Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game [Concluded]

[Reenk Roink]

I get the feeling that Aries is just holding off his vote strategically so he can place it when he wants to live...

Vote: 777Ares777

This will force your hand?

Shilin and Quintus are still on my suspect list...

[Sigurd]

I know YLC's main concern with this game was to keep the dead players active.
Apparently our killer is a ghost and taka was saved by someone living. Someone with the power to expel ghosts. I am thinking either a exorcist or something.

Should we start voting for our recent deceased players? If I am not mistaken, the murders started after Beefy was lynched. If there is anyone with a role description that hints to killing dead players or blocking dead players, I am all ears.

vote: Abstain

[Askthepizzaguy]

Current personal theory:

The dead are not all aligned to the same faction, and they can kill one another, but most townies (living people) cannot. Townies, most of us, don't have a role until we die and are converted to bad things. I seem to recall something vaguely like this when YLC mentioned the game to me. But he could have changed it by now, and I cannot recall the details at all.

I also would like to say, I haven't been here, and I am expendable if you want. Like I said before. I will do a thorough analysis of the game and get back to you, as I always do. For now, I won't be responsible for the deaths of any innocent people.

I haven't even read the thread properly yet. Give me time, and I will do a follow-up.

Vote: Abstain.

[Andres]

Fair enough, taka.

I get the feeling that Aries is just holding off his vote strategically so he can place it when he wants to live...

Vote: 777Ares777

What makes you think that?

Unvote : taka ; Vote : Reenk Roink

[Askthepizzaguy]

I do not feel the need to defend anyone, they can do it themselves;

It's possible that those who abstain can monitor the tally and vote in a strategic manner to keep themselves alive. He may have the same theory.

I've been looking over the reasons others have voted. Some fair, early meatballish reasons. I can't say any of them have been compelling enough to warrant my involvement.

suddenly a dark impluse surges through Askthepizzaguy:

You can be mafia if you die. You are always suicidal with your life. You love being dead. Your avatar is a freaking zombie. Get yourself lynched... get yourself lynched...

Dangit! It's my blasted bloodlust again. Sorry, fellows. Although I am presently in a state where I would be happy dead or alive, I swear I'll try to be a good townie.

I'm far too attracted to death for this game.

...Lynch me please? No! No.... stay alive. Stay. Good boy.

[taka]

yes, i probably will need to be lynched soon - however hear my plea

let's not lynch anyone yet

i think it's our evil conscience when lynching that is killing people

looking at write-up lynch 1 about beefy, it seemed like he was possed or something when he "killed himself".

kill 1 also sounded like "someone" was possed by "something" that killed white-eyes, again his conscience or

"Your judgment"

played a role

lynch 2 happened in reenk's room:

A little while later, a scream was heard from Rene's room

attempted kill 2 - read my earlier posts (#169), i dunno whether they are of any use, but it could indicate something :S

i dont really know how to put it altogether, but thats all i can figure out atm from the write-ups

[Askthepizzaguy]

That has precisely the strange twisted logic that YLC would use when designing the game.

Something I would even come up with.




I admire that creative theory. I think it's even better than mine, by a long shot.

You have my attention. IS this your first mafia game? Or are you a veteran hiding behind a tiny post count?

[taka]

That has precisely the strange twisted logic that YLC would use when designing the game.

Something I would even come up with.




I admire that creative theory. I think it's even better than mine, by a long shot.

I dunno really, ive not played a YLC game before, and is the creative bit a good thing or bad?

You have my attention.

good thing or bad??

i kinda get confused what you mean sometimes coz... you post weird lol

IS this your first mafia game? Or are you a veteran hiding behind a tiny post count?

well its not my first game, but i am no where near a vet

[shlin28]

I can absolutely resolutely completely say that I am not mafia, and given my status as the selfless town, you guys should believe me

I really have no idea who to vote for (honest!), and I really don't get Taka and ATPG's conversation right now, so I'll just do it the old school way and look at the post counts...

