Westeros: A Game of Thrones.

[Kagemusha]

Why are you speculating like this here in this thread? How the Frey´s will react depends completely how JHT wants to rule about it. In the end the Frey´s are vassals of Tully´s so maybe you ought to be more concerned about Tully´s rather then Frey´s?

[White_eyes:D]

Why are you speculating like this here in this thread? How the Frey´s will react depends completely how JHT wants to rule about it. In the end the Frey´s are vassals of Tully´s so maybe you ought to be more concerned about Tully´s rather then Frey´s?

This is a feudal medieval system. Not a Absolute monarchy, it's somewhat expected to predict how various vassals will react. It was just an example that I was not singling out the Frey's but that if I wanted to pass anyone who is at a bottleneck, that I might need to try more "forceful" methods.(And not because the book said so but because its just common sense if you look at the map)

[Kagemusha]

This is a feudal medieval system. Not a Absolute monarchy, it's somewhat expected to predict how various vassals will react. It was just an example that I was not singling out the Frey's but that if I wanted to pass anyone who is at a bottleneck, that I might need to try more "forceful" methods.(And not because the book said so but because its just common sense if you look at the map)

I never suggested it was absolute monarchy, but maybe the Frey´s are more of a concern of Tully´s then you. There is no indication of what so ever that they are going to betray you, so unless you get information concerning such possibility from game host.Such speculation is completely unnecessary.
If you are paranoid about Frey´s send a spy among them rather then speculate how they might act based on how they acted in the books.

[Beskar]

Frey's do have a history is based upon Lore. Their stance and actions during Robert's rebellion are all well known.

[White_eyes:D]

Whoa, where are you getting that I was even expecting that they would betray me and that's why I would attack them?

I was just mentioning how there in the way and how a feudal system works. Even if the liege told him to let us pass, it would still be up to him on whether or not he should honor it. Who knows, maybe he well declare independence or sign up with someone else.

We just don't know what well happen and that's the beauty of it.

[Kagemusha]

I was just pointing out how such speculation is unnecessary in public. Like i said in my first post concerning the issue. I am quite sure JHT will not make this game a copy of the books.We will know when things will be unraveled.
You can react to issues when you have proper information to base your actions upon. If indeed Frey´s would decide to reject you passing the Twins.I am sure you Stark´s can come up with ideas how to deal with that.

[Greyblades]

You can react to issues when you have proper information to base your actions upon. If indeed Frey´s would decide to reject you passing the Twins.I am sure you Stark´s can come up with ideas how to deal with that.

I never really understood that, couldnt Robb have just said "screw it" and walked upstream to the green fork's source and crossed there, or heck they could go around alltogether by heading west of greywater watch and following the forest edge south and end up in the same place.

[Kagemusha]

I never really understood that, couldnt Robb have just said "screw it" and walked upstream to the green fork's source and crossed there, or heck they could go around alltogether.

My thoughts exactly.