Well, that's the most recent scum game of his I participated in.
Is that a yes?
How were his posting/bussing tendencies in that game? I have my own recollection but I'd like to hear yours, since you were a teammate and I wasn't always following the game that closely.
(Winston, it's my personal estimation. Of course they could both be town.)
Zack, in both games there would be about the same number of posts to look at. Khaan didn't say much in QT then, he isn't saying much now. Hard to get a broad analysis with this little content, so better to look for unique elements. First, here are Khaan's posts in this game.
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
Originally Posted by seireikhaan
Hello, everyone, I'd like to welcome you to another day of "the joys of lynching." If this is your first time with us, then I personally invite you to grab your torches and pitchforks and deliver some justice along with the rest us. Over the next few days, we'll go over a variety of tactics to flush out royalists, and with any luck, we'll make this a nice, quick game. So, thanks for joining us, and let us get started. Now, I have to say, my first thought here is that NotACop is looking pretty suspicious. The fedora is, secretly, a sign of the royal family, and boy that sure makes me think that he must be looking to find some unsavory friends with a post like that.
Vote: NotACop
Right after NAC comes into the thread voting Manasi.
Originally Posted by seireikhaan
So folks, here we have a nice little case of what we'll call "wifom". Now I don't see this back and forth meaning all that much, and it's always a happy time to be with Askthepizzaguy and Renata, so I'm not going to vote on this, but if this is the sort of thing that makes you feeling just a bit paranoid, feel free to start votes on either one.
On Pizza-Renata links. "Feel free to start votes on either one".
Originally Posted by seireikhaan
Well now there's no need to be washing our hands until we've settled on a lynch. Of course you don't want the blood to get stained into the skin, but I don't think we'll be doing any scrubbing until our first mislynch. Unless we feel like getting real crazy and start mixing our colors. Hmm, you know, that might be a good idea, actually, but we'll be wanting to play that by ear, I think.
To Renata after response to previous post
Originally Posted by seireikhaan
So here we are, friends, with what looks like it could be a real example of a royalist being paranoid of looking like they were on the bandwagon of an innocent townsperson. Your average mafia will not want to be on the day one lynch, because if that comes up as an innocent, it'll be the first place we go barging in to beat the nillies out of people. So, I think I'll go ahead and slide my vote on over here, and I'll encourage all of you to think about this for yourselves and see how it rings to you.
Unvote: NotACop
Vote: Jabbz
Particularly striking language in this post. And similar language to the case he didn't pursue against Renata: "I'll encourage all of you to think about this for yourselves..."
Originally Posted by seireikhaan
Hello again everyone, and welcome back to day two of "The Joys of Lynching". Last time we nabbed ourselves a royalist, an excellent start. I'm going to go ahead this round and Vote: Dp101. Now, I've played my share as mafia in the past, and especially with results on death, I can tell you that DP's vote at the end of the day doesn't look great to me. Some might call it a sealing vote for a royalist, but to me, that looks like a good old fashioned, meaningless late bus to try and give some cover.
Case against DP on Day 2.
Originally Posted by seireikhaan
Well not to be the bearer of bad news, but the timing speaks for itself. Even if this was a rock solid stroke of logic, it wouldn't mean a whole lot because the actual vote speaks a heckuva lot louder.
???
So far in this game Khaan hasn't really spoken to anyone directly, or been asked of much. Without presenting all his Futuramafia posts, I can note a big difference in Khaan's play (9 posts) came from his being directly engaged by vig virtuoso CrimsonFox (who later vigged Khaan). Crimson was aggressive and Khaan was a bit pissed off, saying he didn't really think Crimson was scum but his attitude justified a vote.
Here is a bit from one of Khaan's biggest posts, going back and forth on Crimson and some random other stuff (Pizza and I were his partners).
Anyways, I'm starting to wonder if I didn't psych myself out on Fox. My initial gut still says he's too brazen to be mafia. But, then again, I've always said that the best way to play scum roles is to do that which the gut wouldn't believe. Another part of me wants to lynch him just to hopefully reduce the postcount a bit so I don't have so much catching up to do after work. But mostly, now I'm really not liking this flip flopping on your potential role. To reiterate Barto: Are you a vig, or are you not? That claim towards the end of the round... as I said earlier, brazen, especially with possible mafia buds to bus you. But, if you're neutral/independent, then that makes a lot more sense. Screw it,
Vote: CrimsonFox
I see his style so far in this game as closer to Futuramafia than Visor's Small Game, once you look past the artistic flair. It's more a case against town-reading Khan than for lynching him today.
