Capo di Tutti Capi IV [Concluded]

[a completely inoffensive name]

14-16 ACIN-Earthling

[Chaotix]

Come one guys, you need to think a little deeper.

First- Yes, we all know ACIN is trying to get himself inducted into the mafia family he stumbled upon. Wouldn't it be better to kill him after he's already been recruited and make it a waste of that family's time, rather than get him now before there's any chance of him being real scum?

Second- Earthling is probably a communist. In the last game (I know from experience being one), Communists were third party, but NOT anti-town necessarily. They were roughly as pro-town as CI-ATPG was, and the two only had goals to kill each other. Otherwise the Commies had goals to recruit a bunch of people like a cult, but they were still essentially townies- just more powerful, capable townies.

Could the communists be different this time around? Certainly. I have no idea. But the bottom line is that neither of these lynches is good for the town.

That said, I'm not gunning for the town and I'm the third candidate after them, so I don't really care.

Vote: Earthling

[Andres]

Hey Sasaki, if Earthling is the guy, you better find a way to somehow get 7 people to vote for Earthling. Because right now it is 15 on me and 9 on earthling.

Unvote : Earthling

To avoid Sasaki posting "hey look at how awesome I am, I got your 7 people in less than half an hour!"

Vote : White_Eyes:D

[Renata]

Lol new policy. Mr. Cal King is going to be completely honest for this game, and if I die, oh well. I got books to read.

I was part of the attack group on Earthling. Trying to satisfy my symmetry that I explained earlier. I can verify Sasaki's suggestion that someone bailed. It wasn't a bail though, but someone sent in their order 60 seconds too late after the timer.

Unvote; Vote: ACIN

Ready to be a replacement if you need one.

I sent ATPG a message saying I wanted to kill people, he put together the group and gave me the courtesy of choosing the target, at which point I picked Earthling.

CR sent his messages and then at the last minute sent a PM to everyone including SF saying to revoke his night orders. I asked why and he said no one else had sent them in. Diana then told us she forgot to BCC them to the rest of us but did snet them and Neri and Khaan never talked to us once.

My usual meta game style is causing everyone to not believe me, which is understandable. But at least I know that after you lynch me that Earthling will be next. Knowing how big this game is, I am sure me and Earthling will be put in again as replacements.

One of these things is not like the other. (Underlining mine.)

[Cecil XIX]

vote: Chaotix

Quips like "People won't realize I'm not joking until it's too late" should be discouraged.

[a completely inoffensive name]

Come one guys, you need to think a little deeper.

First- Yes, we all know ACIN is trying to get himself inducted into the mafia family he stumbled upon. Wouldn't it be better to kill him after he's already been recruited and make it a waste of that family's time, rather than get him now before there's any chance of him being real scum?

Second- Earthling is probably a communist. In the last game (I know from experience being one), Communists were third party, but NOT anti-town necessarily. They were roughly as pro-town as CI-ATPG was, and the two only had goals to kill each other. Otherwise the Commies had goals to recruit a bunch of people like a cult, but they were still essentially townies- just more powerful, capable townies.

Could the communists be different this time around? Certainly. I have no idea. But the bottom line is that neither of these lynches is good for the town.

That said, I'm not gunning for the town and I'm the third candidate after them, so I don't really care.

Vote: Earthling

I won't get inducted into the mafia family because this person would never have me join his team. Once you guys kill him, it will become obvious.

[White_eyes:D]

I changed my vote about 2-4 minutes before you posted this.

Earthling is obvious lynch. I really don't have to fight any anymore than I have to argue that the sky is blue. He said stupid stuff, he said scummy stuff, I have been putting a big target on my back and having some fun trying to have everyone call me by my pimp name.

I was posting and check other threads.

Ah, I like "Mr.Cal King" and Pizzaguy and Sasaki did bring up some nice points on Earthling...Unvote:ACIN Vote:Earthling

[Xenoneb]

13-17 ACIN-Earthling
Did it for you!

