Ugh, do you want to examine this even further?
How many turbos and games have I played where I have placed myself in a position of reading someone's alignment based on trivia or nothing? Hell, I strongly scum-read someone once for being one of three non-posters. Specifically that player, too, not the other two.
Right now, I have a dead to rights villager in the non-poster pile.
You want me to explain that? I can't. I'm not going to do so. There's absolutely nothing I could possibly say that could make anyone ever come around to understanding how I do that.
Bookmarks