Mafia X [Concluded]

**Earthling** · 06-30-2011, 22:32

Well Johnny probably was not scum is why, might as well hear from him, he can't be worse than Connie or Vincent or any of the other lynchees trying to tell stuff to the town.

Luigi and Richie voting together to save Richie, that's a lot more interesting as a possibility though. We could finally just kill off (assuming Richie's fake ability is fake of course) Luigi tomorrow if any of the townies are bothering to try.

**[MAFIA] Angelo** · 06-30-2011, 22:36

Originally Posted by Earthling

Well Johnny probably was not scum is why, might as well hear from him, he can't be worse than Connie or Vincent or any of the other lynchees trying to tell stuff to the town.

Well I ain't listening to them either and what makes you say Johnny was probably innocent?

**Earthling** · 06-30-2011, 22:57

The game didn't end did it? So he wasn't the last scum.

And if you assume he was scum, then where was his partner and why didn't he even bother to try to defend himself? There were TWO, not one, alternate bandwagons and a couple votes on either could have at least tied it up and possibly kept Johnny alive. Yet neither he nor any supposed partner even tried to defend him when they easily could have had the votes to do so.

Plus, it's not like Johnny was ever really guilty of anything close to what several still-living suspects are. A couple bandwagon votes, when at this point in the game everybody has bandwagonned some, and an OMGUS by Anne? Populus/Johnny looks like a clear townie is all.

We're probably only going to get two more lynches total. And Luigi has to die, preferably in the next one, unless Richie somehow is telling the truth and comes through on a vigkill. We don't need people making the wrong assumptions about past lynchees being scum and overlooking obvious suspects.

**[MAFIA] Angelo** · 06-30-2011, 23:14

Well to clear up a few things:
We get 2-3 lynches, depending on how many scums are left when we enter D11
If we don't get both of them before that there'll be 4 people left on D 11 so if two of them are scum the town's defeated. If only one of them is there'll be one more lynch. Or GH allows a double lynch like he did in Mafia I but I doubt that.

Richie is most probably lying about this secret power. As far as I understood this game is designed as a continuation of the original Mafia like it was in the beginning, celebrating the start of the Gameroom. The first Mafia didn't even have a detective, let alone a vigilante, none of the games in the series had one of those... so I highly doubt GH would put one in this game.

About Johnny: So now you're a townie by not defending yourself against false accusations?

**[MAFIA] Sonny** · 06-30-2011, 23:24

Just lynch Fat Tony tomorrow.

**Earthling** · 07-01-2011, 00:06

Originally Posted by [MAFIA] Angelo

About Johnny: So now you're a townie by not defending yourself against false accusations?

Well yeah, or else you're a really suicidal and incompetent Mafia, but is it really the best idea to assume that and run with it? He didn't defend himself and didn't even place his vote where it could have gotten him out of a lynch. Combine that with him not being guilty of anything particularly bad or unusual, and it doesn't look like he was scum.

**Populus Romanus** · 07-01-2011, 00:42

About Johnny: So now you're a townie by not defending yourself against false accusations?

I was going to unvote and vote for Richie, but never got around to it. I wouldn't say Anne isn't scum, but other people are better lynches. Like Richie. What is this about him claiming he has a "special power?" Because this is a vanilla game, the only special power he could have is to murder people. He has to be lying.

**[MAFIA] Sonny** · 07-01-2011, 13:42

Originally Posted by Populus Romanus

I was going to unvote and vote for Richie, but never got around to it. I wouldn't say Anne isn't scum, but other people are better lynches. Like Richie. What is this about him claiming he has a "special power?" Because this is a vanilla game, the only special power he could have is to murder people. He has to be lying.

Course he's lyin. That's the whole

point, if Richie's a townie. Toss out a pile of cow

as been dressed up to look like apple pie, an see who comes in an laps it up. If Richie's a mafia, he don't expect to be believed, he expect the rest of us decide a scum won't do

like that.

**White_eyes:D** · 07-01-2011, 03:12

Originally Posted by Earthling

Well Johnny probably was not scum is why, might as well hear from him, he can't be worse than Connie or Vincent or any of the other lynchees trying to tell stuff to the town.

Why would town listen to lynched townies???(who could be mafia and providing false info on purpose)