XCOM Mafia [Concluded]

[Zack]

@GeneralHankerchief has replaced @Champ.

Do not discuss substitutions.

[Dp101]

Hi GH! Read much?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Hey guys.

Haven't read a thing, probably won't before tomorrow. Can I get a quick summary?

[Fredwood]

There goes Bart, misrepresenting and conveniently leaving out contradictory data again.

You're really bad at setting up mislynches huh? Literally said I was going to focus on townclearing and not try to scumhunt.

I can tell you one person who I haven't cleared.

I feel better about Sooh, at the very least there's effort in appearing townie which could be exploited. Manasi still is a bit null but I have a feeling she's the queen of null reads. There is the push on Sooh, but the pressure isn't aggressive or confrontational enough to eliminate the possibility of a W/W scenario and just setting up a contrarian IG relationship. So not willing to extrapolate a read on the other based on one's flip.

Winston and Montgomery seem null but have context and content that's been generated, Winston seems to be more analytical of the meta but did self-clear Pizza and Cuth in a concise and specific manner, so giving him pluses.

The Monty interactions have been interesting this phase. Amusing at the very least.

I should have questions, the only ones I have are to someone I'm washing my hands of. So, I'm just kind of blankly staring at the screen currently.

[Zack]

Official Tally as of #964

----

Day 2 ends in:

----

1 Askthepizzaguy (Cuthillius)
1 Fredwood (El Barto)
1 GeneralHankerchief (novice)
1 Montmorency (Sooh)
1 Sooh (Manasi)

----

Not Voting: Askthepizzaguy, Csargo, Dp101, Fredwood, GeneralHankerchief, Montmorency, Winston Hughes

Not Posting: @autolycus, @BSmith, @crimson_snow, @Logic

----

If you notice anything wrong, PM me.

[Csargo]

Fredwood:

Fredwood is sort of hard for me to read. I don't particularly like this post:

Oh, I do love Eddie Izzard.

I hope you have noticed that I am voting for you to be hanged from the neck until you die.

Cake please.

Seems like a you problem not a me problem. I guess I could beg but if I get lynched day 1 in my first game, then I get lynched day 1 in my first game. The Random gods must be sated.

I think the tone's off in response to Barto. Honestly, don't think much of the back and forth between both of them wasn't very good. Neither looked good from that argument imo.

The problem is I really liked Fredwood's interactions with ATPG from the tone and points he made. Looks good from that interaction, and not the best from the Barto one.

I'd agree that he's been defensive/reactionary, but it's understandable given the situation, so I'm not really going to hold that against him. New forum might have him a bit on edge, so I'd just chalk it up to that for now.

Would like to more reads honestly before I make a final call on my lean. Fairly sparse in that department I feel, so that's something I'd really like to see from him today.

Vague thoughts really.

[GeneralHankerchief]

There goes Bart, misrepresenting and conveniently leaving out contradictory data again.

You're really bad at setting up mislynches huh? Literally said I was going to focus on townclearing and not try to scumhunt.

I can tell you one person who I haven't cleared.

I feel better about Sooh, at the very least there's effort in appearing townie which could be exploited. Manasi still is a bit null but I have a feeling she's the queen of null reads. There is the push on Sooh, but the pressure isn't aggressive or confrontational enough to eliminate the possibility of a W/W scenario and just setting up a contrarian IG relationship. So not willing to extrapolate a read on the other based on one's flip.

Winston and Montgomery seem null but have context and content that's been generated, Winston seems to be more analytical of the meta but did self-clear Pizza and Cuth in a concise and specific manner, so giving him pluses.

The Monty interactions have been interesting this phase. Amusing at the very least.

I should have questions, the only ones I have are to someone I'm washing my hands of. So, I'm just kind of blankly staring at the screen currently.

Without having read a single thing, all these reads appear to check out in terms of people acting in line with expectations.

[Csargo]

Hey guys.

Haven't read a thing, probably won't before tomorrow. Can I get a quick summary?

@GeneralHankerchief GH. Give me soul reads. Go!

[Dp101]

Hey guys.

Haven't read a thing, probably won't before tomorrow. Can I get a quick summary?

