Visor's Small Mafia Game [Concluded]

[Renata]

I disagree but fair enough. It could well be all three of them.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Vote: Atheotes

A futile gesture, but I'd like to be right once this game.

[Renata]

So would we all.

[Newyn]

Pizza/Renata/BSmith is my scum team.
A moment of madness made me change when I shouldn't have because I refused to believe that Pizza could rand scum 3 games in a row.
Renata's 1-shot bp claim is a very convenient excuse for why he doesn't get night killed.
Bsmith said he wants khaan or Pizza but votes to save Pizza.

Vote: Pizza

[Renata]

Pizza/Renata/BSmith is my scum team.
A moment of madness made me change when I shouldn't have because I refused to believe that Pizza could rand scum 3 games in a row.

Oh please. Pull the other one, it's got bells on.

Renata's 1-shot bp claim is a very convenient excuse for why he doesn't get night killed.

Is this your way of telling me you're going to wimp out of shooting at me tonight, too?

[Newyn]

I do not believe khaan can be scum because I think Renata is almost always scum here and he could have saved khaan d2 if they were both scum.

[Newyn]

Oh please. Pull the other one, it's got bells on.



Is this your way of telling me you're going to wimp out of shooting at me tonight, too?

You made the claim to support Pizza's claim of 1 shot, you claimed to be given the bp vest.
This is a simple setup, there are no roles I'd consider simple that would magically give or receive a BP during a game.
You're either scum buddies with Pizza or the SK. You been SK could actually explain why there's no lylo announcement.

[Newyn]

In a world where Renata is sk, I can see Khaan been scum with Pizza but in a world with a sk, we already lost.

[Newyn]

Actually, thoughts on a 2 mafia, sk "mountainous" setup?
That could explain why we havn't had a PR claim all game outside of Pizza/Renata.

[Renata]

You made the claim to support Pizza's claim of 1 shot, you claimed to be given the bp vest.
This is a simple setup, there are no roles I'd consider simple that would magically give or receive a BP during a game.

Inventor. That's why I assumed Pizza had been given a one-shot vig, not had it originally, check my ISO. I mentioned my vest hoping for some kind of handshake from others who might have received something or from the inventor themselves; when I got nothing, I started asking more pointed questions about the vig because then the obvious assumption starts to become the Inventor gave the power to a scum.

You're either scum buddies with Pizza or the SK. You been SK could actually explain why there's no lylo announcement.

This from someone who just tried to sell that a bulletproof vest was too much for a simple game now wants to posit a SK who's killed nobody. You should quite while you're behind.

[El Barto]

OK, so that was storybook nonsense, and it throws quite a lot of shade.

Renata, that did not look good overall.

Atheotes more or less did what was expected, but those analysis posts didn't have a lot of substance.

As we all witnessed, Newyn clutched that whole round, and BSmith technically helped, but given the timing and sequence I can conclude that there is no way they are partners. No more than one of them could be scum now.

This is the Era of Bad Feelings, and somehow El Barto is the closest thing to null I have now.

So let's stick with what I know, which is two things:
1. Khaan must be lynched.
2. Pizza must be lynched.

Vote: Khaan

Pizza can't serve as the immediate consensus wagon, as we learn little from its course. I will probably be voting him by the end of the day, but by Khaan's own admission I should not let the pressure slide from him.

Once we have set out those things which we know, namely that Khaan and Pizza are scum, we at least have a little more time to discover the final, deep, scum.

Wouldn't that be so neat, that Newyn would expose himself at the last minute, and take the lynch from some inconvenient other target.

I will vote to lynch the two scum-in-hand before any prospectives. The endgame has arrived. You know what that means.

Pizza+Newyn/Khaan+You would fit these posts. vote:Montmorency

[Renata]

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Inventor

I've played with this role before; my first and only suspicion after receiving a bp vest at some point after receipt of a vanilla role PM.

[Askthepizzaguy]

There's no SK in this game. It would have been me if it was anyone, because I claimed the one shot.

You're looking for a team of three most likely, and there's probably powers in play that can stop a murder, therefore no lylo was called.

Instead of faffing about on exploring options which already result in town having lost the game, focus on the universe where town can still win and lynch the best candidate from that universe.

If that's me, the game will be over this round, so we can see what went wrong. Butter me up, I'm toast anyway.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Ridiculous vote splitting is the icing on the trainwreck.