Out of all players, 'khaan, Tevash and Glyphz has been uncharacteristically quiet.

'khaan has been hosting a game so I would kinda expect that.
Tevash - no idea.
glyphz, he managed to get 16 posts in Andres' game yet only 4 on here? and most of them are voting abstains

However, the general consensous seems to be wait and see, so I will do just that.

Vote: Abstain,

[Thermal]

I appreciate your help andres, but as ATPG said, i must address this personally, firstly apart from the fact im playing with my normal play behavior (which is lynch material in itself?) i want white eyes and reenk roink to elaborate on there points, seeing as there the most pathetic points i've heard in my life.

-reenk, you want me to vote? vote:abstain good enough? or do you just want to kill a townie for nothing
- white eyes, explain how im acting like i did on where? please

[Reenk Roink]

What makes you think that?

Unvote : taka ; Vote : Reenk Roink

I thought it was self evident but quite simply, Ares voted for White_eyes for a terrible basically joke reason (and now he calls our reasons for voting him "pathetic ). Then he goes and FoS's shilin but witholds voting. When someone accuses someone in Mafia games, but witholds a vote, it always seems to me that they are strategically sitting on the fence waiting for their vote to count in a big way. That is however better than switching votes constantly (which you have made a great example of ).

My vote stands.

Now then Andres, maybe YOU should explain your voting. Instead of calling out peoples voting reasons (and using that as a reason to then vote then ), perhaps you should examine your own reasons. After all, you honestly don't seem to have much confidence in them yourself with the multiple changes mmm... Neither does the town.

-reenk, you want me to vote? vote:abstain good enough? or do you just want to kill a townie for nothing

Read your post against WE and then come back to me.

EDIT: Just as I thought. He switches his vote to me to save his skin.

You have a choice town. Vote for me, the one who was roleblocked on the only night a murder took place or vote for Aries, who voted for WE with a BS reason, and now does exactly what I predicted him to do (Reenks Mafia Psychology 232 ).

[Andres]

Vote switching is the perfect tool to make people talk, especially in a round where nobody really is in the lead.

It made taka talk and it made you talk.

I don't know who's the best lynch for today, you or 777Ares777. I would be satisfied with a tie and an extension of this round.

Do you have other suspects besides 777Ares777 or, more in general, do you have some thoughts to share?

[Andres]

You have a choice town. Vote for me, the one who was roleblocked on the only night a murder took place or vote for Aries, who voted for WE with a BS reason, and now does exactly what I predicted him to do (Reenks Mafia Psychology 232 ).

Wait, I admit I haven't been following this game very close. You were roleblocked?

Unvote : Reenk

[Thermal]

Read your post against WE and then come back to me.

EDIT: Just as I thought. He switches his vote to me to save his skin.

my reasons for voting against white eyes were completely valid! and its the people that bandwagonned that were supposedly more suspicious, i tried to come up with a reason and those that mindlessly follow the bandwagon get let off the hook? If i am voting to save myself its only because im fed up of dying on votes as shabby as these seeing as your reason for lynching me is non-existent.
unvote


i couldnt care less, i realise im the easy lynch in any game now, go on, use me as a buffer as usual, like id care

[taka]

guys, the more we lynch, the FASTER we all die (and lose), since we in theory we get a role after we die (which i assume is baddie role).

let's abstain the round, and let the pro-town do their thing with more time.

isnt there a game where we win by not lynching? (not sure, i think its the golden rule?)

i am sure that if we lynch, we're gonna get another killer of some sort afterwards

[ULC]

Just letting the town know, do to RL, voting period is extended till around 9:00 EST.

As always, make sure your plan makes sense, and take into account the character of those playing.

[Chaotix]

Please, like I said before, do not lynch anyone until you have some very strong evidence going. I'm not finding Reenk to look scummy at all right now, and lynching him will be a big mistake for town. A lynch in this game is much more significant than a mafia kill.