04/12 Generic Fantasy WW Game Thread

[ladd]

I lost faith in my Cuth wolf read after his big re-entry post. I think it had some very good analysis and it would be quite impressive if he faked that as wolf. But he only touched upon 1/3 of the playerlist which is making me hesitant to put him higher on the list. Granted, he did talk about all of the most vocal players, but still.

I find it hard to believe that Cuth is actually this sensitive. You aren't clear to me, why would you get offended over me trying to put you in a spot? I think Cuth is faking being annoyed here so he doesn't have to answer my question and also make me look worse when all I wanted was to know why he doesn't agree with Logic being town.

cuth, the sick wolf, is too scared to answer a simple question?

[dyachei]

I find it hard to believe that Cuth is actually this sensitive. You aren't clear to me, why would you get offended over me trying to put you in a spot? I think Cuth is faking being annoyed here so he doesn't have to answer my question and also make me look worse when all I wanted was to know why he doesn't agree with Logic being town.

why cant he be annoyed as either alignment? like what makes it lock wolfy to you?

[Cuthillius]

I find it hard to believe that Cuth is actually this sensitive. You aren't clear to me, why would you get offended over me trying to put you in a spot? I think Cuth is faking being annoyed here so he doesn't have to answer my question and also make me look worse when all I wanted was to know why he doesn't agree with Logic being town.

Since when am I trying to make you look worse, genuinely? I think you're a villager, I've said that before.

With regards to the rest, I would classify it as "rather impatient with certain unproductive styles of interaction" rather than "sensitive", but you're free to have your own impression.

[Zack]

I find it hard to believe that Cuth is actually this sensitive. You aren't clear to me, why would you get offended over me trying to put you in a spot? I think Cuth is faking being annoyed here so he doesn't have to answer my question and also make me look worse when all I wanted was to know why he doesn't agree with Logic being town.

You never answered his question, that was asked first, but are all up in arms that he doesn't want to answer yours? (which again... is basically the same question you were asking him except his was actually first)

[Logic]

Since when am I trying to make you look worse, genuinely? I think you're a villager, I've said that before.

With regards to the rest, I would classify it as "rather impatient with certain unproductive styles of interaction" rather than "sensitive", but you're free to have your own impression.

Would you care to interact with me instead, Cuth?
AMA.

[Insaner]

You never answered his question, that was asked first, but are all up in arms that he doesn't want to answer yours? (which again... is basically the same question you were asking him except his was actually first)

Ya.

[Insaner]

How is me asking you for a Logic read unproductive Cuth

[ladd]

insaner 2frozen

can't answer my question

[Cuthillius]

Would you care to interact with me instead, Cuth?
AMA.

Sure. How's your day? Why did you categorize your read on GH as being similar to your read on Zack despite their very different behaviors this game? How do you feel about the person you're most familiar with meta-wise and how do you feel about the person you're least familiar with meta-wise in this game? Are you happy with the amount of content in the game so far? Do you have a question for me?

[Insaner]

cuth, the sick wolf, is too scared to answer a simple question?

It's hard to keep up the act I suppose. His recent read posts suck ballz

[Cuthillius]

How is me asking you for a Logic read unproductive Cuth

It's not, but you being obstructive is.

[ladd]

@gh @zac

what's your choxorn read and when(if) do you feel confident in reading him right?

yes, zack, I already now you think he is a wolf, just wondering how good you are at reading him, I vaguely remember you locking him in as v from spec chat during champs

[Insaner]

It's not, but you being obstructive is.

You weren't exactly cooperative either.

[ladd]

It's hard to keep up the act I suppose. His recent read posts suck ballz

your reasons for thinking he is a wolf are absurd regardless if he is one or not

your posts are the ones getting worse though

[Logic]

Sure. How's your day? Why did you categorize your read on GH as being similar to your read on Zack despite their very different behaviors this game? How do you feel about the person you're most familiar with meta-wise and how do you feel about the person you're least familiar with meta-wise in this game? Are you happy with the amount of content in the game so far? Do you have a question for me?

Decent, despite being at work. Internal network issues prevent me from doing research for my job, but I cna read and post just fine.
Being dead in all my recent games but this one mean this has my attention. The fact that I don't have a read but should, on both Zack and GH is concerning.

The only thing I can summon regarding a read on GH is that normally by now he would have called me scummy, or at the very least "wait and see" but last I saw he had me in a town-lean category.

As for Zack, his posts exist, but I can't for the life of me remember anything about them that make me want to categorize him one way or another.

[Cuthillius]

You weren't exactly cooperative either.

Oh gosh, you really weren't cooperative when you didn't want to wade through those sewers, I'd have paid you five dollars in cash!