[a completely inoffensive name]

One of these things is not like the other. (Underlining mine.)

You are 100% correct. Pulling my inbox right now.

[Renata]

Come one guys, you need to think a little deeper.

First- Yes, we all know ACIN is trying to get himself inducted into the mafia family he stumbled upon. Wouldn't it be better to kill him after he's already been recruited and make it a waste of that family's time, rather than get him now before there's any chance of him being real scum?

Second- Earthling is probably a communist. In the last game (I know from experience being one), Communists were third party, but NOT anti-town necessarily. They were roughly as pro-town as CI-ATPG was, and the two only had goals to kill each other. Otherwise the Commies had goals to recruit a bunch of people like a cult, but they were still essentially townies- just more powerful, capable townies.

Could the communists be different this time around? Certainly. I have no idea. But the bottom line is that neither of these lynches is good for the town.

That said, I'm not gunning for the town and I'm the third candidate after them, so I don't really care.

Vote: Earthling

Likewise, though more subtle. (Underlining mine again.)

[Kennigit]

No comment at all on earthling? fos:kennigit

Sure I will. Earthling claimed some stuff that can easily be confirmed or denied. There are parties out there that should know what earthling is claiming, and I encourage any of them to send a PM my way and see if the story checks out.

ACIN has his night action last night accounted for, in attacking earthling in a 4 person party. However I am happy to lynch acin since I'm pretty sure he just made a pretty metagamey lie, and I don't exactly see a reason to do that. And it's not particularly good to have ACIN go to ATPG (a proposed wiseguy by some? unsure, and thread is hard to follow. This is from my memory), say "I wanna kill people", then have ATPG help organise a vig kill. I.e. I'm personally not too fond of that organization. And I don't see how that would clear ACIN of being a don, as a don can appear as innocent and if I understand the rules correctly, A Don normally cannot kill opponents during a “night” phase, and must work through others", so a don is free to send in whatever orders he wants, including sending in orders as part of a coalition with townies? If the Don cannot work with his family he may as well try to act like a full on townie.

I guess it would also be good for Neri or khaan to speak up, since according to ACIN they didn't leave a papertrail (also, khaan posted earlier he wanted earthling dead anyways in his lynch vote).

there is still 9.5 hours left or so right? Some of these claims can be identified and cleared easily.

[a completely inoffensive name]

Tell me to kill people. Idc who, just tell me my partners and I will send in a kill order.

Greetings, ACIN-

Night one will be difficult. People are asking me for groups after the night has begun; folks will be missing, uncooperative, unresponsive.

However, the instant I have a viable group I will assign and send it out to you. My advice: Help me, find a couple more folks, like your old Four Horsemen buddies, perhaps, and attach yourselves to them.

When you do, contact me, I will try to fill in the blanks.

Night Two will be different. We will begin discussing actions at the beginning of the day, we will boot the dead weight from our groups and reassign them. Folks like you, who I know I can trust to perform kills because that's badass, will be given priority assignments.

I will help you. Stick with me, I know how to run this ship. Standby for orders and partners, as I get them.

You may choose your own target, however, if you want the kill to have a chance of success, allow me to make suggestions as I also know who is being protected by my groups.

I'm gonna kill Earthling. I am gonna find people to help me kill him.

mmm. Not a problem, no objection here.

If I find more people, I will direct them to you immediately.

If it's alright with you guys, I'd prefer Warman to die tonight, though I wouldn't mind going after Earthling tomorrow.

CR

Neri ; Crazed Rabbit ; a completely inoffensive name; Diana Abnoba ;



You'll need another, I'll try to persuade Khaan to join. He's doing protections but he prefers this.


I also need to know if any of you are wiseguys. Too many wiseguys and the attack will not function, I just was informed; there's fewer people required if there are wiseguys involved.


The target is going to be Earthling, as per ACIN's request. Any objections, contact me now.

If it's alright with you guys, I'd prefer Warman to die tonight, though I wouldn't mind going after Earthling tomorrow. CR

Neri ; Crazed Rabbit ; a completely inoffensive name; Diana Abnoba ; You'll need another, I'll try to persuade Khaan to join. He's doing protections but he prefers this. I also need to know if any of you are wiseguys. Too many wiseguys and the attack will not function, I just was informed; there's fewer people required if there are wiseguys involved. The target is going to be Earthling, as per ACIN's request. Any objections, contact me now.

I would rather have Earthling dealt with immediately just to cover all my bases here. Me and him got into a beef last game and he never replied to my message where I said politely "good game, sorry about the heated words. I didn't mean any of it. I was just being in my mafia game playing character."

So yeah, I got a monkey on my back telling me that Earthling might try to kill me off early, and I gotta scratch the monkey.

After Earthling dies, I am 100% down to kill Warman just to get his annoying personality out of here.

I'm down with this plan, either target is fine with me, just let me know which one, so I can send in my orders.

Very well, I'll get Earthling.

Let me know who the final member of the group is. I will be online before the deadline to send in orders.

CR

If it's alright with you guys, I'd prefer Warman to die tonight, though I wouldn't mind going after Earthling tomorrow. CR

Neri ; Crazed Rabbit ; a completely inoffensive name; Diana Abnoba ; You'll need another, I'll try to persuade Khaan to join. He's doing protections but he prefers this. I also need to know if any of you are wiseguys. Too many wiseguys and the attack will not function, I just was informed; there's fewer people required if there are wiseguys involved. The target is going to be Earthling, as per ACIN's request. Any objections, contact me now.

I would rather have Earthling dealt with immediately just to cover all my bases here. Me and him got into a beef last game and he never replied to my message where I said politely "good game, sorry about the heated words. I didn't mean any of it. I was just being in my mafia game playing character."

So yeah, I got a monkey on my back telling me that Earthling might try to kill me off early, and I gotta scratch the monkey.

After Earthling dies, I am 100% down to kill Warman just to get his annoying personality out of here.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

If it's alright with you guys, I'd prefer Warman to die tonight, though I wouldn't mind going after Earthling tomorrow. CR

Neri ; Crazed Rabbit ; a completely inoffensive name; Diana Abnoba ; You'll need another, I'll try to persuade Khaan to join. He's doing protections but he prefers this. I also need to know if any of you are wiseguys. Too many wiseguys and the attack will not function, I just was informed; there's fewer people required if there are wiseguys involved. The target is going to be Earthling, as per ACIN's request. Any objections, contact me now.

I would rather have Earthling dealt with immediately just to cover all my bases here. Me and him got into a beef last game and he never replied to my message where I said politely "good game, sorry about the heated words. I didn't mean any of it. I was just being in my mafia game playing character."

So yeah, I got a monkey on my back telling me that Earthling might try to kill me off early, and I gotta scratch the monkey.

After Earthling dies, I am 100% down to kill Warman just to get his annoying personality out of here.

I'm down with this plan, either target is fine with me, just let me know which one, so I can send in my orders.

Okay folks, here's the plan.

Diana Abnoba ; a completely inoffensive name ; Crazed Rabbit ; Neri ; issaikhaan;

Attack Earthling together, naming each other as members of your vigilante team, sending the message to Seamus Fermanagh and myself for confirmation.

This group will function even if one of you forgets to send in orders.

I will kill Earthling along with these people: Neri ; ACIN; Diana Abnoba ; and Khaan.

PS ACIN you forgot to include Khaan.

CR

I will kill Earthling along with these people: Neri ; ACIN; Diana Abnoba ; and Khaan.

PS ACIN you forgot to include Khaan.

CR

Add Khaan ​to my orders Seamus.

Cancel night one orders. There's no one besides me and ACIN attacking.

CR

Cancel night one orders. There's no one besides me and ACIN attacking.

CR

Did the time run out?

Cancel night one orders. There's no one besides me and ACIN attacking.

