Netherworld III: Final Judgment [Concluded]

[Choxorn]

johnhughthom is Ishtar. That should be obvious by now, and has been for a long time.

[Chaotix]

The only thing that I regret is not asking Ishtar out to dinner before I died.

She has such fine taste.

[Major Robert Dump]

presumably all the WoK'd were basic townies. Blackadder not being WoK'd is still rather bothersome, and MRD was not what he said he was, whatever it is he actually is, maybe he got preferential replacement due to being converted into the cult.

I was a vanilla townie, just like I said

[Askthepizzaguy]

I could.

And no, we don't. The cultists probably know or at least have a good enough suspect but they won't lynch her obviously. By the way, what explanation did she give for killing another one tonight? Defense mechanism against the last remaining scum... who cannot attack at night... and doesn't exist... ?

LYNCH ISHTAR!

No, I would rather see Ishtar eat everyone. That's hilarious and fitting.

[TheLastDays]

It is hilarious. I still want to be right

[Secura]

That should be obvious by now, and has been for a long time.

[Riedquat]

Of course not, how can all of you confuse a simple servant with a Goddess like me? I'm Ishtar!!!

Vote: warman

[ELITEofWARMANGINGERYBREADMEN88]

I just love how people waste votes on me. Tickes me funny!

[Secura]

I just love how people waste votes on me. Tickes me funny!

Don't you see what's going on, Warman? The votes against you are not 'wasted', because you're not being lynched as a possible mafia culprit in the first place; you're probably the sole remaining non-cult element remaining and this is just the cult removing the last obstacle in their path.

It's nothing personal, it's just good business.

[ELITEofWARMANGINGERYBREADMEN88]

Don't you see what's going on, Warman? The votes against you are not 'wasted', because you're not being lynched as a possible mafia culprit in the first place; you're probably the sole remaining non-cult element remaining and this is just the cult removing the last obstacle in their path.

It's nothing personal, it's just good business.

Yeah I know, I know I was going to die anyhow from them, via lynch or via night phrase.

[ELITEofWARMANGINGERYBREADMEN88]

Vote:johnhughthom

I just wish to dead with a full stomach of Cashews,Gingerbreadmen and Milk though please!

[TheLastDays]

Do we have to watch a lot more rounds like that?

[ELITEofWARMANGINGERYBREADMEN88]

I guess.

[Riedquat]

Do we have to watch a lot more rounds like that?

No! This is the final one, here and now I achieve my victory conditions and town too! You have my word! If game continues after this vote phase I will eat my own chariot!!

[TheLastDays]

Yeah, ok, as long as I don't see another zombie-round I'll even take a loss

[ELITEofWARMANGINGERYBREADMEN88]

No! This is the final one, here and now I achieve my victory conditions and town too! You have my word! If game continues after this vote phase I will eat my own chariot!!

So by voting a fellow townie you going to win the game for us?

[Riedquat]

So by voting a fellow townie you going to win the game for us?

I'm going to win the game for me and my minions! My victory conditions being town aligned are just a coincidence. And you being a fellow townie? :D Come on? You are so townie as TLD was ;)

[ELITEofWARMANGINGERYBREADMEN88]

Hey, I know what my role PM tells me whener you guys want to believe me or not !

[Renata]

TLD, I'm pretty sure you get to lose whether there's another zombie round or not.

[TheLastDays]

You're right.

[Earthling]

I was a vanilla townie, just like I said

No, you said you were a role with an ability and then got recruited and became a cultist, never being vanilla at any point. However, it's easy to accept you could be lying both then and here, doesn't really matter.

Blackadder- you ought to vote or else you get WoK'd, just as a friendly heads up. If it denies you cult victory I don't really care but would be a shame for you anyway.

I don't see Warman being a serial killer, classical_hero was a small chance and that sacrifice was smart by the cult, but then again I don't see why the game continued at all the past couple of days. The cult clearly had a majority and should have just won, doesn't even matter if they were anti-town (should have just won with majority) or not (all other scum eliminated anyway).

Very well played by the way Riedquat, whatever you are.

[Earthling]

The only thing that I regret is not asking Ishtar out to dinner before I died.

I did and got ignored :(

[johnhughthom]

I did and got ignored :(

Ishtar does not eat at McDonalds.

[Riedquat]

The cult clearly had a majority and should have just won

If it were for that we should had won like 6 days ago...

Very well played by the way Riedquat, whatever you are.

Thank you!

[Riedquat]

Ishtar does not eat at McDonalds.

Oh, my faithful servant, don't be jealous! There is enough love in me for everybody! ;)

[Earthling]

If it were for that we should had won like 6 days ago...

Well yeah, that's why the rest of the cultists probably aren't going to win and you'll just have a solo victory.

The chance that Warman is a serial killer whose elimination will cause town and cult victory is very low. As town victory isn't already achieved we pretty much know you're anti-town, and as the cult didn't win as a group it's a good guess there too.

Just out of curiousity, can you confirm if pizza was one of your cult recruits?

It already looks like he was because he kept providing bad suggestions for the town, implying a cult leader didn't exist and giving no opinions on who she was or that the town needed to get rid of her. Still, would be nice to have confirmation as I'm especially interested what people so worried about the dead talking will think in the end. Not that I'm not personally ok with everything he said, it was fine by me and this game was still much stricter than most with dead talking and did as well as any game could do I imagine, I'm not a fan of arbitrarily restrictive rules that never exactly work on that issue. But I still bet the situation for a few folks contradicts what some other players might have expected, for example, dead cultists still having access to the cult QT. If a living player was sending dead players PMs that clearly goes against what at least some people thought khaan's rules, but reading new posts on a quicktopic and trying to convey that information is really the same. pizza and maybe to a lesser extent other dead cult kept insisting repeatedly what he thought the living should do, based on information he couldn't share, and as there's no way for hosts or players to prove he was or wasn't reading up on the QT that's a little different than for the real dead townies. Also an observation for the future I guess, and we'll find out in the end eventually all the stuff we'd want to know about player status in this game, but just curious now.

[Riedquat]

Well yeah, that's why the rest of the cultists probably aren't going to win and you'll just have a solo victory.

Nonono, you're wrong here! I owe everything to my worshipers, their support has been paramount, there is not a chance of solo victory for me.

The chance that Warman is a serial killer whose elimination will cause town and cult victory is very low.

Again, who said anything about a serial killer? uh!?

Just out of curiosity, can you confirm if pizza was one of your cult recruits?

I can but I won't!

[Earthling]

The game would have ended as per the town victory condition if there was nobody left who is anti-town. If it's not you (by far the most likely though) and not Warman, you still have some serial killer/independent neutral who's infiltrated your group.

[Beskar]

The game would have ended as per the town victory condition if there was nobody left who is anti-town. If it's not you (by far the most likely though) and not Warman, you still have some serial killer/independent neutral who's infiltrated your group.

Also why Ishtar is doing the sacrificing for self-protection, since it wouldn't work on some one who infiltrated the job (or recruited out of it, like Andres)

And since Andres was recruited out of it after his revival, I believe that is why Ishtar sacrificed him incase.

[ELITEofWARMANGINGERYBREADMEN88]

The game would have ended as per the town victory condition if there was nobody left who is anti-town. If it's not you (by far the most likely though) and not Warman, you still have some serial killer/independent neutral who's infiltrated your group.

Indeed.