[Insaner]

Looks like people are taking Cuth's side in this exchange. What a shame.

vote: Pzelda

We'll talk after this flips wolf. Glgl

(My second choice would be ladd byw)

[Cuthillius]

Decent, despite being at work. Internal network issues prevent me from doing research for my job, but I cna read and post just fine.
Being dead in all my recent games but this one mean this has my attention. The fact that I don't have a read but should, on both Zack and GH is concerning.

The only thing I can summon regarding a read on GH is that normally by now he would have called me scummy, or at the very least "wait and see" but last I saw he had me in a town-lean category.

As for Zack, his posts exist, but I can't for the life of me remember anything about them that make me want to categorize him one way or another.

Do you think you have been wolfy in the context of your usual play, or does he just always call you that?

Do you feel like you have a hard time reading Zack in general outside of this game?

[dyachei]

I didnt see an answer to my question, insaner. why is it wolfy to be annoyed with you?

[ladd]

The only thing I can summon regarding a read on GH is that normally by now he would have called me scummy, or at the very least "wait and see" but last I saw he had me in a town-lean category.

As for Zack, his posts exist, but I can't for the life of me remember anything about them that make me want to categorize him one way or another.

maybe you should try reading them since he is the top poster and by far the guy with the most content

[Cuthillius]

Looks like people are taking Cuth's side in this exchange. What a shame.

vote: Pzelda

We'll talk after this flips wolf. Glgl

(My second choice would be ladd byw)

I don't understand either of those reads, would you mind walking me through them?

[Insaner]

My read on Choxorn is that he is pretty much rand btw

[Insaner]

I didnt see an answer to my question, insaner. why is it wolfy to be annoyed with you?

It isn't. Do carry on with your day.

[ladd]

alrighty, here is the division of the jobs

I expect:

gh to give us a locked in logic read

dya and fable to give us a locked in read on each other

zack to give us a lock choxorn read

me (while I try to dodge being lunched) and empoof will take care of the trolling and the cat herding

[ladd]

Looks like people are taking Cuth's side in this exchange. What a shame.

vote: Pzelda

We'll talk after this flips wolf. Glgl

(My second choice would be ladd byw)

I could lunch p

[Zack]

@gh @zac

what's your choxorn read and when(if) do you feel confident in reading him right?

yes, zack, I already now you think he is a wolf, just wondering how good you are at reading him, I vaguely remember you locking him in as v from spec chat during champs

He seems almost cartoonishly serious and I don't recall much solving, things he's focused on have been strange and nitpicky

He was pretty laid back and joking around in champs as I recall

[ladd]

He seems almost cartoonishly serious and I don't recall much solving, things he's focused on have been strange and nitpicky

He was pretty laid back and joking around in champs as I recall

alrighty

let's try it

vote:Choxorn

[Insaner]

Insaner
merl1n
Zack
Empoof


Newyn
El Barto


Cuthillius
Egix
Montmorency


Csargo
Choxorn
Logic
Dyachei
Fable


Pzelda (Capage)
ladd
GeneralHankerchief



El Barto is so high on the list because I think his big post was just that townie and I am very disappointed that this was our #1 consensus scum for the entire day.


I read Monty again and I don't feel as justified defending him as I feel about Barto, but there are small tidbits that make me lean town on him.


I lost faith in my Cuth wolf read after his big re-entry post. I think it had some very good analysis and it would be quite impressive if he faked that as wolf. But he only touched upon 1/3 of the playerlist which is making me hesitant to put him higher on the list. Granted, he did talk about all of the most vocal players, but still.


Egix feels like he just sorta exists. His posts seem good on tone and the points he is making have merit, but it doesn't feel like he has a lot of presence and I don't really have a good idea of what the game is like to him yet. It's a slight town lean and I wouldn't wanna kill them today, but don't feel comfortable placing them higher either.


Capage just feels... very different from the last game I played with him where we were both villagers. Like he isn't providing reads in order to expose the self evident truth of everyone's alignment here but rather just to look like he's contributing. There is little specificity behind his reads and the ones that do have an explanation aren't that hot either.


Like this read here is just frankly bull. You said you liked his posts, why would everyone else thinking the same make Zack suspicious? It makes no sense. It's like you are on that level where you aware that slapping a lazy town read on Zack might make you look suspicious so you want to add some sort of tinfoil to your read.

There is my Capage read.

As for ladd, I just don't get the feeling that we are on the same team here. Like he is working against people I think are likely villa and is giving my wolf reads an easy pass. His reasons for his reads don't impress me either.

[Zack]

Have people suspecting Ladd this much every played with him before

This is pretty par for the course for how he'd begin a game as villa in my experience

[ladd]

As for ladd, I just don't get the feeling that we are on the same team here. Like he is working against people I think are likely villa and is giving my wolf reads an easy pass. His reasons for his reads don't impress me either.

like who?