CR

Did the time run out?

about 60 seconds after this pm

Hey guys,

Sorry I forgot to BCC the rest of you guys with the orders I sent for night 1, will do this from now on. This way we can all know that we all sent the orders out. I sent my order to kill Earthling with the rest of you several hours ago.

Well hopefully, everyone besides CR sent in their orders.

Hey guys,

Sorry I forgot to BCC the rest of you guys with the orders I sent for night 1, will do this from now on. This way we can all know that we all sent the orders out. I sent my order to kill Earthling with the rest of you several hours ago.

Yeah, it seemed it was just me and ACIN, so I bailed.

Sorry about that, it seems that I was the only person not there.

CR

Hey guys,

Sorry I forgot to BCC the rest of you guys with the orders I sent for night 1, will do this from now on. This way we can all know that we all sent the orders out. I sent my order to kill Earthling with the rest of you several hours ago.

These are all my inbox and my replies.

[El Barto]

vote:Earthling, hate your walls of text.

Our protection of Winston last night was inconclusive…

[BSmith]

Come one guys, you need to think a little deeper.

First- Yes, we all know ACIN is trying to get himself inducted into the mafia family he stumbled upon. Wouldn't it be better to kill him after he's already been recruited and make it a waste of that family's time, rather than get him now before there's any chance of him being real scum?

Second- Earthling is probably a communist. In the last game (I know from experience being one), Communists were third party, but NOT anti-town necessarily. They were roughly as pro-town as CI-ATPG was, and the two only had goals to kill each other. Otherwise the Commies had goals to recruit a bunch of people like a cult, but they were still essentially townies- just more powerful, capable townies.

Could the communists be different this time around? Certainly. I have no idea. But the bottom line is that neither of these lynches is good for the town.

That said, I'm not gunning for the town and I'm the third candidate after them, so I don't really care.

Vote: Earthling

The underlined statement is the part that raised my eyebrows, although the entire last sentence is worthy of a deeper look. And it’s not like being third is really a threat to you at this time with all the votes on the other two… (underlining mine)

[landlubber]

Vote:Earthling.
I agree that it would be better to lynch a known scum than a potential scum.

[a completely inoffensive name]

Cue people saying that I faked all those PMs in the 7 minutes between that post and my previous post.

[Ishmael]

Lots of posts to read this morning - good thing I woke up earlier than normal. I really don't see how Earthling was getting off earlier, his posts were blatantly scummy, although his squirming was kind of amusing to read . I agree with the others that we only have ACIN's word for his tale, but the obvious target this round should be Earthling, so:

vote: Earthling

EDIT: I meant the "PM from the mafia" tale, not the one that was presumably proven wrong by all those PMs (although I didn't quite understand what that was about anyway).

[classical_hero]

Come one guys, you need to think a little deeper.

First- Yes, we all know ACIN is trying to get himself inducted into the mafia family he stumbled upon. Wouldn't it be better to kill him after he's already been recruited and make it a waste of that family's time, rather than get him now before there's any chance of him being real scum?

Second- Earthling is probably a communist. In the last game (I know from experience being one), Communists were third party, but NOT anti-town necessarily. They were roughly as pro-town as CI-ATPG was, and the two only had goals to kill each other. Otherwise the Commies had goals to recruit a bunch of people like a cult, but they were still essentially townies- just more powerful, capable townies.

Could the communists be different this time around? Certainly. I have no idea. But the bottom line is that neither of these lynches is good for the town.

That said, I'm not gunning for the town and I'm the third candidate after them, so I don't really care.

Vote: Earthling

So basically what you have said is that ACIN is definitely trying to be a mafia and Earthling propably is a communist. I would take the odds of getting someone who is definite, than a probable. So therefore my vote is obvious.

Vote:A completely inoffensive name.

[a completely inoffensive name]

So basically what you have said is that ACIN is definitely trying to be a mafia and Earthling propably is a communist. I would take the odds of getting someone who is definite, than a probable. So therefore my vote is obvious.