[Renata]

You're looking for a team of three most likely, and there's probably powers in play that can stop a murder, therefore no lylo was called.

Ya think? ;)

[Askthepizzaguy]

Ya think? ;)

I don't think you actually have a bp, because it makes no sense for a villager to claim it.

The idea is to draw a murder, not tip off the scums not to shoot there.

[Newyn]

Inventor. That's why I assumed Pizza had been given a one-shot vig, not had it originally, check my ISO. I mentioned my vest hoping for some kind of handshake from others who might have received something or from the inventor themselves; when I got nothing, I started asking more pointed questions about the vig because then the obvious assumption starts to become the Inventor gave the power to a scum.



This from someone who just tried to sell that a bulletproof vest was too much for a simple game now wants to posit a SK who's killed nobody. You should quite while you're behind.

Never even heard of that role before just now. SK would fit my definition of simple, inventor doesn't.
Lack of kills every night can easily be explained by sk and wolves going for the same targets one night and mafia hitting sk vest another night.

Pizza, if you're town, sell me a potential scum team that I can believe in. I think I pretty much have to vote with you now since I don't see any world where I don't get mislynched eventually and lose us the game if you're scum.

[Renata]

I don't think you actually have a bp, because it makes no sense for a villager to claim it.

The idea is to draw a murder, not tip off the scums not to shoot there.

I don't care. Playing games with the scums over it is redeeming this whole game for me. I'm glad I did.

[Renata]

Never even heard of that role before just now. SK would fit my definition of simple, inventor doesn't.
Lack of kills every night can easily be explained by sk and wolves going for the same targets one night and mafia hitting sk vest another night.

Pizza, if you're town, sell me a potential scum team that I can believe in. I think I pretty much have to vote with you now since I don't see any world where I don't get mislynched eventually and lose us the game if you're scum.

Don't worry, Monty will save you.

[El Barto]

I don't think you actually have a bp, because it makes no sense for a villager to claim it.

The idea is to draw a murder, not tip off the scums not to shoot there.

Wouldn't a 1-off bulletproof be the best person to try to draw a nightkill?

[Montmorency]

I do not believe khaan can be scum because I think Renata is almost always scum here and he could have saved khaan d2 if they were both scum.

But - Khaan is still alive, so he was - saved? What are you saying here again?

Don't worry, Monty will save you.

By lynching Khaan? Or are you claiming that I have some kind of power?

@El Barto: I can hardly believe that you're one of the less scummy players left right now.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Never even heard of that role before just now. SK would fit my definition of simple, inventor doesn't.
Lack of kills every night can easily be explained by sk and wolves going for the same targets one night and mafia hitting sk vest another night.

Pizza, if you're town, sell me a potential scum team that I can believe in. I think I pretty much have to vote with you now since I don't see any world where I don't get mislynched eventually and lose us the game if you're scum.

You would like to have a game where we only kill the people that I, askthepizzaguy, wanted to lynch or vig, and all of them have been townies so far.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Given that I've been the focus of half of the game and we've gone after the people I've pointed at, let's try something different.

Just for fun.

Perhaps someone else can start naming suspects that don't end in "guy".

[Renata]

By lynching Khaan? Or are you claiming that I have some kind of power?

By lynching Khaan, yes.

[Montmorency]

Name a suspect who doesn't start with the letter "a".

[Renata]

Given that I've been the focus of half of the game and we've gone after the people I've pointed at, let's try something different.

Just for fun.

Perhaps someone else can start naming suspects that don't end in "guy".

ATPG and Pizza, they're scummy.

[Askthepizzaguy]

ATPG and Pizza, they're scummy.

Very well.

Unvote: atheotes
Vote: Renata

[Askthepizzaguy]

Strike 1: Calling for the vig to claim
Strike 2: Claiming bulletproof
Strike 3: Only suspect is me

[Askthepizzaguy]

I got 4 strikes this game but I have the special askthepizzaguy card that allows me to be wrong 4 times and still win games.

[El Barto]

By lynching Khaan? Or are you claiming that I have some kind of power?

There were two kills on the same night once - Night 2 IIRC.

@El Barto: I can hardly believe that you're one of the less scummy players left right now.

Get off it, mate.

Given that I've been the focus of half of the game and we've gone after the people I've pointed at, let's try something different.

Just for fun.

Perhaps someone else can start naming suspects that don't end in "guy".

Name a suspect who doesn't start with the letter "a".

‘Sooh's husband’.
‘Montmorency’.