor's when I claimed I was going to vig him.

I am not a believer in truth-telling except where I think it's actually useful to do so.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Does anyone have any evidence clearing Renata? My PM box is open.

[God Emperor]

I didn't check the tally, but I believe Renata is in the lead. making room for a change of heart Vote: Beskar

[Askthepizzaguy]

I didn't check the tally, but I believe Renata is in the lead. making room for a change of heart Vote: Beskar

This is why I think you're the Godfather. Just know, I will be voting for you next round, and I'm not buying investigation results on you, taking them in any way as exonerating.

[God Emperor]

investigation results ?

Edit: and do you believe it's wrong not to make runaway bandwagons ? I thought that was the lesson learned from the previous games

[Askthepizzaguy]

investigation results ?

Edit: and do you believe it's wrong not to make runaway bandwagons ? I thought that was the lesson learned from the previous games

Yes, of course. I just believe that it is now being used as an excuse for people to openly support their mafia partner, under the guise of lessons learned.

Situations change, scumtells are updated to reflect the new situation.