Vote:A completely inoffensive name.

FoS You.

You taking Chaotix at his word even though I have given a counter argument and other people have shed doubt on Chaotix's allegiance?

You be trying to continue the bandwagon, scum.

[Monk]

Some people are going fishing today...

Vote: Abstain.

[BSmith]

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:



Okay folks, here's the plan.

Diana Abnoba ; a completely inoffensive name ; Crazed Rabbit ; Neri ; issaikhaan;

Attack Earthling together, naming each other as members of your vigilante team, sending the message to Seamus Fermanagh and myself for confirmation.

This group will function even if one of you forgets to send in orders.

These are all my inbox and my replies.

So which one of you guys is a wiseguy? (underline mine)

[Suburban Plankton]

ACIN,

If we're to believe your wall o' quotes, the Vig group was supposed to consist of you, Diana Abnoba, Crazed Rabbit, Neri, and issaikhaan. Pizza informs you at one point that "This group will function even if one of you forgets to send in orders". In the end, CR fails to participate, leaving four of you to make the kill. The kill fails, meaning that either Pizza lied to you about your actual chances of success (shocking possibility, I know), or you are lying to us about the timing of events, the content of one or more of the PMs, or both. Since you haven't been able to keep your story straight all Day, I'm betting the liar here is you.

[Cecil XIX]

Cue people saying that I faked all those PMs in the 7 minutes between that post and my previous post.

There's no reason to believe you couldn't had prepared those in advance. Getting worried?

[a completely inoffensive name]

If everyone but CR sent in orders, than it would have to be CR as the wiseguy. We had 4 people and failed. Thus we didn't have a wiseguy.

[a completely inoffensive name]

There's no reason to believe you couldn't had prepared those in advance. Getting worried?

Not really, considering my original statement didn't match up with my second statement as Renata pointed out. If I am preparing everything in advance here, I am doing a piss poor job of keeping it all together.

[a completely inoffensive name]

ACIN,

If we're to believe your wall o' quotes, the Vig group was supposed to consist of you, Diana Abnoba, Crazed Rabbit, Neri, and issaikhaan. Pizza informs you at one point that "This group will function even if one of you forgets to send in orders". In the end, CR fails to participate, leaving four of you to make the kill. The kill fails, meaning that either Pizza lied to you about your actual chances of success (shocking possibility, I know), or you are lying to us about the timing of events, the content of one or more of the PMs, or both. Since you haven't been able to keep your story straight all Day, I'm betting the liar here is you.

So kill me.

[Suburban Plankton]

Not really, considering my original statement didn't match up with my second statement as Renata pointed out. If I am preparing everything in advance here, I am doing a piss poor job of keeping it all together.

I find that completely believable.

So kill me.

BANG! You're dead!

Did it work? No? OK, then I guess I'll have to settle for leaving my vote on you. Not much more I can do at this point.

[a completely inoffensive name]

Alright, so I must be guilty because I haven't been able to keep my story straight, therefor I am a liar. But also, I have been planning everything in advance, so i am fooling everyone and thus must be scummy.

Therefor I planned my conflicting lies in order to put the heat on me and get myself lynched, because I am mafia! It makes perfect sense!

[a completely inoffensive name]

I find that completely believable.

That hurts more than any accusation. I think I will kill you next game.

[El Barto]

Vote: Earthling

Xeno, Xeno dear, where are you now? So monosyllabic, your posts are. What of all the mayhem you caused last night?
'Assigning' people to groups without asking, then conveniently leaving for 15 hours -AdorethePizzagod always says, in his mozzarella-tomato-anchovian wisdom, that people who start the game by setting an 'absence calendar' are up to no good- after everyone is trying to organise? Somehow I got into a couple groups.

Never mind johnhughthom and Zack who started by proposing a defense group and then herding people into a proposed vig-kill group? Folks, you can do better than that.

So kill me.

Insert owl picture here.