Family Guy Mafia - The Teddy Snatcher [Concluded]

[Askthepizzaguy]

The reasoning behind Brian as the snatcher makes sense.

Brian is stewie's arch-rival, first of all, in the show. I am starting to doubt Shlin's story, and I'm starting to believe his seeming cooperation is all to just throw us off the track.

If it's not Seirei and it's not Shlin then I am really stumped. All the evidence points to one or both of them.


Tally:

Quintus-2(Shlin,White_eyes,)
Shlin28- 2(Askthepizzaguy, Yoyoma1910) <---- Please. This one.
El Diablo-1(Chaotix)
ATPG-1(Khaan)
White_eyes-1(El Diablo)

Confirming this tally would be great. I'm seriously exhausted now and I'm just copying and adding new data.

[shlin28]

...

I got the most pointless role ever so if you really want to, lynch away

(Also, would everyone stop saying "I'll show you my role PM!"??? It is banned you know... you guys should all be WoGed! WoGed I say! WOGed! )

Unvote :QCJ
Vote: shlin the Dawg

[White_eyes:D]

Unvote:Quintus Vote:Shlin I obey Master ATPG I think he is guilty after looking over, how the arch enemy of stewie would make sense and all

[Askthepizzaguy]

(Also, would everyone stop saying "I'll show you my role PM!"??? It is banned you know... you guys should all be WoGed! WoGed I say! WOGed! )

As soon as you mentioned that a while back, I PM'ed the host to ask for clarification on the rules.

His rules do say that quoting PM's, forging, and so on are allowed. Then he contradicts himself later on. But it's all been brought to his attention.

And apparently almost everyone misinterpreted his rules if thats what he meant.




Tally:


Shlin28- 4(Askthepizzaguy, Yoyoma1910, Shlin28, WhiteEyes)

El Diablo-1(Chaotix)
ATPG-1(Khaan)
White_eyes-1(El Diablo)

Bold move voting yourself Shlin. I am nervous that I'm wrong about you now. But we have to be sure, and we can't touch my top suspect tonight anyway.

[White_eyes:D]

Damn, good thing I tweaked all my PMs......but still I feel that a couple of WoG's will follow.....
No, he is just mad because we helped eliminating all the suspects by forming a Pro-town block but still we might get whooped from within I hope you kept alot of those roles and there ability's to yourself ATPG.....

[Askthepizzaguy]

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Damn, good thing I tweaked all my PMs......but still I feel that a couple of WoG's will follow.....

I think most everyone in town should be WOG'ed, if that's the case. I tend to think the rules themselves are written in a confusing way, though.

This could be a case of mafia winning due to mass WOG, if the host doesn't see it that way.

Ok, I am tapping out for today.

Maybe I'm wrong about shlin, maybe I'm not. Chicken... makes sense, but Brain makes even more sense. And Meg makes the most sense. Everyone else has done a good job of convincing me of their guilt or innocence, but I cannot be certain. I've been convinced by reasoning to have to change my mind several times this round, I've typed half a book, I've been PM'ing like mad, I've exonerated some, called crusades on others. Town, you've been patient and open-minded, and I think we're closer to cracking the case.

I have to go to sleep now. It's noon, my time, and I've been up since morning yesterday.

Here's hoping we get a townie victory.

[White_eyes:D]

I hope we do win....I get the feeling Tom tucker is the good Doctor......don't ask me why, it's just a hunch......

[naut]

Ok, it's late here and I need to get to bed. But, before I do that I'll cast my vote. Although I hate to bandwagon, the last couple posts are rather convincing at pointing towards Shlin28 aka Brian. It does afterall make sense in terms of the show that Brian would snatch Rupert.

Vote: Shlin28

Night y'all.

