Capo di Tutti Capi IV [Concluded]

[scotchedpommes]

Vote: No Lynch

[gibsonsg91921]

i am tempted to vote a complelete inoffensive name because i feel like there is some weird energy around that other name he is saying, but then again it seems interesting and I want to know more about it

Vote: Skotsko because this isn't the flower child mafia, it's the lynch mob mafia.

[scotchedpommes]

What an excellent meatball of a reason.

[edse]

May I ask you to be more specific in your reasoning, edse?

Nope

[Believer]

Nope

Vote: edse

Totally valid.

[Suburban Plankton]

"I am gonna kill Earthling along with these people: Neri ; Crazed Rabbit; Diana Abnoba; Khaan


​And I am gonna laugh when he dies first night...hopefully."

Forgot about Neri participating because Neri has never talked to me. Crazed Rabbit sent his order in too late. As I have said before, go ahead and lynch me. I got books to read and a book blog to start.

I will hover around and answer questions, but otherwise I'm going inactive for tonight.

"Crazed Rabbit sent his order in too late"

Either

You made that bit up for some reason known only to yourself, which means you're a liar and need to be eliminated before you can become Made, or

You know that's true because you are both part of the same Family, which means you are Mafia and need to be eliminated before you kill us all, or

You actually believed Crazed Rabbit when he told you "sorry guy's, I meant to get in on the kill, but I missed it by that much...", which means you are a gullible yaboo who needs to be eliminated before you hurt somebody through your own inptitude.


vote: ACIN

[The Stranger]

or it could mean he is a Super Sexy Vampire!

robert pattison ftw!

[BillMc]

vote: AskThePizzaGuy

I'm a newb to this board, and have only played one game with AskThePizzaGuy before, and how he is behaving here (trying to coordinate the world) may be his normal play style. But it seems to me he is trying to manipulate the world in plain sight, and I don't like it.

[Johhog]

VOTE: Abstain

For now.

I totally missed the Night because the timer on Page 1 wasn't updated. :(

Please update in the future.

[ULC]

Oh, please. I stand by my statement. The Earthling case is a distraction. Early on in a game like this it is best to get as much information about what we're dealing with as possible. It's pointless to even expect good lynches at this point. The goals should be to get more information about the game set up and to get people talking so that their posts can be referenced again later. A bandwagon on someone who isn't even accused of being a mafioso is a waste of time. Lynch him by all means, there is no better candidate that I see, but spread the votes out and pressure multiple people. The Earthling wagon means you're letting 115 people walk through this day without any concerns at all. This is pretty basic mafia-wagon stuff.

How do you expect to put the necessary pressure on anyone today? It's a total roll of the dice if anyone even responds or something relevant comes up due to the enormous amount of potential posts. I'd prefer to make one person squirm and then watch the responses, or lack thereof, and then press those who remain either totally silent or are slightly scummy the next day.

Ergo, I'm not seeing how voting for Earthling is a bad thing, nor am I seeing how spreading your votes thin and making them easy to manipulate is good for the town - most nontown factions have a 3 vote block. Speaking of number of votes, does anyone have a tally? It'd be interesting to see how many people are actually voting for Earthling out 117, and whether there really is a "runaway total distraction bandwagon" on him.

[classical_hero]

What an excellent meatball of a reason.

And it's a spicy meatball too.

[scotchedpommes]

I totally missed the Night because the timer on Page 1 wasn't updated. :(

Please update in the future.

if you check the summary thread you'll see the latest timer there.

[DaveShack]

I don't understand how there can be such a big bandwagon so soon, or how so many folk who are targeted for kills happen to also have protection. Does having more than one mafia family in town have anything to do with it? As someone who hasn't lived in Fatlington very long, all this activity so soon seems really unusual. In my experience, usually it took several nights to get anything going, and protection was a lot more miss than hit.

I'm swayed a bit more by the "he knows a secret" evidence than I am by the possibly innocent (and unfortunate) use of a codeword, so I'll vote: ACIN for now. If nothing else that will even things up a bit...

[Kennigit]

yeah, so I may be overreacting, I was rushing to post earlier in a like 2 minute timeframe before I had to leave. I didn't play in other capo's so I dunno how it's like exactly. If precedent showed mistakes, and since it is presumably a player's fault, that's a bit different. But this scenario wouldn't be quite the same as a public post, since people could never "unsee" a public post/you don't know who saw it or not; a PM is specific to just the ones receiving/sending it.

also true that it isn't necessarily game breaking if he was a wiseguy or something hoping to be converted to mafioso. So, either he can cough up the info freely or seek some intervention if it actually was very relevant (again, he said it was a question over role PM--if like an entire mafia role PM was quoted as opposed to just "so I can kill every night???", one scenario is more severe).

acin can at least quantify how much is at stake--if it's just 1 mafia member's name, or more pertinent information. And he can do this is private to people probably.

