Day One voting closed at 2-3-09, at 1453 hours.
People active that night and still a suspect:
Shlin28 (most of the night), 777Ares777, Chaotix27, QJC, WhiteEyes, Beefy, LG, Gaius, Andres
TinCow, YLC, Seamus, ATPG, Tevash, Lord Winter, Rythmic
Day Two voting closed 2-5-09 at 1553 hours.
Day Two A voting began at 1729 hours on 2-5-09.
Day Two A voting closed 2-6-09 at 1432 hours.
People active that night and still a suspect:
Shlin28 (again), Ares (2), Gaius (2),
ATPG, Sasaki Kojiro, Lord Winter, Beefy, boudica, LG
Day Three voting began at 1300 hours on 2-7-09
Day three voting closed at 1300 hours on 2-9-09
People active that night and still a suspect:
Chaotix (2), Beefy (2), LG (2), Gaius (3), WhiteEyes (2), Andres (2), QJC (2), Ares (3), Reenk
ATPG, Sasaki Kojiro, Seamus Fermanagh, TinCow, boudica , Jolt, Sigurd, Khaan,
Day Four voting closed at 1400 hours on 2-11-09, pms taken since.
People active that night and still a suspect:
QJC (3), Andres (3), LG (3), glyphz, Shlin28 (3), Ares (4), Gaius (4), White Eyes (3) Beefy (3), Reenk (2)
ATPG, Sasaki, TinCow, YLC, Jolt, boudica, Seamus, Rythmic
Day Five voting closed at 1400 hours on 2-13-09.
Voting re-opened due to tie between ATPG and TS.
People active during that phase and still a suspect:
777Ares777 (5), QJC, (4) WhiteEyes, (4) Reenk (3), Beefy (4), taka, Chaotix (3) Gaius, Shlin28 (4), Andres (4), glyphz (2)
Sasaki, TS, Jolt, Seireikhaan, Ignoramus, Seamus, Lord Winter, YLC, Rythmic
Day Five A ended at 1535.
People active that night and still a suspect:
Shlin28 (5) (most of the night, defending Tevash), Reenk (4), glyphz (3), 777Ares777 (6), WhiteEyes (5), Beefy187 (5), QJC (5)
ATPG, Seireikhaan, Sasaki, TinCow, Seamus, CountArach, YLC, Sigurd,
Post 987-
"ATPG... Tevash investigated YLC on NIGHT 4, AFTER YLC got scummy, so what is this focus on Tevash's inactivity on the 3rd night? His vote for YLC on Day 3 were valid and quite sensible at the time, as he (claimed) he had no results at that moment. His actions afterwards... meh. It does seem odd, but it still does not detract from the fact that as he is a potential detective, he should not be lynched last day phase. Why couldn't YLC be the Godfather anyway? Its a 1 in 28 chance, he is no more likely to not be a Godfather than me... Anyhoo, got to go now, be back in 3-4 hours. I hope you'll still be online then ATPG! "
Focusing on the wrong parts of my analysis. The point was he investigated YLC, cleared him, and promptly and without thinking FoS'ed YLC. THAT MAKES NO SENSE!!!
Post 1009-
"Wow, that was... dramatic. As for Tevash, even I (one of his defenders) would say that he needs to be watched, but certainly not lynched immediately"
Stop defending Tevash! Let Tevash defend Tevash!
Post 1017- (Reenk Roink)
"2 kills. Sasaki among them. Boy were all you lot wrong (points at TinCow and Atpg). Edit: Vote Seamus. Reenktuition says you killed Sasaki as he was one of the innocent looking enemies of you."
Quick to jump to the conclusion that the mafia still have two murders. Votes Seamus (innocent/vigilante, most likely, in my book.)
Post 1018- (Lord Winter)
"Hah, I told you I was innocent."
(15 minutes after the night writeup was done.)
He was clearly lurking in the thread, NOT doing town's work. Then he scummily defends himself, and after only very light questioning by me, runs away like "a chihuahua engulfed in flames" as I said earlier.
