Three Wolf Moon [Concluded]

**Ishmael** · 08-30-2011, 10:55

I do buy your logic, although it obviously isn't 100% conclusive, but I'm also voting Seamus for selfish reasons - if he turns out to be scum and I'm talked out of lynching him, I'll feel terribly embarrassed after the game is over (I'm looking at you, Visorslash).

**Askthepizzaguy** · 08-30-2011, 11:06

Originally Posted by Ishmael

I do buy your logic, although it obviously isn't 100% conclusive, but I'm also voting Seamus for selfish reasons - if he turns out to be scum and I'm talked out of lynching him, I'll feel terribly embarrassed after the game is over (I'm looking at you, Visorslash).

It's fair enough Ishmael. I'm just pushing theories out there, I can't vote, and I can't stop you from doing your own thing.

Your objective as of right now is to find out which one is the best lynch that I'm not recommending. Don't leave it up to me to solve this, please by all means scum-hunt. It's pro-town of you to do so.

Find the scums, gimme reasons.

**Visor** · 08-30-2011, 11:16

Originally Posted by Ishmael

I do buy your logic, although it obviously isn't 100% conclusive, but I'm also voting Seamus for selfish reasons - if he turns out to be scum and I'm talked out of lynching him, I'll feel terribly embarrassed after the game is over (I'm looking at you, Visorslash).

Who talked you out of lynching me? Monty?

**Ishmael** · 08-30-2011, 11:22

Originally Posted by Visorslash

Who talked you out of lynching me? Monty?

Myself

**Visor** · 08-30-2011, 11:29

**Ishmael** · 08-30-2011, 11:32

I'll take a different approach to ATPG, and list the people I think aren't scum (no way that this will come back to bite me later, no sirree):

Ishmael

Believer
Bestrfcplayer
Tratorix
Yarapolk (most questionable of this lot, I don't really know his style)

I frankly can't be bothered to trawl through the thread to find evidence to support this list, and it's based entirely on intuition anyway. I'm also not really sold on B_Ray being scummy, but I'll refrain from making any judgement at present. Finally, I don't want to touch the scan results with a ten foot stick at the moment, considering all the weird mechanisms that have been bandied about - I'll let other people analyse those.

**Askthepizzaguy** · 08-30-2011, 11:40

Originally Posted by Ishmael

I'll take a different approach to ATPG, and list the people I think aren't scum (no way that this will come back to bite me later, no sirree):

Ishmael

Believer
Bestrfcplayer
Tratorix
Yarapolk (most questionable of this lot, I don't really know his style)

I frankly can't be bothered to trawl through the thread to find evidence to support this list, and it's based entirely on intuition anyway. I'm also not really sold on B_Ray being scummy, but I'll refrain from making any judgement at present. Finally, I don't want to touch the scan results with a ten foot stick at the moment, considering all the weird mechanisms that have been bandied about - I'll let other people analyse those.

I believe you on Believer.
I believe you on Bestrfc (for now).
Yaropolk I'd scan, not lynch. He's leaving few tells for sure, and he's not very flinchy. But he's VERY good, I wouldn't count him out as scum based on this record this game. he's good enough to pull it off.

Tratorix, I get the scummy vibes from. His vote on Monty could be distancing, I'm anxious to see if he follows up this round on Monty.

As for yourself, getting better. But the vote on me plus the shirt still made no sense.

That's going to haunt you if we don't end this game quickly, Ishmael.

**Ishmael** · 08-30-2011, 11:45

Bear in mind that whilst I liked your idea of checking Memnon, I was seriously considering the possibility that you were Mafia pulling an all-or-nothing stunt that would either lynch you (but probably not your buddies), or win you all the game. Besides, I do play Mafia games for the purpose of enjoyment, and hence may not always do the most rational thing if it means I have fun (you'll note I was trying to break your 'streak' at the time

).

**Askthepizzaguy** · 08-30-2011, 11:50

Originally Posted by Ishmael

Bear in mind that whilst I liked your idea of checking Memnon, I was seriously considering the possibility that you were Mafia pulling an all-or-nothing stunt that would either lynch you (but probably not your buddies), or win you all the game. Besides, I do play Mafia games for the purpose of enjoyment, and hence may not always do the most rational thing if it means I have fun (you'll note I was trying to break your 'streak' at the time

).

Yeah, but (secret notebook open) I currently have you marked down as scum for using the "gimme" reasoning.

So reverse that opinion. You've got 2 rounds.

**Johhog** · 08-30-2011, 11:47

There is no way that Monty and Tratorix is scum together though, scum don't want to create connections among themselves in thread, as they did when they self voted for shirt and agreed on an alliance.

**Askthepizzaguy** · 08-30-2011, 11:52

Originally Posted by Johhog

There is no way that Monty and Tratorix is scum together though, scum don't want to create connections among themselves in thread, as they did when they self voted for shirt and agreed on an alliance.

Well, to be fair, Monty wanted to agree on an alliance, I don't think Tratorix agreed to it.

And I agree, of the two, Monty is guilty and Trats is townie. But Tratorix is cunning as all heck, and you don't write HIM off for that move. It's evidence but not solid.