Tally:

Shlin28- 5(Askthepizzaguy, Yoyoma1910, Shlin28, WhiteEyes, Rythmic)

El Diablo-1(Chaotix)
ATPG-1(Khaan)
White_eyes-1(El Diablo)

[seireikhaan]

Claimed and uncontested roles:

Alive-

Stewie
Death
Joe
Cleveland
Lois
Herbert
Tom
Quagmire

DEAD-
Peter Griffin
Carter Pewterschmitt

Circle of trust:

Glyphz
Rythmic
WhiteEyes
ATPG
Yoyoma
Beefy187
El Diablo
Chaotix27
YLC- dead
Reenk Roink- dead

Immediate suspects:

Seireikhaan (reasons above)
Quintus.JC (lack of data)
Shlin- lingering doubt. Could be doing an ATPG-style tactic to gain my trust. But thank you!

Circle of Trust? Plus, with Quintus supposedly cleared, what happens when Shlin and I are dead, and the game continues? This whole farce is already unraveling. This game is already over- the mafia are embedded into the "pro-town network".

ATPG, did you really think that nobody could forge a role PM? Its been done plenty of times in the past. Either you are complete scum, or you made a foolhardy assumption, and now the town is completely doomed because of it.

And now you claim you can't even keep basic facts such as my lynch immunity in order. You could't even keep in order that I can't be lynched this round, something you conveniently "remembered" only after people other than myself called you on the inhrent wastefulness of the action. My vote stands.

[Thermal]

i got rid of the slightly mis leading rule near the end, no pms can be shown on this thread, though i will allow pm sharing out side of the thread, though dont make it your reliable source, belive me, it isnt reliable

so many votes are in, ill proceed tomorrow though

[Chaotix]

Unvote, Vote: shlin

Let's see what happens. I still think that we should investigate ATPG and not seireikhaan in order to be absolutely certain he's innocent. For now I trust him, but khaan does raise a point we cannot ignore- especially after the Prometheus.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Then when he's proved innocent we can lynch seirei.

[White_eyes:D]

We had no Pro-town roles on the The Prometheus.....on here we have tons......or maybe not....
but yeah it would be nice to be free of this guy err.....I mean he is firmly town no question about it.......and it does seem like Khaan is some kinda holdout.....why does he not at least trust one person with the PM role?.....I think because he is the SK.....

[seireikhaan]

We had no Pro-town roles on the The Prometheus.....on here we have tons......or maybe not....
but yeah it would be nice to be free of this guy err.....I mean he is firmly town no question about it.......and it does seem like Khaan is some kinda holdout.....why does he not at least trust one person with the PM role?.....I think because he is the SK.....

You apparently do not know my style as maf/sk.

[Thermal]

why does he not at least trust one person with the PM role?

sounds wise to me

[Beefy187]

Unvote, Vote: shlin

Let's see what happens. I still think that we should investigate ATPG and not seireikhaan in order to be absolutely certain he's innocent. For now I trust him, but khaan does raise a point we cannot ignore- especially after the Prometheus.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Then when he's proved innocent we can lynch seirei.

If there is a investigator....

[glyphz]

My guess is Chicken (Quintus?), but arguments against Dog is sound.
If Quintus IS Chicken then...
Vote: Quintus

shlin28 has the most votes anyway...

[shlin28]

Hmmm... now that the Host has spoken regarding da rulez, would ATPG send a copy of his PM to allive people (including me )? Its no biggy, it merely decides whether we would kill you or not

[Beefy187]

Hmmm... now that the Host has spoken regarding da rulez, would ATPG send a copy of his PM to allive people (including me )? Its no biggy, it merely decides whether we would kill you or not

I doubt you will succeed. Mummy got his back

[Askthepizzaguy]

It's hilarious, people are repeating over and over "pms can be forged! pms can be forged!" And they want my PM anyway.

Fine. Sent. I don't know what it proves, and like I said, if you want to investigate me be my guest. You want to lynch me again, be my guest. You want to vigilante me, wait one turn, and then be my guest.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Ask yourselves if what I am saying makes sense, and if it's worth exploring. How you proceed is up to you, but I've already been lynched, and as many have pointed out, it's rare that any host will make a lynchproof mafia, or even a mafia that can survive one lynch.

