Come on Sasski, you gave me 20 miniutes to respond to your post, I wouldn't call that a delay. Response to your orginal accusation.

Now, mafia in those days was much more helter skelter. Lynching was often pretty random. In that game I (as mafia) started a bandwagon to elect GH (godfather) as chief of police. GH voted second. So why pick out Seamus as the "third on the bandwagon" and vote for him? Checking the original game Lord Winter was 4th on the GH bandwagon

I don't buy Lord Winter finding the reenk bandwagon incredibly suspicious because there's no particular reason for the mafia to make a big effort to elect one of their own, and if they had then surely Lord Winter should suspect Reenk and another person from the reenk wagon as well.

You can't write off that bandwagon as evidence just because we're supposedly more experienced. The town has fallen for stuff like that in recent memory. Yes, the use of incredibly may be hyperbole but it still set off an alarm in my head as I was reading it. There's plenty of reasons a mafia would want one of theirs in the CoP position. It gives them influence over the town and an excuse of why they haven't been killed when we get further into the game. Even if Reenk wasn't mafia, bandwagons still are a tool frequently used for the mafia to slip by the town. My choice of Seamus was based off of the common idea that mafia tend to be third on the Bandwagon. His response still hasn't proved his innocence to me either.

Further more none the accusations point towads mafia behavior. At best I'm guilty of poor logic.