The fight for Inishmore [Concluded]

[Andres]

Is revealing after dead allowed?

[A Very Super Market]

It should be, since in the beginning Padraic sounded like a serial killer.

"Splinter group from the IRA"...

I mean, it should be rather obvious.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Game seems awfully quiet, although that might just be by comparison. Anyway, I don't think reenk is a good choice for today. taka is better.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Sorry about that. I do tend to go off on a tangent. At least this time, it's interesting and relevant.

I disagree on Taka. This is a double-Godfather game. Would you seriously recruit the guy who always gets lynched for being a lurker? You're banking he's a Godfather or another serial killer, I suspect.

I have no qualms with his lynch, but I doubt it would help us. I am more concerned about Seamus at the moment, but I do need to cut him some slack, he is a little busy at the moment.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I'm not worried about who would be recruited. The godfather's are the important people.

VVSpeaking of which, what did you mean earlier about thinking one of the TWC people was the Godfather? I disagree that I have a bitter tone btw...

[ULC]

This is borderline spam, but has the day ended? I mean, discussion seemingly has and this is the day phase. The phase in which the town can question each other, attempt to find the mafioso, and lynch them.

Instead, a few random votes, no one really even trying to dig deep - even Sasaki's bitter tone and biting analytical posts mixed with mild propaganda or mild devilishly leading misinformation designed to further his case is missing (thinking of coining a new term, Sasakism, but am concerned some may take it for a new religion).

Come one town...a little more action, a little more thought.

-Just realized Sasaki posted..still a bit empty Sasaki...

[Askthepizzaguy]

I need to take a break from the Settlement game, myself.

I'd be happy to discuss possible suspects with anyone, please let us get a discussion rolling here too.

I might be juggling a lot but I can handle the discussion if there is one.

[F.C is the bees knees]

unvote taka
vote ATPG
because you are sticking up for taka

[ULC]

unvote taka
vote ATPG
because you are sticking up for taka

TRUE! He must be mafia, just like Reenk stuck up for Beefy in the Godfather and...oh wait, Reenk wasn't mafia at all, silly me.

I'm after Seamus and Sasaki right now, Sasaki especially. Neither have given anything constructive(Seamus) or sarcastic(Sasaki) in the way of at least attempting to help the town.

Since your own, I'd like you to try to explain how you have made a case yet for someones throat Sasaki.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Instead of voting for someone who always lurks, how about someone who usually doesn't lurk but is doing just that in this game?

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Accusing me of sarcasm? Yeah, real original.

[F.C is the bees knees]

TRUE! He must be mafia, just like Reenk stuck up for Beefy in the Godfather and...oh wait, Reenk wasn't mafia at all, silly me.

I'm after Seamus and Sasaki right now, Sasaki especially. Neither have given anything constructive(Seamus) or sarcastic(Sasaki) in the way of at least attempting to help the town.

Since your own, I'd like you to try to explain how you have made a case yet for someones throat Sasaki.

Hush little boy.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I knew it!



Hah, Who's making groceries now!

Just got this reference, it's to super market? Why do you say you knew it?

***


And to answer you seriously ylc, there isn't much to go on. Compare to the first day of gf3.

[ULC]

And to answer you seriously ylc, there isn't much to go on. Compare to the first day of gf3.

True, but we also lost GF3, not from the town trying though

We really have to let go to an extent our feelings towards another player ingame, otherwise we become biased and make poor descsions. However, I feel your doing what might be considered not actually answering my full question - I asked why haven't you tried to make a case, but you ignored that. Your the type of person Sasaki to make an entire case form one post, yet you haven't.

I have time to burn yet, so I'm waiting.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Defending Taka?

I am offering an opinion that he'd be an abysmal choice as a henchman this game due to the fact that he is more of a lurker than a contributor and we've been on an anti-lurker bender for several games in a row now, and in the last one, all of the mafia were contributors or at the very least, semi-active. If giving reasoning behind why I am not suspect of Taka over anyone else yet is a defense, then I differ with you on the definition of defense. If there is a case to be made against Taka, I am listening, and I'll vote for him if I see something compelling.

There is always the case to be made that perhaps Taka might be an interesting, riskier choice, seeing as how we now have people not voting for the lurkers as a backlash from Godfather III.