I remember in Chaotix's lunar whale I only had 1 extra live, I bluffed that I have infinite lives and immune to everything (you led the investigation rememeber). Your not bluffing in this one are you?

No, I am not. But me saying so will not satisfy your doubts.

You have several options, I stated you could lynch me again, you could investigate me, or you could vigilante me after the next voting cycle. I intend to share all my knowledge with the remaining townies then, and give my suggested endgame strategy, by tomorrow day phase. After that, I'm expendable.

What is stronger, because I know I am innocent, is to do none of the above and just trust me, so we can use all of our resources proving innocent those who remain, and lynching suspicious parties and those who don't follow town's strategy. However, I know my reputation is too dirty for you to all implicitly trust me, so I don't expect you will.

I would point out that I have been lynched already, and I should be given the benefit of the doubt FOR NOW, and maybe vigilante me later, because you always have the option to destroy me. I already told you how this is accomplished.

You decide. if you still doubt me, investigate. If no result from the investigator, lynch me AGAIN, which will prove my innocence and I'll still be alive. Or if you absolutely want me dead, just stop defending me tomorrow night, and the mafia might take care of it. And if that's not good enough, you can always vigilante me.

I'd prefer to survive past tonight due to the information I have, and how premature it is to share it. The defender must defend me again tonight, though, or all will be lost. Hopefully the mafia will target me anyway, so they lose a kill.

Is everyone satisfied with my proof, my explanation, and my strategy?

[Quintus.JC]

I do trust ATPG, I'm 95% sure he's innocent and if he does get lynched and remain alive then he definitely is innocent. You have my cooperation.

[Quintus.JC]

I don't think revealing my abilities public would be a good idea, I have a valuable ability and could help the town a lot. It would be a pity if I got killed, I should need a protector to for my safety.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I don't think revealing my abilities public would be a good idea, I have a valuable ability and could help the town a lot. It would be a pity if I got killed, I should need a protector to for my safety.

I don't see why. I know your ability and it's no more useful than some of the others.

However, you would be a great candidate for an investigation, because if we CAN prove your story, I agree you should survive until the endgame.

I won't reveal your ability, except to the ABSOLUTELY confirmed townies, OK? There are some who are already proven innocent due to the host's own writeups. And I will not reveal the sensitive information except to a chosen few, and they can decide if and when to reveal to the rest. We have to be careful with this information.

I am going to give another analysis of everyone's characters, their risk, their worth, and who should be lynched, investigated, and vigilante'd. Stand by.

[shlin28]

The Dawg gives ATPG his Seal of Approval.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Analysis complete.

Should I reveal my results here? Some people have sensitive roles, and even revealing their claimed character could be telling.

Do you just want my suggested course of action, or do you want the full report?

[Chaotix]

Go for the full report.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Go for the full report.

Interesting, you want all the answers... :eyebrow:

Would you agree to be investigated tomorrow night?

[White_eyes:D]

Analysis complete.

Should I reveal my results here? Some people have sensitive roles, and even revealing their claimed character could be telling.

Do you just want my suggested course of action, or do you want the full report?

can't quote role pm's on the forums ATPG...... keep some stuff till the near the end game....with what we have now, we might last enough rounds EVEN if someone has infiltrated us
Khaan and Shlin would be the top targets but like I said go ahead and lynch me pointless....

Edit: don't do a full report....and its not necessary to do a full report yet

[Askthepizzaguy]

can't quote role pm's on the forums ATPG...... keep some stuff till the near the end game....with what we have now, we might last enough rounds EVEN if someone has infiltrated us
Khaan and Shlin would be the top targets but like I said go ahead and lynch me pointless....

I know, no PMs will be revealed here. Just what everyone claimed their character was, what their ability is, etc. Some characters will have their character blanked out and their ability blanked out, to cover for the sensitive roles, and to mix them in with totally worthless roles.

[Chaotix]

Investigation on me is fine, provided we still have an investigator.