El Barto's Clueless Mafia Game #1

[El Barto]

Can I still talk and stuff?

OP doesn't say anything about it.

Yes, yes, if you must.

What happens if Bladescape doesn't post/vote today?

He'll be replaced. Probably by one of the two dingi quoted above.

[Zack]

This is a bad argument. Zack was the must-murder last night, he was never getting lynched this game due to the lack of village PMs.

Assume that for the moment, zack is village, pizza is village, you're village, and Ishmael is village. Your top suspects then?

Last edited by Askthepizzaguy; 06-07-14 at 01:05 AM. Reason: In fact, I'm skipping analysis of Zack. It doesn't even need to be said.

Because I said I didn't get a PM? Like a scumbag's never done that before? Smells likes PIS to me.

[Riedquat]

Well, I'm not going to get anything out of Jarema.

Unvote; Vote: Riedquat, I find his posts today to not nullify any suspicion I had on him.

Pizza, you or myself.

Know what? Now I'm suspicious of me too, Vote: Riedquat Tomorrow lynch Ishmael, and nobody would need to deal with wolfquat in any other round!

[Zack]

Know what? Now I'm suspicious of me too, Vote: Riedquat Tomorrow lynch Ishmael, and nobody would need to deal with wolfquat in any other round!

Vote for literally anyone but yourself, please. That goes for everyone.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Because I said I didn't get a PM? Like a scumbag's never done that before? Smells likes PIS to me.

Maybe you have urinal cakes in your nostrils.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I like how Reidquat is totally willing to lynch Ishmael, like, someday? But not before self-owning.

That's pretty kewl. It's a really unorthodox way of hunting scums.

[Bladescape]

Know what? Now I'm suspicious of me too, Vote: Riedquat Tomorrow lynch Ishmael, and nobody would need to deal with wolfquat in any other round!

This stinks.

Mucho apologies for the absence, as Pizza said it was announced clearly on GITP but I forgot to mention it here and didn't realise how fast things would go here.

A quick Vote:Ishmael read for me right now. Sick so I probably won't go too in depth until later.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Praise be to bladescape, holy defender against the wrath of.... of...

Well, El Barto I suppose.

[Riedquat]

I like how Reidquat is totally willing to lynch Ishmael, like, someday? But not before self-owning.

That's pretty kewl. It's a really unorthodox way of hunting scums.

Letting me here round after round barking in each one I'm scum but still keeping me alive to start over in the next round doesn't help anyone except the scum, the truth is I'm f'king annoyed because regardless of Ishmael's role, tomorrow you are going to start it again how wolfie I am and blah blah blah... so what is the point of this exercise on futility from my part?

So, unvote. Don't expect further participation from me.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Melodrama!~

[Double A]

Lynch me tomorrow if I am wrong.

Has anyone else noticed that when Pizza's wrong and we do this, we only lynch him when he's town?

Yes. Of course you have. And so has Pizza. Also, he knows we know, so it's a WIFOM. I advocate lynching him on principle.

[Jarema]

I need to be murdered tonight to prevent shenanigans, so if everyone could be on record as thinking Askthepizzaguy is an obvious villager, that would probably tilt things that way.

Regardless of how Ishmael flips, me surviving to lynch or lose is never good for village's ability to think clearly.

I have a strong scum vibe on you after reading this post.
In fact, stronger feeling of you being scum that I ever had.
You like to wave your big, diamond balls (or "crystal used in lightsabers"*) in front of town, dont you?
It is exactly how I've seen scummy Pizza behaving before.
I say we should lynch him.

Unvote; vote: ATPG

PS
Pizza, you said more than once that you want us to realy try to read you. Now, I am realy trying.

[El Barto]

DAY TWO

Ishmael was lynched.

Riedquat: Visorslash (1)
Ishmael: Askthepizzaguy; edse; Bladescape (3)
Askthepizzaguy: Ishmael; Jarema (2)

Abstain: Riedquat (1)
Not voting: TFT (1)

List of players:
1. Double A LYNCHED DAY ONE, Innocent
2. Kumquat
3. Askthepizzaguy
4. edse
5. TFT
6. Jarema
7. Bladescape
8. Ishmael LYNCHED DAY TWO, Innocent
9. Zack KILLED NIGHT ONE, Innocent
10. Visorslash

It is now Night Two. Posting is still allowed.
This phase will last:

[Ishmael]

What, my 'innocent' isn't in bold font? I'm wounded.

Seriously though, lynch ATPG tomorrow. Don't let him worm his way out of it - he's mafia.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Have I got some disappointing news for you.

[Askthepizzaguy]

So, tell you what, I think I'll also be melodramatic and go on strike.

I won't help the town team win since I'm the next lynch.

Ordinarily I'd dig deep and pull a rabbit out of my hat but there's little point in it for me, because (a) I'm basically half of the town's analysis and activity anyway, and (b) too many confirmed innocents want me dead, so let's let that happen.

[Jarema]

not nice :)

as you well know, IF you are town, you can still help us even if we lynch you. We will analyze your words after your death.

