French Revolution Mafia [Concluded]

[Montmorency]

Reveals would only present the illusion of certainty.

Are you saying the post-mortem investigations are invalid?

[Renata]

Are you saying the post-mortem investigations are invalid?

No, I'm saying that all of us revealing our factions and then playing from there would not be as revealing of people's motivations as you think. Faction members would still be trying to whittle down opposing numbers whenever they could get away with it. Royalists would still be hiding their motivations.

All it does is remove the fun of trying to hide your own faction alliances and to ferret out connections between other players.

[Montmorency]

No, I'm saying that all of us revealing our factions and then playing from there would not be as revealing of people's motivations as you think. Faction members would still be trying to whittle down opposing numbers whenever they could get away with it. Royalists would still be hiding their motivations.

All it does is remove the fun of trying to hide your own faction alliances and to ferret out connections between other players.

In secrecy our convention cannot help but indulge in tyranny, against the genuine pressing needs of the country.

[Lewwyn]

Against faction reveals. I think... Scum is scum, even if its in my faction or another faction. Scum is scummy and as long as we all partake of scumhunting in the main thread then scum will be caught out.