Fillet Royale- Large Mafia game [Concluded]

[Reenk Roink]

boudica... I think your gorgeous.. Just look at those scums who doesn't keep up the tally.. Thanks heaps

I also kept the tally! And the tracker! Aren't I gorgeous too?

Anyway:
Unvote: Chaotix27
Vote: Aries

Not lynching someone is a great idea.

Aries: 4 (Andres, CA, Tevash, Reenk Roink)
CA: 5 (YLC, Boudica, Sarathos, Aries, Chaotix)
Andres: 2 (Rythmic, glyphz )

Somebody (not voting for CA) vote Aries now!

[Beefy187]

I also kept the tally! And the tracker! Aren't I gorgeous too?

Anyway:
Unvote: Chaotix27
Vote: Aries

Not lynching someone is a great idea.

Aries: 4 (Andres, CA, Tevash, Reenk Roink)
CA: 5 (YLC, Boudica, Sarathos, Aries, Chaotix)
Andres: 2 (Rythmic, glyphz )

Somebody (not voting for CA) vote Aries now!

Your sexy

[Andres]

I think Aries is a much better lynch candidate then CA.

Also, Reenk Roink, you're not giving much of a reason for voting me.

I believe Andres is very suspicious.

Explain. A vote without proper explanation smells scummy and leads to bandwagoning.

I think there shouldn't be even any suspicions against White Eyes, since he was the first killed. Any orders (if he can make one) would have been canceled. Having 3 (?!) murders should indicate that all(?) killers had acted.

That is simply not true. If you have three mafia families, then it's perfectly possible for one family to kill members of the other family; also, mafia A targeting mafia B does not automatically mean B's kill of that night will be cancelled.

If Beefy uses a "real time" system, like GH does since Mafia VI, then B's kill would still go through, if B got his orders in earlier then A.

There are also plenty of hosts who, in case of mafia A targetting mafia B, would allow the kill of mafia B, no matter what. I'm such a host myself.

When you have more then one mafia family in a game, getting killed by night is not = confirmed innocent.

[CountArach]

No one has provided a reason for me to be lynched yet...

[boudica]

No one has provided a reason for me to be lynched yet...

Hey CA,

AT the point I voted for you, Aries had 4 votes and you, Andres and Chaotix27 had 1 each. I wanted to see how/if people changed their voting if there was another possible 'runner' for lynching. I picked you, as i said at the time, not because I had any conclusive evidence, but purely from intuition/poker face/whatever based on your aggressive work before night 1. The way you were pursuing people as if your innocence was beyond question - and the fact that you changed your vote twice to either tie up the vote/protect Aries is specifically why i picked you instead of Andres or Chaotix27. And look what happened: The voting has gone crazy since then. I don't have any 'evidence' - I don't see how anyone can, but I wouldn't be suprised that if you were lynched we wouldn't be getting 3 murders a night any more :)

[CountArach]

So you believe that, despite all the evidence against Aries, I am a worthy lynch candidate simply based on a hunch?

I picked you, as i said at the time, not because I had any conclusive evidence, but purely from intuition/poker face/whatever based on your aggressive work before night 1.

That is how discussion is sparked and that is what gives us evidence to use against people at a future date. I have played like this in all my recent games.

The way you were pursuing people as if your innocence was beyond question - and the fact that you changed your vote twice to either tie up the vote/protect Aries is specifically why i picked you instead of Andres or Chaotix27.

Two things:
1) Accusing me of defending Aries is a little strange seeing as I am currently voting for him.
2) You still choose to ignore the evidence against Aries - I can understand that he might be your scumbuddy, but I can't see any other possible reasoning.

And look what happened: The voting has gone crazy since then.

Which is just more discussion and hence more evidence. The town rarely has anything more to go by other than posting and voting habits.

I don't have any 'evidence' - I don't see how anyone can

If you check the last few pages you will see the case against Aries. That is how people can get evidence.

[boudica]

well - lots of beef for thought. Now I'm really confused