So, at least tell us who are your two main suspects (or one) before you die

[Jarema]

and I understand whay you may want to be lazy, but I am angry at you anyway, 'cause I am going to die in your game :)

[Askthepizzaguy]

not nice :)

as you well know, IF you are town, you can still help us even if we lynch you. We will analyze your words after your death

So how does that work, exactly?

Tell me how you feel town can win after it lynches villager pizzaguy.

Give me all the scenarios where town wins after a third villager lynch in a row in a 10 player game.

[Askthepizzaguy]

This is how town wins: You swallow the fact that I'm still a villager.

This is how town loses: You lynch any villager next round.

Math.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Here's your pre-mortem post-mortem.

Town lost because town chose who died and town chose incorrectly.

Ishmael 1 (TFT)
Double A 3 (Ishmael; Zack; Askthepizzaguy) LYNCHED
Jarema 1 (Riedquat)
Visorslash 1 (Jarema)
Riedquat 1 (Double A)
Askthepizzaguy 1 (Visorslash)
Not voting, edse, Bladescape (2)


Riedquat: Visorslash (1)
Ishmael: Askthepizzaguy; edse; Bladescape (3)
Askthepizzaguy: Ishmael; Jarema (2)
Abstain: Riedquat (1)
Not voting: TFT (1)


Next: Zack or Double A rejoins the game, both think I'm scum. That's all she wrote.

We'd have a chance if all the pizza-is-scum people remained dead. Instead, the zombies will arrive and carry off pizza's brains.

The mafia will continue to vote off-wagon and be Visorslash.

[Askthepizzaguy]

D'aww I said I wasn't going to contributed and I still contributed.

Pizza lied, lynch pizza.

[Visor]

Vote: ATPG I'm convinced.

[edse]

What do the colours represent Pizza? Seeing my name in bolder black is unsettling.

I think we should lynch Jarema tomorrow.

[Visor]

I actually voted AA D1, but it must have been after the deadline.

Still we have more information to look at.

Noticeably Ishmael being innocent, ATPG pushed Ishmael hard, and TFT pushed Ishmael hard both days.
Riedquat and ATPG both had 'drama' moments. Now, Riedquat, I'm unsure of what to believe. Ishmael flipping town makes me believe Riedquat might be town. ATPG's 'drama' is what he does as scum, seen it before (masquerade anyone?), especially after pushing two town lynches hard.

Out of the seven left, I want to hear from edse and bladescape the most, as they have missed a day here.

Riedquat: I thought he was scum initially, and I'm still not sure now, but both he and ATPG are not scum together. Unlikely they both have 'drama' as wolves. Hesistant town lean.

Bladescape: If he is mafia he is the inactive partner. Null so far.

Edse: Similar to TFT, mostly about Ishmael, pushing the lynch, though he did mention he thought Jarema was scum with him. Null.

Jarema: Town. His early game is comparable to what I expect from town Jarema, and his posts recently are big town tells for Jarema, and I like his post against Pizza.

TFT: TFT didn't post here, but he did post on GITP, I don't know how he plays as scum, but he has barely had any interaction with anyone besides Ishmael (small AA discussion).

Pizza: Pushed hard for Ishmael and AA. Did his drama act.

[Visor]

What do the colours represent Pizza? Seeing my name in bolder black is unsettling.

I think we should lynch Jarema tomorrow.

No, I don't think we should. Jarema is highly highly likely to be a townie.

[Visor]

Edse is actually pretty similar to Bladescape - painful situation to be in, to try and guess their alignment.

[Visor]

I think Riedquat is town too, on reread. The Ishmael flip and his drama is more likely to make him town.

Pizza must go.

[Riedquat]

I tend to think Atpg is more town than you Visor, he has been terrible all game long so far but it seems he keeps thinking I'm scum, (by the bolded text?), every game I played with Pizza at one point or another he always accuses me of being scum, some times he has been right of course, many others not so. But he always point out me, perhaps something about his dyslexia and my name, who knows... but you Visor? You know better of my lack of play style to come forward with I'm convinced he must be scum...

Now, voting at night is a sweet detail too... because it is night, you know it, right?

Perhaps I got everything wrong and Atpg has been playing with us as many of you think, but he has been the only one playing with us?

[Bladescape]

Apologies for my inactivity, but this game start actually came up at a worse moment for me than I expected, so my focus isn't really on any game. Which sucks because there are a lot of games I want to focus on. Luckily Semester end comes up in a bit over a week, which doesn't help when games might be over by then.

So quick analysis of what I see so far:

I don't like the drama of Ried, but I don't know what to base that on with having so little knowledge of him. His voting history/interaction makes me think he really shouldn't be tossed up for lynch so much though just because I don't quite see what people are seeing in him being a mafia.

ATPG is at one of those points where I can't really place town vs scum at the current moment. I have an idea but no real solid thesis.

But you know who I really don't like on review?

TFT.

Visor and Edse I have nothing on right now. Read through Visor and something's niggling me but I'd need time to review what I've seen already to catch what it is.

Jarema I don't like but not willing to push yet.