I'm hosting a game!

[Ishmael]

I'm inclined to believe Visorslash for now, given that claiming as he's done would seem to entail more risk than reward were he scum. Of course, the same holds true if he's town, but one tends to be more willing to take risk in town games, since you tend to get more of them and thus have less to lose.

So, pseudo-random vote then:

Vote: Csargo.
I don't trust people whose names begin with silent letters.

I don't trust landlubbers. I bet you've never even hunted a great white whale.

vote: landlubber

(OMGUSing 'khaan was tempting, I'll admit, but his 'Call me Ishmael' won me over).