[F.C is the bees knees]

I'm watching you

[Askthepizzaguy]

Stalker.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

(in-joke... I told him I was a fan, and that I wondered why he hadn't contributed more at the Org, seeing as he is at TWC, and he called me a stalker)

[F.C is the bees knees]

Stalker.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

(in-joke... I told him I was a fan, and that I wondered why he hadn't contributed more at the Org, seeing as he is at TWC, and he called me a stalker)

[Sasaki Kojiro]

True, but we also lost GF3, not from the town trying though

We won gf3

We really have to let go to an extent our feelings towards another player ingame, otherwise we become biased and make poor descsions. However, I feel your doing what might be considered not actually answering my full question - I asked why haven't you tried to make a case, but you ignored that. Your the type of person Sasaki to make an entire case form one post, yet you haven't.

I have time to burn yet, so I'm waiting.[/QUOTE]


In gf3 I questioned LW and then attacked him the next day because I was about to be lynched. After that we had the missed kill...and I advocated we lynch a lurker. That's why I suggested you compare to godfather 3. in the end of that game I stated that, as holmes would say, it's a capital mistake to over-theorize when you don't have enough information. I've also never been someone who goes for the same style every game.

The only people who've tweaked my interest this game are yoyoma and reenk. I've pushed for the lynches of pizza and taka because they fit the "good lynch" strategy that I think is good to use in the early game. I hope that answers your questions.

edit: and yes, the fake ending from gf3 still haunts my memory...

[Diana Abnoba]

Ok I was a little confused at the start because of the dual names. I didn't get that AVSM was Padraic right away, I think I am up to speed now. I would prefer to abstain for now because we need to start a more focused discussion to find real clues of players identities.

[ULC]

Yes, I was quietly informed of the true resolution of GF3 after I opened my mouth and in a rage shoved both feet in and a bit of leg.

You answered my questions, but my eye is still upon you Sasaki, thus making you the most trusted person ingame to me for now. Now, back to some discussion...

Explain how Yoyoma being guilty also makes Reenk guilty. Also, explain your position on taka's lurking when he currently holds more posts then several other more nonresponsive players.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I'm giving Seamus until next round to respond. He honestly hasn't been busy with the Settlement game up until this point, kind of lurking there, and I did most of the questioning I believe.

edit: (didn't finish my thought) but now he is really really swamped. As such;

unvote: Seamus
vote: Andres

Surely now that you've been revealed as a scum in the other game, you will be able to contribute more here.

[El Diablo]

I am just getting used to this godfather thing - cutting the head of the snake and all (get rid of the rest of the mafioso group). If I was one I would try and keep my head down (but that is probably a poor idea as..)

I am suspicious of those defending (yes you did ATPG - no real reasoning just a "hunch").

Vote Taka - Maynot be the Godfather but will as previously noted prevent lurking.

Brendan left his card, and on it said Three Blind Mice.

Any idea on this people?

ED

[Sasaki Kojiro]

fos:El Diablo

[Askthepizzaguy]

badly needed Tally:

yoyoma1910: 2 (Reenk Roink, White_Eyes)
Reenk Roink: 4 (boudica, FactionHeir, yoyoma1910, Greyblades)
Seamus: 2 (Andres, YLC)
Taka: 3 (Seamus, Sasaki, El Diablo)
Ares: 1 (GH)
Sasaki: 1 (Seireikhaan)
Seireikhaan: 1 (shlin28)
Askthepizzaguy: 1 (F.C)
Andres: 1 (Askthepizzaguy)

Abstain: Ituralde

Seems I've been neglecting my duties.

Can someone re-check? I don't want my tally to be the only one, and also have it with errors.

[gaelic cowboy]

Unvote YLC:
Vote: Taka

Apparently this lurking caic is suspisious so I will give in to peer pressure.

[Askthepizzaguy]

pls bold all votes in proper format, GC: (see spoiler)

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

vote: YLC

This is not a vote change.

[Reenk Roink]

Unvote: Yoyoma
Vote: taka

[Askthepizzaguy]

Reenk Roink: 4 (boudica, FactionHeir, yoyoma1910, Greyblades)
Taka: 4 (Seamus, Sasaki, El Diablo, Reenk Roink)
Seamus: 2 (Andres, YLC)
Ares: 1 (GH)
Sasaki: 1 (Seireikhaan)
Seireikhaan: 1 (shlin28)
Askthepizzaguy: 1 (F.C)
Andres: 1 (Askthepizzaguy)
yoyoma1910: 1 (White_Eyes)
YLC: 1 (Gaelic Cowboy)

Abstain: Ituralde, Diana Abnoba

Did I miss your unvote, Reenk?

[GeneralHankerchief]