[Kennigit]

whoops forgot no edits. was just simple grammatical stuff.

[Jarema]

[B]
I'm a newb to this board, and have only played one game with AskThePizzaGuy before, and how he is behaving here (trying to coordinate the world) may be his normal play style. But it seems to me he is trying to manipulate the world in plain sight, and I don't like it.

Yeah, that is exactly what he is doing. The problem is, he almost always does...

[The Stranger]

you can edit posts right? as long as they dont have a vote in them.

[Tratorix]

vote: AskThePizzaGuy

I'm a newb to this board, and have only played one game with AskThePizzaGuy before, and how he is behaving here (trying to coordinate the world) may be his normal play style. But it seems to me he is trying to manipulate the world in plain sight, and I don't like it.

In other breaking news rain is wet and the sun rises in the east.

Unvote, Vote: ACIN because sportsmanship has no place in Capo.

[Peasant Phill]

Vote edse

Already protecting someone?

[GeneralHankerchief]

TALLY. Keep it updated. And no, I didn't get a trait from this.

Earthling: 12 (sasaki, acin, atpg, beskar, cahoma, diy, lazymccrow, arjos, seon, warman, ulc, khaan)
ACIN: 9 (earthling, jarema, renata, subotan, kennigit, shlin, sturmhauke, suburban plankton, tratorix)
Chaotix: 3 (fluffy, lewwyn, lastdays)
ATPG: 2 (stranger, billmc)
edse: 2 (believer, phill)

People with one vote:
Silver Jan (edse)
Visorslash (diamondeye)
Diamondeye (xehh)
Camikaze (tincow)
Arjos (psychonaut)
ULC (frozen in ice)
Skotsko (gibson)

No Lynch (Skotsko)
Abstain (Johog)
Can't vote but is still awesome (GH)

[Yaropolk]

"Crazed Rabbit sent his order in too late"

Either

You made that bit up for some reason known only to yourself, which means you're a liar and need to be eliminated before you can become Made, or

You know that's true because you are both part of the same Family, which means you are Mafia and need to be eliminated before you kill us all, or

You actually believed Crazed Rabbit when he told you "sorry guy's, I meant to get in on the kill, but I missed it by that much...", which means you are a gullible yaboo who needs to be eliminated before you hurt somebody through your own inptitude.


vote: ACIN

This makes me think of this:
But I agree, vote:ACIN

[Johhog]

UNVOTE: Abstain
VOTE: a completely inoffensive name

Might as well, and Suburban Plankton should obviously be the next target if ACIN is scum.

[Johhog]

No wait, he shouldn't be the next. Got the situation wrong.

[glyphz]

Vote: Johhog The guy who posted above me.

You lucky guy!

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

TALLY.

Earthling: 12 (sasaki, acin, atpg, beskar, cahoma, diy, lazymccrow, arjos, seon, warman, ulc, khaan)
ACIN: 11 (earthling, jarema, renata, subotan, kennigit, shlin, sturmhauke, suburban plankton, tratorix, Yaropolk, Johhog)
Chaotix: 3 (fluffy, lewwyn, lastdays)
ATPG: 2 (stranger, billmc)
edse: 2 (believer, phill)

People with one vote:
Silver Jan (edse)
Visorslash (diamondeye)
Diamondeye (xehh)
Camikaze (tincow)
Arjos (psychonaut)
ULC (frozen in ice)
Skotsko (gibson)
Johhog (qlyphz)

No Lynch (Skotsko)

Can't vote but is still awesome (GH)

edit: updating GH's tally

[Arjos]

Unvote; Vote: ACIN

To provide GH with something to do with the tie...

[scotchedpommes]

Don't edit posts with votes in them.

[Suburban Plankton]

This makes me think of this:
But I agree, vote:ACIN

Yes, regrettably, I am inexorably linked to SpongeBob. And to make matters even worse, my real first name is Gary.

For the record, my user name comes from my High School days, which were well before Mr. SquarePants made his television debut.

[GeneralHankerchief]

And if there is a tie, how would my adoring public like to see me break it? Choose whichever one I think most deserves the lynch, or kill 'em all?

[glyphz]

Don't edit posts with votes in them.

Don't sweat the small stuff

[DaveShack]

GH's tally missed my vote for ACIN. In too much of a hurry right now to count intervening votes and update it myself.