Visor's Small Mafia Game [Concluded]

[Riedquat]

Quat is pissed!

Explicit N1 orders: Kill choxorn, Stork, Al sips and monty with a single bullet!

Thank you!

[GeneralHankerchief]

Moderator note: Per the host's request, I have restored the above post to its original contents.

Please obviously keep the "no posting at night" rules in mind.

GH

[Visor]

reminder to not post at night.

also don't edit

etc


scarlett aria was killed, they were town.

48 hours for day.

https://www.timeanddate.com/countdow...7&font=cursive

Alive: 13/15
1. Renata
2. Stork
3. Askthepizzaguy
4. BSmith
6. El Barto
7. Montmorency
8. GeneralHankerchief
9. Al Sipsclar
10. Zack
11. Choxorn
12. Newyn
13. Atheotes
14. Riedquat

Dead: 2/15
5. Dp101, Town, lynched D1.
15. Scarlett Aria, Town, killed N1.

[Montmorency]

Zack, any comments on yesterday's lynch process?

GH, any comments on yesterday's lynch?

Pizza, any comments?


Riedquat is too confident again.

[Stork]

blah, i guess

lynching dp sucked pretty bad t b h

dunno why alette gets killed she is reasonable lynch bait i would think

will reread her i guess, though that stuff is all wifom

[Stork]

gotta think quat is a wolf making that last post for ??? no reason i think

[Stork]

the two people i signed up to play with aren't here anymore :sob:

[Renata]

The more Renata talks, the more I get the feeling I should follow through with my initial read of Renata scum.

Newyn doesn't believe this. I've just switched back to Dp at this point and he's on Dp himself. If he believed this, he'd have switched to Riedquat on the spot.

[Montmorency]

the two people i signed up to play with aren't here anymore :sob:

Not at all, but he is presenting a lot of bravado, and that's usually a scum-tell for him. Of course, he might have become overall more confident after his performance in the previous games.

Newyn doesn't believe this. I've just switched back to Dp at this point and he's on Dp himself. If he believed this, he'd have switched to Riedquat on the spot.

Sounds like the Pizza School of Analysis.

[Renata]

the two people i signed up to play with aren't here anymore :sob:

Well, why'd you murder Alette, then?

Kidding; I think you and Monty look pretty decent for being around at end of day pushing the opponent to a wagon on a townie. How decent depends on how hard you pushed, I guess, which I don't entirely remember.

I think atheotes looks good even though he was wrong. Coming up with the thing on Al Sipsclar in the middle of that seems townie-ish, maybe.

Reads other than Riedquat?

[Renata]

Sounds like the Pizza School of Analysis.

I'll take that as a compliment.

[Stork]

agree about newyns popin

agree al sips can be a wolf though he is utr enough that i don't have a lot of confidence either way

theres some decent world building if quat is a wolf, less easy if he isn't

don't think you letting it go to a flip is that bad even if he is a wolf but its pretty bad

idk

[Stork]

i think gh is wolfier for having edited that post too

#gross reads

[Renata]

don't think you letting it go to a flip is that bad even if he is a wolf but its pretty bad

idk

I don't understand that line.

[GeneralHankerchief]

I want to talk about this post:

I've isoed everyone, and can't make my mind.
If I were mafia, I'd leave town DP to the endgame. I think DP might still be town, though. His wagon is probably mostly town, there might be a single scum there.
Don't like GH, but I never like him. Same with Monty.
Don't like Pizza, Quat, Chox.

This post is full of contradictions and very little commitments.

He says he's ISO'd everyone but can't make up his mind, and yet lists four or five suspects, a couple of whom have votes and none of whom are DP.

He says he doesn't like me but he never likes me. This would ordinarily be fine save for the fact that my playstyle this game has been noticeably different than in other recent games and other people have commented on it. I don't think this reasoning holds up under scrutiny.

He eventually waffles and votes DP because he says he wants a resolution, but then he says he supports calls for claims and abandons ship to the Riedquat wagon (Riedquat being still unresolved).

[Stork]

I don't understand that line.

i mean, you could have saved dp and didn't, against ried who:
if wolf - you look bad but not that bad
if villa - you look ok but a little worse

right?

[Montmorency]

I don't understand that line.

Yeah, um, Stork, could you rephrase that entire post?


I agree with GH.

[Renata]

i mean, you could have saved dp and didn't, against ried who:
if wolf - you look bad but not that bad
if villa - you look ok but a little worse

right?

I still don't entirely get it, but I'm not going to argue.

[Montmorency]

GH, can you give a post mortem on your choice of lynch?

[GeneralHankerchief]

GH, can you give a post mortem on your choice of lynch?

I stand by my reasoning and my vote. He looked scummy; he just happened to be innocent.

It happens sometimes. Not going to get too broken up about it.

[Stork]

i mean, you could have saved the top poster, who i said was likely a villager

but instead you let it go to a flip with ried, who you agree is wolfy at eod

looks kinda bad if ried a wolf right?

i think it isn't damning in that case ok?

[GeneralHankerchief]

i mean, you could have saved the top poster, who i said was likely a villager

but instead you let it go to a flip with ried, who you agree is wolfy at eod

looks kinda bad if ried a wolf right?

i think it isn't damning in that case ok?

Who was this directed at?

[Montmorency]

I stand by my reasoning and my vote. He looked scummy; he just happened to be innocent.

It happens sometimes. Not going to get too broken up about it.

Polished. I acknowledge it.


Stork, could you specifically explain your sentence on "world-building"?

[Renata]

i mean, you could have saved the top poster, who i said was likely a villager

but instead you let it go to a flip with ried, who you agree is wolfy at eod

looks kinda bad if ried a wolf right?

i think it isn't damning in that case ok?

Yeah, I get that part; it's the v/v part I don't get. Obviously I look bad if Riedquat is wolf, because I could have buried him and didn't.

[Renata]

Who was this directed at?

Me.

[Renata]

Scarlett had a vote on Monty at end of day (for seeming off/less willing to say things) than she remembered. I don't see anything resembling a breadcrumb of a power role, much less a n0 peek or anything like that. It's possible they killed her on the chance of being a n0 peek of Pizza's, but why not just kill Pizza then? All else being equal I'm going to say there's nothing to learn here, and it was just going after a townie who might have been a little more quiet than expected/possible power role.

[Montmorency]

Well, there is Pizza spouting off that Scarlett was his #1 lock townie. And BSmith who guessed it?

[Renata]

Right.

I just looked at Al Sipsclar again. I don't see him being wolf with Riedquat. I think wolf with choxorn is possible. Choxorn was getting noise about the time Al Sips made his two votes, for one of the non-choxorn options and then for the other, with no reasoning in between.

I should look at choxorn.

Newyn could be wolf with anyone.

[Stork]

Polished. I acknowledge it.


Stork, could you specifically explain your sentence on "world-building"?

i mean: it went to a flip, so people around at eod had the opportunity to impact on his wagons in ways that would be telling if he is a wolf

[Stork]

Who was this directed at?

the last person who asked me a question i guess
probably renata