Vitiate Man.
History repeats the old conceits
The glib replies, the same defeats
Town lean on Lewwyn, scum lean on Khaan. Vanishingly-small odds that both are scum. Given my leans, I feel one being scum is more likely than both being town. This is pretty plain. Are you thinking of something in particular?
Vitiate Man.
History repeats the old conceits
The glib replies, the same defeats
Town lean on Lewwyn, scum lean on Khaan. Vanishingly-small odds that both are scum. Given my leans, I feel one being scum is more likely than both being town. This is pretty plain. Are you thinking of something in particular?
I still don't get how you ended up linking the reads on them.
I see how one being scum makes it very unlikely the other is scum too, but I don't see how one being town makes the other one much more likely to be scum, given the number of other suspects available.
Welcome back to our third day of "The Joys of Lynching". Unfortunately, we weren't quite on the ball last time, but I'm sure we'll make up for it this time. Now, I don't have a whole lot to tell you, Montmorency. I myself wanted a DP101 lynch yesterday, and I still want one today. That's my priority. Divulging the rest of my thoughts doesn't mean a whole lot in my opinion. I still think his vote day 1 amounts to a late, meaningless bus. He didn't need to vote, and to be plain, could have stayed asleep for all the difference it made. His most recent post doesn't strike me with any great degree of town either.
Vote: DP101
It is better to conquer yourself than to win a thousand battles. Then, the victory is yours. It cannot be taken from you, not by angels or by demons, heaven or hell.
Welcome back to our third day of "The Joys of Lynching". Unfortunately, we weren't quite on the ball last time, but I'm sure we'll make up for it this time. Now, I don't have a whole lot to tell you, Montmorency. I myself wanted a DP101 lynch yesterday, and I still want one today. That's my priority. Divulging the rest of my thoughts doesn't mean a whole lot in my opinion. I still think his vote day 1 amounts to a late, meaningless bus. He didn't need to vote, and to be plain, could have stayed asleep for all the difference it made. His most recent post doesn't strike me with any great degree of town either.
It's hard not to read that from the words you used.
If they're portrayed as linked, perhaps it's because they are in the sense of being in my faction.
Originally Posted by Winston Hughes
Other than the obvious, who's town for you?
Manasi, Renata, Zack are obvious. Other than that, the only strong town-lean is Choxorn, then Al Sipsclar. From there, Snerk, Lewwyn, Barto on special circumstance...
You and auto are in temporary abeyance until further information presents itself.
Vitiate Man.
History repeats the old conceits
The glib replies, the same defeats
Afraid I don't have a great handle on our friend right now. I'll need to reread again with a better focus on him.
It is better to conquer yourself than to win a thousand battles. Then, the victory is yours. It cannot be taken from you, not by angels or by demons, heaven or hell.
If they're portrayed as linked, perhaps it's because they are in the sense of being in my faction.
It's a small point, obviously, but I've got to give you a scum mark for making that link, because I can more easily see how a scum mind goes there than a town one.
Originally Posted by Montmorency
Manasi, Renata, Zack are obvious. Other than that, the only strong town-lean is Choxorn, then Al Sipsclar. From there, Snerk, Lewwyn, Barto on special circumstance...
You and auto are in temporary abeyance until further information presents itself.
Wait a second, you have Al Sipsclar about the same tier as I do.
Originally Posted by Winston Hughes
I've scanned the whole thread, but only read properly up to post 585.
I'll read the rest a bit later, but here's where my reads are at:
Renata - town or wtf
Zack - town or wtf
Manasi - very townie
khaan - seems safe
Lewwyn - check this again
Dp101 - check this again
chox - post 556, 558 etc look townie
Al Sips - post 558 pizza gives town reason
Snerk - post 574 monty gives town reason, post 582 renata gives town reason
Barto - post 582 renata gives town reason
Auto - getting towncred from others, not clear on reasons
Monty - ditto
NAC - probable scum
Csargo - probable scum
And you already knew what Pizza said about Al.
Vitiate Man.
History repeats the old conceits
The glib replies, the same defeats
Originally Posted by Zack
Re: French Revolution Mafia [In Play]
If they're portrayed as linked, perhaps it's because they are in the sense of being in my faction.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks