The Palace [Concluded]

[Arjos]

I have made exactly one case this entire game, that against GH.

That and all the contrite reasoning with BSmith and Ishmael...
Since you said time to get serious, all you have done, has been distracting...

[TinCow]

That and all the contrite reasoning with BSmith and Ishmael...
Since you said time to get serious, all you have done, has been distracting...

Again, a lot of exaggeration. I have made exactly one post with any reasoning about Ishmael and BSmith. That post was essentially a response to 'khaan's request to have TheFlax lynched, it was simply pointing out an argument that had already been advanced by GH. You seem rather agitated by my relatively minimal contributions to this game, why is that exactly? And please, do explain how you know that GH is "obvious non-scum."

[Arjos]

That post was essentially a response to 'khaan's request to have TheFlax lynched, it was simply pointing out an argument that had already been advanced by GH.

That is textbook mafia: contorting or pushing town's arguments, to increase credibility and ride the tide for wagons...
In our case it made two of them, tying, imo none of the two were mafia (looking at their voting)...

[TinCow]

That is textbook mafia: contorting or pushing town's arguments, to increase credibility and ride the tide for wagons...
In our case it made two of them, tying, imo none of the two were mafia (looking at their voting)...

You still haven't explained why you said that GH was "obvious non-scum." Obvious is a very strong word and implies a level of certainty that is highly unusual in mafia, particularly in a classic-style game like this one. What was it about GH that made him so obviously not scum?

[Arjos]

You still haven't explained why you said that GH was "obvious non-scum."

Because I never did XD

I was speaking of Ishmael and by the extension the Ishmael-BSmith duo, that you sidelined on that ridiculous case and pushed it forward, influencing town...

[TinCow]

Because I never did XD

I was speaking of Ishmael and by the extension the Ishmael-BSmith duo, that you sidelined on that ridiculous case and pushed it forward, influencing town...

Ok then, why are Ishmael and BSmith "obvious non-scum"?

[Arjos]

BSmith as I said was a fifth voter on a wagon, that's just unnecessary for any mafia...

Ishmael, iirc he broke at first a tie on Xeno, in which case both are mafia and soon both goners...
Otherwise he was just a townie voting however he felt like...

Regardless your vote was on BSmith, so if Ishmael is scum, then you are very likely to be the 3rd one (not voting yet), since the 2nd (Xeno) is about to meet a bus on his face, desperately trying to get something out of this conversation...

On the same boat, I see Darth Feather, coasting around and quoting other players with the mafia-like "I agree with him and will vote like him" bla bla bla...

[GeneralHankerchief]

You still haven't explained why you said that GH was "obvious non-scum." Obvious is a very strong word and implies a level of certainty that is highly unusual in mafia, particularly in a classic-style game like this one. What was it about GH that made him so obviously not scum?

Honestly yeah, I was pretty scummy.

[Csargo]

It's a shame that one of the leaders of discussion in this game is also one of the vote leaders at this point. I don't think lynching him will be beneficial in any way.

Vote: Makrell

He's been doing the same thing I've been doing. That's pretty scummy imho.

[White_eyes:D]

He's been doing the same thing I've been doing. That's pretty scummy imho.

Yeah....and my vote on you before was not justified when even you think you act scummy?

If you and TinCow are scum, I will kick myself for ever letting you both get a pass of my scum sense on you two.(Which is going red alert BTW)

[Visor]

The second/third guy who voted for Xeno should be lynched.

Dunno who that is, but this is a bad lynch.

[TheFlax]

The second/third guy who voted for Xeno should be lynched.

Dunno who that is, but this is a bad lynch.

Second is edse who is replacing Cornelius, so no.

Apart from that, why couldn't you be bothered to take a few more moments to check for yourself? Its not like these day phases are overflowing with posts.

[Riedquat]

The second/third guy who voted for Xeno should be lynched.

Dunno who that is, but this is a bad lynch.

Third, would be me... I voted for him yesterday too for what is worth, why is a bad lynch? Is he participating in any way? No. Good lynch then, or at least, better than Tincow, imo.