I was pushed D1 by Csargo and Pizza, Pizza was also pushing Jowy who everyone thought was independently scummy and thus he died, and some people were defending me and voting Csargo. Those were the major wagons. If I got something wrong, someone please correct me.

[Csargo]

I was pushed D1 by Csargo and Pizza, Pizza was also pushing Jowy who everyone thought was independently scummy and thus he died, and some people were defending me and voting Csargo. Those were the major wagons. If I got something wrong, someone please correct me.

I think that's pretty spot on.

[GeneralHankerchief]

I was pushed D1 by Csargo and Pizza, Pizza was also pushing Jowy who everyone thought was independently scummy and thus he died, and some people were defending me and voting Csargo. Those were the major wagons. If I got something wrong, someone please correct me.

Jowy flipped town I take it?

Who else died?

[Csargo]

Jowy flipped town I take it?

Who else died?

Nobody.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Nobody.

No nightkill?

We get any leads from that?

[Fredwood]

Fredwood:

Fredwood is sort of hard for me to read. I don't particularly like this post:



I think the tone's off in response to Barto. Honestly, don't think much of the back and forth between both of them wasn't very good. Neither looked good from that argument imo.

The problem is I really liked Fredwood's interactions with ATPG from the tone and points he made. Looks good from that interaction, and not the best from the Barto one.

I'd agree that he's been defensive/reactionary, but it's understandable given the situation, so I'm not really going to hold that against him. New forum might have him a bit on edge, so I'd just chalk it up to that for now.

Would like to more reads honestly before I make a final call on my lean. Fairly sparse in that department I feel, so that's something I'd really like to see from him today.

Vague thoughts really.

You're literally quoting the reaction test to see Bart's response. I was purposefully exhibiting what I thought was scum behavior to try and read his response for something that felt off to me. There was none, not even a mention and later switched. The reaction, or the lack of one, is the basis for my scum read on him, within the thread the progression should be obvious.

[Csargo]

You're literally quoting the reaction test to see Bart's response. I was purposefully exhibiting what I thought was scum behavior to try and read his response for something that felt off to me. There was none, not even a mention and later switched. The reaction, or the lack of one, is the basis for my scum read on him, within the thread the progression should be obvious.

Okay, that makes sense. Thanks.

[Csargo]

No nightkill?

We get any leads from that?

Monty thinks scum holstered.

[Fredwood]

No nightkill?

We get any leads from that?

None...I have a tinfoil mod brain theory about trying to incorporate flavor into the game, and think N1 was a ambush set up phase. I'm hoping i'm wrong but it would mean multiple kills in a single night phase.

[Montmorency]

Jowy flipped town I take it?

Who else died?

That's a very strange thing to ask.

[GeneralHankerchief]

That's a very strange thing to ask.

Hey Monty, nice to see you again too.

[Montmorency]

Monty thinks scum holstered.

Lol no

[Dp101]

Monty thinks scum holstered.

I thought that was a joke?

[Montmorency]

Hey Monty, nice to see you again too.

I assume you would have read the first page host posts.

You asking that sounds like a handshake re: why no one died.

[Csargo]

I thought that was a joke?

It was in all caps, I thought it was really serious. /s

[GeneralHankerchief]

I assume you would have read the first page host posts.

You asking that sounds like a handshake re: why no one died.

I said I haven't read a thing in the first post I made after subbing in. I meant what I said.

But congrats, you get my first townread of the game.

[Montmorency]

I said I haven't read a thing in the first post I made after subbing in. I meant what I said.

But congrats, you get my first townread of the game.

GH hasn't read the rules of the game!

[GeneralHankerchief]

I think that's my cue to head out for the night.

Looking forward to chatting with everybody and figuring out just what I've got myself into tomorrow.

[Csargo]

I said I haven't read a thing in the first post I made after subbing in. I meant what I said.

But congrats, you get my first townread of the game.

Congrats, you played yourself. 1st townread for Monty all game. That's not a good start.

[Montmorency]

1st townread for Monty all game.

False.

[Csargo]

False.

You can't count yourself.

Who else townread you?

[Montmorency]

You can't count yourself.

Who else townread you?

Manasi, and probably Pizza.