You're committing the common error of showing a lack of foresightedness. Fluffy:
a) Has just as much a chance of being scum as anyone else, and since no real cases have jumped out this round he is an equally valid option anyway,
b) Is impossible to analyze in the endgame, when the chances of lynching a mafioso are significantly higher due to percentage
Getting rid of him now will save us all a lot of trouble in the rounds where we're more likely to catch a mafioso anyway. Since, as I pointed out in A, there aren't any real other cases going on, I fail to see why the Fluffy lynch today is an issue (aside from the fact that the bandwagon is picking up steam, but there's nothing you can do about that).
Bookmarks