Gemma's Favorite Music Mafia

[Lissa]

Ok cool, so the town part being similar is nice and tbh you disagree with the entirety of my wolf concerns is something I a.) find villagery and b.) could very well mean I'm just in the wrong half of my not bracketed off to the villa list people. Do you have specific wolf reads that differ or just kinda vibes so far

well I have come to the realization that I don't actually have any wolf reads

and like

too many v reads for that to like

work

so uh

hm

thread feels really villagery imo

makes me think a wolf hasn't posted yet but that's obv kind of a jank read to make on a number of levels

ladd's thing re: taffy does make me rethink my village read there somewhat

arctic is a weird one

[Lissa]

who's neb

ben

nah, no need for drawing board revisiting yet it's very early still!

yeah it is I just kind of already have too many villagers lmao

i'm not really vibing with anyone's view on the game state so far and even when I do start to lean into a certain realm i regress and hate it. basically a lack of a cohesive feel on the current game state.

hm fair enough ig

re: stett -- tonally she's been quite good aside from a post @ arctic that i really disliked. but actions wise her line here is a bit perplexing. doubly so if she's wolf, so i'm kind of sticking with the idea she's town more often than she's not but I don't really love my position here.

yeah ultimately I think the type of confusing/weird stuff she has done isn't really a kind of weird that makes her a wolf or makes really much of ANY sense for her to actually do as a wolf


it is possible I am giving the waza/stett stuff too much weight re: annika

[ladd]

iyam stuff like "x would be more aggressive/agendaed" as a wolf doesnt really work in org games (not sure how much they work in general tbh) as it would stick out as a sore thumb, esp d1


just a random thought



@Sunbae i am curious about your artic/visor reads if u have time to explain them

to me artic most notable post was this:

meh i'm really not seeing the visor townreads guys >.<

the post about annika felt like verbalized in a way such that he was trying to get townread and he doesn't have other reads with that same level of depth of thought which i feel lends credence to what i'm saying, and people even recognize that his push on stett didn't feel great which is the main thing i'm suspicious of - not just the detached comparison to lissa's game, but more the way he was sort of sewing the seeds there in a shady way

i think he is the wolfiest person amongst active posters. i feel like ender got a tiny bit towny but i'm not sure

but cant really say it made me lean 1 way or the other, just found it interesting

[Visor]

ben



yeah it is I just kind of already have too many villagers lmao



hm fair enough ig



yeah ultimately I think the type of confusing/weird stuff she has done isn't really a kind of weird that makes her a wolf or makes really much of ANY sense for her to actually do as a wolf


it is possible I am giving the waza/stett stuff too much weight re: annika

Are you talking about this post?

[nebjiamn]

just pulled up playerlist to kinda look at the whole picture

** My own editing for formatting emphasis below **


rask ?? no posts,
ladd maybe v?
visor v,
stett v,
sunbae kinda v?,
ben probably v,
maple ????? gth v,
arctic idk kinda light v,
waza v,
taffy v,
ender ?,
annika v,
dya ?? no posts,
pzelda v
** End of my edits **
lol

think I gotta go back to the drawing board somewhere in here

another read list by lissa. she's not at all committed to a v read and seems entirely confused by why she's GtHing maple town but her next post:

well I have come to the realization that I don't actually have any wolf reads

and like

too many v reads for that to like

work

so uh

hm

thread feels really villagery imo

makes me think a wolf hasn't posted yet but that's obv kind of a jank read to make on a number of levels

ladd's thing re: taffy does make me rethink my village read there somewhat

arctic is a weird one

she striaght up TMIs a wolf hasn't posted yet and then espouses how she'd refactor her reads from there:

arctic is town that she is willign to reconsider for light v
taffy is very probable town (at least, she is almost CERTAINLY town from a wolf's POV) that she's happy to reconsider

but not at all maple, who would absolutely fit in with how she's parsing the game in her previous post? if maple's town, why would lissa act so hedgey this entire time only to never bother putting them close to a poe?