Pirate Ship Mafia III [Concluded]

[Zack]

Lying is such an ugly word. I'm saying he's wrong. I do not have 200 gold.
I really do appreciate the amount of attention that is being drawn to my finances though. It's really helpful. Suggesting that I'm fantastically wealthy will no doubt be oh so helpful for my future here. Thanks.

Why would he be wrong and not lying? That makes no sense.

[Xiahou]

Why would he be wrong and not lying? That makes no sense.

I can't answer why he'd lie. All I know is that he's wrong. I know exactly how much gold I have and it's not 200.

[Zack]

How much is it then?

[Csargo]

What does that mean?
Wow, really? Well played. What else would you be referring to?









Okay, that's good stuff.

What exactly is wrong with that? What is suspicious about it? Can you give a reason other than oh my god visor sucks?
Well, considering the vast majority of this game has been about networking, I don't see why it was necessary to do it that way. Do you think I would have been attacked if it hadn't been done that way?

Because...?
Principle

You don't even have a story.
Seriously? Kage got elected captain and tried to put inactives in groups like Monty said a few posts ago. I declined and told him I already was in one. He didn't pass that along to the other two fellows.

What is harmful about it?
I don't know. What's harmful about vigging random people?

All of his posts?
The one's I've read from the last day or so. I'd say in my opinion.

How is that the case and why would it even matter?
Wow.

As opposed to protecting suspicious people? Is vigging suspicious people wrong?
You could prolong the game by not offing random people that a select few find suspicious. I'd say it's bad overall and shortens the game if done constantly. More rounds equals more information and more concise targeting.

Apparently you were in two places at one time, and you couldn't even be bothered to give any explanation at all. Today you voted Visor and couldn't be bothered to even fabricate a reason. I don't see you saying anywhere you think he's French. Tell me more about you do care about the French, and not just getting rid of someone who suspects you.

They weren't even aware that I didn't submit orders, so the only reason any of you know about it is because I was forthcoming after the fact and told them what Kage didn't. It's funny really, considering I caused it. Why else would I have voted him? Yeah, because that's the smart play here. Vote the guy who called you out in the thread. You've got some strange opinions about what guilty people do.

[Montmorency]

Gaius, do you have anything to say about Csargo?

[Xiahou]

How much is it then?

If you don't believe me when I say it's not 200, why would you believe me if I gave a different number? I'm not in the business of disclosing my finances.

I will say that I started with 110 gold. How much I have now shouldn't be anyone's business. I think we're wasting a lot of time and energy on this side-show though.

[Csargo]

Gaius, do you have anything to say about Csargo?

I like your style. Thanks.

[Csargo]

I'm going to be logging off for the night in an hour or two, so consider this a friendly heads-up from me, speaking as Moderator (and not just the host):

Currently the level of discussion in this thread (amount of profanity, tone of posts, etc) is a bit before the borderline of being un-Gameroomish. Let's please ensure that it stays on that side of the line. Remember, we want to keep the environment friendly.

My thanks.

My apologies if I crossed a line. I didn't intend to.

[GeneralHankerchief]

My apologies if I crossed a line. I didn't intend to.

Nobody has, yet. I'm just pre-emptively making sure it stays that way.

[Montmorency]

If you don't believe me when I say it's not 200, why would you believe me if I gave a different number? I'm not in the business of disclosing my finances.

I will say that I started with 110 gold. How much I have now shouldn't be anyone's business. I think we're wasting a lot of time and energy on this side-show though.

What do you think we're playing here, Audit Mafia?

Come up with another line.

[spaceman98]

I am extremely dissatisfied with the current administration
vote: mutiny



Wait, we can curse on the org now? ' A.

[You can to an extent. Not that one. - GH]

Also vote: Xiahou for having 50 more gold than he should. If you all will recall, the Frenchman last game had an ability to outbid the captain. It's not unreasonable to imagine that there is a similar mechanic this game, though probably with a harder to achieve goal. He probably got the extra gold from his partners.

That, or he's King Orgnum.

are you voting to mutiny against yourself?

_______________

vote: Xiahou

I've been saying he was a suspect since before it was cool. This gold thing settles it

No, because he is going to have his first mate spite vig me. Or shoot me himself.

First mate can vig?


___________________________________

The C(s)argo also needs to be thrown overboard

Yes. Lynch Xiahou because there's a chance that the frenchman has more starting gold. Let's ignore anyone else that might have a highly suspicious role setup.

Why is the ghost of seireikhaan still posting? Should he not be in Davy Jones' Locker? Is the Flying Dutchman upon us?

Lying is such an ugly word. I'm saying he's wrong. I do not have 200 gold.
I really do appreciate the amount of attention that is being drawn to my finances though. It's really helpful. Suggesting that I'm fantastically wealthy will no doubt be oh so helpful for my future here. Thanks.

