Classic Songs of the 13th Century (The REAL Classics)

[Reverend Joe]

Hmm?

What does it suck Father Joe?

Dude... don't make me spell it out for you. I don't feel like getting warning points.

I mean, honestly, I understand how classical music was, well, classical, but it is also an unbelievably arrogant and conceited form of music without any appeal to basic human emotion. It is entirely intellectual and devoid of emotion, utterly obsessed with perfection and willing to trample all over actual musical entertainment to reach this purpose.

Kinda like the late 70's Pink Floyd, actually.

[PershsNhpios]

You are right!

By God sah! I do indeed believe it!

When I play my favourite melody, Die Liebestraum Nummer Drei von Franz Lizt, I sit there at my desk like a stone!

And those toffy, civilised Viennese people - look how stiff they are, walzing strangely about their halls of careless inspiration to Strauss.

I bet they have black holes for hearts!

Would you agree with me when I say that the Opera, " The Elixir of Love", by Donizetti, with it's infamously popular Aria, "Una Furtiva Lagrima", is nothing more than a facade?
I should think that man was incapable of basic emotions like, 'love', when he wrote of the girl whom his character was deeply obsessed with.

And others, like "O Lola", sung by a Grenadier trying to convince his sweetheart of his affections - my, it must be a piece suited only for psychologists and elevators!

People must have been nothing more than dull, greedy politicians and doctors before 1950!

[Evil_Maniac From Mars]

I mean, honestly, I understand how classical music was, well, classical, but it is also an unbelievably arrogant and conceited form of music without any appeal to basic human emotion. It is entirely intellectual and devoid of emotion, utterly obsessed with perfection and willing to trample all over actual musical entertainment to reach this purpose.

Sir, no. Just no.

[Reverend Joe]

...You asked.



Edit: dude, in all seriousness, I really do understand classical music, and I have genuinely loved some in my time. But I am supremely irritated and, frankly, insulted when people try to do what you do, which is to use it to trash modern music by means of condescension. Less-refined and complicated music is just as good; it may not take as much effort to produce, but the main point of music is to excite the soul. And whether this is done so by the perfect classical melody or your average rock song, the music still achieves its purpose. So please, refrain from insulting the music I know and love by implication.

[PershsNhpios]

Asked for what, sah?

For Classical repetoire?

Or for something to suck?

[Reverend Joe]

darnit, you responded too fast... look up, please, look up!

And don't call me sirrah... I know you're thinking it.

[PershsNhpios]

Aha..

Well, Reverend Father, what reason have you to believe that I have not listened to Jimi Hendrix, Creedence Clearwater Revival, Black Sabbath, Count Five, Led Zeppelin, Ray Charles, and Leadbelly for years before turning to Django Reinhardt, Stephane Grappelli, Enrico Caruso and John McCormack?

I hope you do not picture me as a middle-class undergraduate student living in Sydney and taking piano lessons..

Ha ha ha ha! Thank you for explaining yourself.

[Reverend Joe]

Well, Reverend Father, what reason have you to believe that I have not listened to Jimi Hendrix, Creedence Clearwater Revival, Black Sabbath, Count Five, Led Zeppelin, Ray Charles, and Leadbelly for years before turning to Django Reinhardt, Stephane Grappelli, Enrico Caruso and John McCormack?

...Because you listened to them, and I can't understand anyone turning their back on them?

I hope you do not picture me as a middle-class undergraduate student living in Sydney and taking piano lessons..

I don't, man. I just get sensitive about what I perceive as condescension.

Ha ha ha ha! Thank you for explaining yourself.

And thanks for understanding.

Edit: also, don't call me "father." The Reverend thing is a reference to my belonging to an online church, where I am technically considered a reverend, and because I consider myself a holy man; but I do not consider myself above anyone else, which the term "Father" implies. Okay, maybe the reverend thing kinda does too, but it's not as blatant, and it sounds better to me anyway.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

...You asked.



Edit: dude, in all seriousness, I really do understand classical music, and I have genuinely loved some in my time. But I am supremely irritated and, frankly, insulted when people try to do what you do, which is to use it to trash modern music by means of condescension. Less-refined and complicated music is just as good; it may not take as much effort to produce, but the main point of music is to excite the soul. And whether this is done so by the perfect classical melody or your average rock song, the music still achieves its purpose. So please, refrain from insulting the music I know and love by implication.

hmmm

Classic '70's songs (the GENUINE classics)
Read posts: 0
Reverend Joe

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

[Reverend Joe]

[Gregoshi]

Joe, I think Sasaki is mere holding up a mirror in front of you.

[Reverend Joe]

Joe, I think Sasaki is mere holding up a mirror in front of you.

I still don't get it... I've viewed my own thread, and so have quite a few other people...

[Fragony]

I mean, honestly, I understand how classical music was, well, classical, but it is also an unbelievably arrogant and conceited form of music without any appeal to basic human emotion. It is entirely intellectual and devoid of emotion, utterly obsessed with perfection and willing to trample all over actual musical entertainment to reach this purpose.

I actually agree with this. Best 'classical' music, much like art, is from the late 19th century.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qI2-1HzgWs8 <- this is the stuff

[desert]

Hey hey, late 19th century = Romantic. Classical music is Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven, etc.

[I of the Storm]

Does the OP mean something like this

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i0zbF5mlvL8
(French, Thibaut de Champagne, 1st half 13th century)
or this

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B6ue8mAt0_8
(no idea actually. French anyway)
or this

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KNHu-Yb2Dvw
(from the Cantigas de Santa Maria by Alfons X. 'el Sabio' of Castille, mid 13th century)

?

The really good ones aren't on youtube, unfortunately...



Edit: Nevermind. Just figured out that this is most probably more of a joke thread in response to another one.

What an uneducated bunch around here... *sigh*.

[Gregoshi]

Hey I, whether it started as a joke or not, it has some serious overtures. Keep it going.