Teacher get's death threats and racist hate mail for banning God Bless America.

[HoreTore]

Human rights charter is also nothing more then an opinion of what human-rights are. Tell me, what are you teaching about the things that make the right really really sad. On immigration, europe, and islam specifically. You solved the entire issue of honour-killings within muslim families by finding out that it also happens in rural India after all, are you sure you are objective.

I don't conclude anything. The standard procedure is "student makes a statement - I give a counter statement".

Ie.
Students say immigration enriches our culture. I respond by asking "what about those who do not want our culture to change", or something like that.

Coming up with counters to a leftist argument is absolutely no problem. Same with right-wing arguments. What is difficult is coming up with a proper response to a moderate, centrist statement.

As for grading, I grade based on how their arguments are built, not what they conclude with(I honestly don't care about the conclusion, other than it having a logical connection to the arguments used).