Three Wolf Moon [Concluded]

[johnhughthom]

Thanks for the game Zack.

Well played town, deserved victory.

[Believer]

Good game, all! Was fun while it lasted.

I very much enjoyed the discussion between ATPG and Montmorency. Very entertaining stuff. I was hopeful that ATPG's directioning wouldn't point to JHT or myself for a long time, but we didn't manage to fly under the radar. Probably should have been more vocal overall, and picked a side in the ATPG / Montmorency debate. Since neither side was correct in their main suspicions, I figured it would be safest to just stay out of the conversation, but that didn't work. I also didn't have the motivation to read all ATPG's posts, so I wasn't really prepared to argue about it one way or the other.

I'm not sure if not getting the shirt was actually disadvantageous for us (the scum) or not.

It was quite funny getting paired with JHT after his promise to get revenge on me killing him first in A Country for Old Men. And we did, in fact, kill Double A because JHT had promised he would do so at the next opportunity. That was nice.

Thanks for the game Zack.

Well played town, deserved victory.

Honorable opponents, Believer strongly approves. Well played.

[Seamus Fermanagh]

Zack, a fun game. Thanks.

First time I have ever been the focus of pizza's loving attention -- my but he can write, and some good analysis under it as well.

[Double A]

Over at TWC I've just told Double A I will kill him the very next time I get a chance to do so. Can we, can we, please, please, pretty please?

[Memnon]

WOOHOO! albeit a little anticlimactic, but I won my first game nonetheless! I actually thought that you were a dud lynch B_Ray, but i was wrong, okay, one game won(perfect record!) and the rest to go

[Askthepizzaguy]

Zack, a fun game. Thanks.

First time I have ever been the focus of pizza's loving attention -- my but he can write, and some good analysis under it as well.

The thing I did right was not be satisfied with one case, but examine a few people.

I managed to get it right on the third case, but Monty was acting so wrong that he went ahead of Johnhughthom.

Then he revealed as scum when he died; I'm sorta furious about that, no offense Monty. That tainted my analysis of everyone in the game.

Being paranoid about the scans and the chain was correct; since the scums could falsely clear themselves, that was a huge danger. Me scanning Memnon and promptly dying essentially cleared 3 townies at once, and by then, the blind lynches alone favored the town. We could afford to drop Monty and still nail the scums, even if there were 4 of them.

As I said, game would be balanced with 3-4 scums. An immortal detective (the shirt) is worth 1-2 scums easily.

Thanks be to those who cooperated with my interrogations.
Thanks be to those who did not take my accusations personally.
Thanks be to those of you who took a chance on me even though I was not scanned. That's using your own analytical abilities and you did well. I am impressed and you've turned around my impression of what townies can do, which as I said was at a low point lately.

I am guessing that Tratorix was assumed to have been scanned on the night he was killed; congrats to Believer for his excellent play all game but ALSO for guessing correctly on a townie that wasnt going to be murdered for the scan. Scanning Warman was the final nail in the coffin, really.

Tratorix did an excellent job with his far less wordy analysis of the game. Very well done.

I don't think I've seen a town more organized and united than they were on that final round. Our minds became one.

Resistance was indeed futile.

[Ishmael]

Yes! My first game that I both won and survived!

On a tangentially related note, why is it that people always suspect me? If I do end up being mafia in Capo, I'll have a life expectancy of about one day .

[Visor]

Good job.

On a tangentially related note, why is it that people always suspect me? If I do end up being mafia in Capo, I'll have a life expectancy of about one day .

I didn't suspect you in Vespasian.

Welcome to the club. About to be lynched early again as protown role.

[Askthepizzaguy]

About to be lynched early again as protown role.

God

I'll handle it, again.

[Visor]

God

I'll handle it, again.

Again? This game, and pretty much no other, really?

[Montmorency]

Man, I became so entangled in my convolutions that I couldn't divest myself of them even after they ceased being convincing to me. Well, at least I understood why town is always eager to lynch you. You set off these recursive panic alarms, and it's very stressful.

Maybe because it was a fairly small and simple game, everything turned out to be very straightforward. The Mafia never tried anything particularly devious or sneaky, and the town was spot-on by the midgame. Without my ravings the thread would have perfectly mirrored the game itself: a steely, relentless march against the Mafia. They never stood a chance.

In this game, the iron fists of the town meet the hollow bones of the Mafia - and break them.

Perhaps I should hope for similar attitudes to prevail in the future.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Man, I became so entangled in my convolutions that I couldn't divest myself of them even after they ceased being convincing to me. Well, at least I understood why town is always eager to lynch you. You set off these recursive panic alarms, and it's very stressful.

I am the player most prominently featured in any mafia quicktopic, primarily because I give that same reaction to the scums if I am anywhere close to being right.

Yep, proven townie dead pizza. Awesome.

JHT's reaction to me being dead proven townie in the QT just about sums it up. My first two cases were dead wrong AND I was urging a wagon on Monty instead of him, but you could already feel the enthusiasm slipping away with that comment.

I'm glad I pushed B_Ray onto my list of suspects, tied with Seamus for 3rd after Johnhughthom 2nd.

Monty.... Monty, Monty, we must discuss this whole admitting scum while not being scum thing.

[Montmorency]

I was heady with power.

[Believer]

I am guessing that Tratorix was assumed to have been scanned on the night he was killed; congrats to Believer for his excellent play all game but ALSO for guessing correctly on a townie that wasnt going to be murdered for the scan. Scanning Warman was the final nail in the coffin, really.

I'm starting to think you're coming on to me. :$

Thanks. :)

[Johhog]

Lolwut? Didn't Monty confess to being scum?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Lolwut? Didn't Monty confess to being scum?

Indeed he did. And we all told him how wrong that was.

That said, congratulations Monty and Tratorix on figuring out the twist of the game before anyone else; that the shirt wasn't reliable on the backs of a wolf, obviously.

It was so obvious I had to make sure that Memnon was town before we continued. I hate surprises.