Right now you need to be giving us a compelling reason to spare your life, not panicking about you're gold

[Csargo]

Unvote:, Vote:Gaius

[Ishmael]

So Double A threw Visorslash in the brig N1, and came up with the right gold total. Then Visor did the same to Xiahou, and came up with a gold total that Xiahou denies. The only ways that I can see to interpret this is that either Xiahou started with or acquired extra gold by some means that he'd rather be lynched for than reveal, or that Visorslash is lying through his teeth. And as Double A pointed out, the latter would be a frankly suicidal move.

vote: Xiahou

[Visor]

What do you think we're playing here, Audit Mafia?

Come up with another line.

Throw him to.... the Loan Sharks.

[Xiahou]

*sigh* Look, night 1, Captain Kage suggested I steal from TFT because he was about to be killed (I was told). Stealing? On the captain's orders no less? Fantastic! Night 1, I stole. Day 2, I got gold as part of the mutiny dog-pile. Night 2, I didn't do anything, but I did get money from a will- I wasn't told who, but it doesn't seem hard to figure out.

And still, I don't have 200 gold. If he's claiming he got this information as part of his role powers, then the only conclusion I can reach is that he's french scum. First he said I started with 150, then later he said I had 200. Both are wrong. But how did he arrive at the 150 number? Is that how much a frenchie starts out with.... hmmm visor?

edit:
vote: Mutiny
Double A and Visor both seem pretty shady right now. I also wouldn't forget completely about landlubber either. He's been awfully quiet since he was the lynching runner-up last time.

[Visor]

I said you started with 150 because there was a gold difference when I did the math.

If you had gotten a will, you would've claimed it when I asked why you had so much gold. There was literally no reason to not claim it there.

[Montmorency]

Why would he lie about a power that is confirmed by Double A - unless they're both somehow scum?

Alternatively, why would he lie about your stash and drum up a lynch for you when there were multiple candidates for the lynch being mooted during the previous night?

[Csargo]

Xiahou also recruited me, so he should have been given gold for that.

[GeneralHankerchief]

In case this wasn't seen:

edit:
vote: Mutiny
Double A and Visor both seem pretty shady right now. I also wouldn't forget completely about landlubber either. He's been awfully quiet since he was the lynching runner-up last time.

If you're adding a vote, please do so in a new post. I'll allow it this time because I caught it, but for the future.

[Visor]

Xiahou also recruited me, so he should have been given gold for that.

Yes I took that into account.

I took into account him stealing first night as well, and I took into account sent actions.

[Visor]

See, the Kage mutiny had reasons. The Double A mutiny has none.

Can you point to a single scummy thing that AA has done?

Can you point to a single thing I've done that is scummy besides generic shady business behind closed doors which literally everyone in the game can attest to me not doing?

[Csargo]

Yes I took that into account.

I took into account him stealing first night as well, and I took into account sent actions.

Okay, just making sure it was accounted for.

[seireikhaan]

Can you point to a single scummy thing that AA has done?

No, I cannot.

[Xiahou]

See, the Kage mutiny had reasons. The Double A mutiny has none.

Can you point to a single scummy thing that AA has done?

Apparently, he's lying about the gold counting power of the quarter master. You're the only person who can corroborate it and you're claiming to have used it yourself- which I have on good authority, my own, that you don't have the right number.

[Zack]

Can you point to a single thing I've done that is scummy besides generic shady business behind closed doors which literally everyone in the game can attest to me not doing?

Your avatar has a goatee.

[Visor]

Apparently, he's lying about the gold counting power of the quarter master. You're the only person who can corroborate it and you're claiming to have used it yourself- which I have on good authority, my own, that you don't have the right number.

Let's assume for the moment that I'm wrong. How far am I off?

[Visor]

Your avatar has a goatee.

I plead insanity.

[Gaius Scribonius Curio]

Gaius, do you have anything to say about Csargo?

Only that I trust him (marginally) more than others in this game. I have no firm evidence as to his alignment, but we pulled a protection job together Night 1 (no attack came). He then told me unprompted that he had been asked by Kagemusha to protect Andres with Ituralde, did not, but received a PM from the latter saying that the protection was successful (no attack).

Since he did not know how this was possible (the rules state that simply the target surviving is enough for payment), such a revelation suggests to me that he, at least, actually protected our target.

[Double A]

When I blocked Visor, confirmed he had the amount GH reported to me.

Why would he lie about a power that is confirmed by Double A - unless they're both somehow scum?

why would a scum captain ever put one of his mooks in the limelight

[Xiahou]

Apparently, he's lying about the gold counting power of the quarter master. You're the only person who can corroborate it and you're claiming to have used it yourself- which I have on good authority, my own, that you don't have the right number.

Also, take a look at the sum total of Double A's posts. It's the pirate ship equivalent of voting present. A few silly cracks and nothing but throwaway, unsubstantiated votes. I find it suspicious.