Post 1026- (Shlin28) (1455 hours)
"I think the nude unicyclist is either a vig or a SK - looking in the write-up, I would say that Sasaki said something that triggered the said attack. *Digs up Sasaki's posts* Also, Tevash survived, next round - I suggest we wait for his results and his role PM before lynching him."
What were your conclusions that you gained from digging through Sasaki's posts? Again wanting more time before Tevash gets lynched.
Post 1028- (Shlin28) (1505 hours; after 10 whole minutes of analysis)
"My quick perusal of Sasaki's posts revealed nothing that strikes me as the kind that would lead to serial killer kill. I seem to remember one in Capo where a SK will kill someone if they say they are "innocent", could be something similar here? The killer here is clearly deranged and thinks Sasaki will lead to "doom"... exactly the kind of SK who will kill due to a keyword."
Wow. Nothing revealed after a whole ten minute? and that doesn't even include the time it took to type all this deep analysis up. Astonishing. Thought provoking. Invaluable data.
Pardon, I know the sarcasm isn't necessary.
But think about it. Why should we consider any analysis that someone spent no time on, which concluded NOTHING?
Chaotix27- post 1029-
https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showp...postcount=1029
"Well, that was certainly an awesome write-up. I see only one flaw: unicycles don't have handlebars. Joking aside, I do not believe that the unicyclist is out enemy. If you read closely, it seems that he believes he was saving the town by killing Sasaki. Additionally, in the opening write-up, the nude unicyclist was present before the mafia arrived. Thus, I believe the unicyclist is our "special twist"- he is a vigilante. We also have to consider the boom box guy. I believe he is either the investigator or another "twist", perhaps a roleblocker or a protector. Vote: Reenk"
That's likely the correct analysis of the writeup. Seems to me Chaotix isn't trying to color the writeups, and most likely innocent.
777Ares777- post 1039-
https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showp...postcount=1039
"I think the unicyclist is cleared relatively well, so hoping your innocent I suggest killing someone like Taka, lurking, and have been known to win as mafia before whilst doing it.
vote:tevashszat Until we get a role pm + analysis of atpg's evidence against you, You were voting for people you had supposedly cleared of suspicion"
Thank you, Ares. And since you don't WANT the job, you would make an excellent CoP.
Shlin28- 1106
Right. TinCow and I both pointed out that his sudden reversal was made when the fate of Tevash had already been decided. Too late, pal.
Shlin28- 1108
"*sigh* Its a bad omen when the CoP actually does some work..."
No. No shlin. It's a bad omen when the CoP does no work.
Shlin28- 1116
"That clinches it, Sasaki MUST be scum!
That means we only got the Godfather left! YEEHAW!
*Fires pistol into the air*"
I piled a mountainous case at your feet when Tevash was on the block, and even before the detective reveal, you defended him up and down. Then you defended him some more. When what, 5 or so people voted Tevash you suddenly got an epiphany: Tevash must be scum. Then, Sasaki mentions how easy it is to do a detective reveal and post a role pm, and you jump out of your pants to assume that Sasaki was scum.
But only when it is too late, when the course of the game has already been decided, have you decided to follow the flow of the mighty river. You fought tooth and nail for Tevash, and then dropped the pretense when Tevash was doomed. These sudden changes in belief about scummy or innocent, conveniently placed to make you look like you agree with town's position, boggle my mind.
You aren't a townie, shlin28; if you were, these epiphanies would happen at a more logical time, instead of as a virtual bandwagon. You want to keep your buddies alive, admit it.
Sasaki Kojiro- 1214
"The case on shlin is well thought out but I'm not feeling it in my gut...hard to say. The town is kind of hacking away randomly at this point."
Good point, Sasaki. I highly encourage town to think with their gut, not with thoughts and evidence. That will surely cut down on the random hacking.
Sorry, Sasaki, you had that one coming after your brutal dismissal/ignore of me earlier for no reason.
No hard feelings, but you're no townie in my book after your performance since I accused Tevash, and your scummy defenses of shlin28.
Re: The Godfather, Part 3 (IN PLAY)
Originally Posted by Andres
Reply With Quote
....but at least have the stones to show up and help discussion.....Vote:Random lurker glyphz
and we'll laugh about it. And I believe you may owe me an apology for this comment:
Bookmarks