El Barto is so high on the list because I think his big post was just that townie and I am very disappointed that this was our #1 consensus scum for the entire day.
I read Monty again and I don't feel as justified defending him as I feel about Barto, but there are small tidbits that make me lean town on him.
I lost faith in my Cuth wolf read after his big re-entry post. I think it had some very good analysis and it would be quite impressive if he faked that as wolf. But he only touched upon 1/3 of the playerlist which is making me hesitant to put him higher on the list. Granted, he did talk about all of the most vocal players, but still.
Egix feels like he just sorta exists. His posts seem good on tone and the points he is making have merit, but it doesn't feel like he has a lot of presence and I don't really have a good idea of what the game is like to him yet. It's a slight town lean and I wouldn't wanna kill them today, but don't feel comfortable placing them higher either.
Capage just feels... very different from the last game I played with him where we were both villagers. Like he isn't providing reads in order to expose the self evident truth of everyone's alignment here but rather just to look like he's contributing. There is little specificity behind his reads and the ones that do have an explanation aren't that hot either.
Originally Posted by pzelda
Zack and Barto produced some activity and I definitely spotted them. The latter's definitely more lackluster of the two. Zack's late posts are solid and filled with micro reads. My only fear is that the read on him is so consensus.
Like this read here is just frankly bull. You said you liked his posts, why would everyone else thinking the same make Zack suspicious? It makes no sense. It's like you are on that level where you aware that slapping a lazy town read on Zack might make you look suspicious so you want to add some sort of tinfoil to your read.
insaner, why do you think he's wolf? is this gonna be like why you thought mendel was town?
I caught more wolves than you did in our hydra game.
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
Seriously though, I think he is very different from that game where he just entered by clearing pretty much every villager that posted up to that point. Here he seems much more hesitant to give reads/has less conviction, with weird tinfoils and shallow/no explanations for some of them. Since you were also in that game I feel like you should have an opinion on him.
Originally Posted by Insaner
Capage just feels... very different from the last game I played with him where we were both villagers. Like he isn't providing reads in order to expose the self evident truth of everyone's alignment here but rather just to look like he's contributing. There is little specificity behind his reads and the ones that do have an explanation aren't that hot either.
Like this read here is just frankly bull. You said you liked his posts, why would everyone else thinking the same make Zack suspicious? It makes no sense. It's like you are on that level where you aware that slapping a lazy town read on Zack might make you look suspicious so you want to add some sort of tinfoil to your read.
I caught more wolves than you did in our hydra game.
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
Seriously though, I think he is very different from that game where he just entered by clearing pretty much every villager that posted up to that point. Here he seems much more hesitant to give reads/has less conviction, with weird tinfoils and shallow/no explanations for some of them. Since you were also in that game I feel like you should have an opinion on him.
you were also VERY wrong about the ones you were wrong on. So excuse me if I don't have confidence in your reads without seeing a reason
Can anybody voting Barto right now tell me why they, individually, think that Barto is scum? Just off the top of your head. No wagon formation nonsense, just tell me - what has Barto done this game that made you think that he is a wolf?
Thanks for the possibly pocketing defence, but what the hell are you doing with the tally?
good lord| if you're telling the truth you're setting new records for scumminess as a townie -Renata on IM, 16/09/2011
Feles deliberatissimae subiugare humanitiati sunt, et res solae quae eas desinunt canes sunt.
I see I've been sigged yet again -Askthepizzaguy, 02/08/2012
Hindsight is 20/20 Askthepizzaguy, 10/07/2013
Re: 04/12 Generic Fantasy WW Game Thread
Originally Posted by pzelda
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks